I did what I could with this request, I got a little stuck on it. I apologize.
Ever since that night the relationship between Nitori and Rin had completely changed. They were much closer to each other, in every sense of the word. Many times they would just cuddle, sometimes even go out in non-official dates, and sometimes they would just fuck all night. They had tried all kinds of stuff in bed, some more enjoyable than others.
This particular time Nitori found himself in a room full of guys. He looked around and recognized all of them, although he wasn't able to recall the name of some.
"A-aren't you the guys from Iwatobi?" Nitori was surprised; he had followed Rin into the room, not really knowing what it was that Rin wished to do with him. The elder had simply told him that he wanted to talk to him somewhere not in their room. They had both walked out of school into the city and into someone's home. Nitori had assumed it was Rin's but he found himself in a small one person condo and with only the bedroom light on.
"This is my house, what did you expect?" The boy's voice was cold and seemed unamused.
"Right! You are Nanase-chan right?" He recognized the older boy from the pictures that Rin kept and showed Nitori once every blue moon. He kept looking around and tried recalling everyone else's names.
"You must be Tachibana-chan, I already know Hazuki-chan, and…" he laid his eyes upon the last member, the one who had replaced Rin on the team. "Sorry! I don't think I remember your name!"
"My name is Rei Ryugazaki, nice to meet you Nitori-chan-san." He said while he pushed up his red framed glasses.
"Nice to meet you Ryugazaki-chan." He hands shook as he felt nervousness from the awkward situation. "So, why am I here?" A tall shadow loomed over him. The young boy began turning when suddenly his arms were seized and he felt rope on his wrist. He looked over his shoulder and saw Rin, who had a smirk drawn across his face. The red haired bent down and whispered into the younger's ear.
"I did tell you that I was gonna pass you around some day right? That I was going to call all of the Iwatobi and pass you around so they could see what a little slut you are." He moved his eyes around the other guys who had "agreed" to be there. In other words Rin either paid them or made them an offer they couldn't refuse, Haruka was to have a life time supply of mackerel on the Matsuoka family.
"Y-you were serious?" Nitori couldn't believe what he was hearing, his tried retreating his arms but the rope burned against his skin. "S-senpai! W-we can't do this!"
"Hm, and why not? I though you wanted this." The elder looked a little confused.
"N-no it's not that I don't," he cleared his throat and whispered to Rin, "It's not that I don't want to do this I just d-didn't think you would actually do it!"
"And why is that? I told you I would." The smiled returned to Rin's face as he tightened the rope.
"But how did you-"his voice was cut off when Rin took out a small pocket knife and put it to his collar.
"I forgot to take your shirt off first; I hope this isn't your favorite." He brought the knife down a cut through the fabric opening the shirt in half.
"H-hey! I liked that shirt senpai!" He looked down a little disappointed.
"Too bad." Rin placed the blade under Nitori's neck and raised it up, forcing the smaller boy to lift his head. They looked at each other for a couple of seconds, Nitori tried to figure out what Rin was thinking. The elder bent down and placed his lips against the other.
At first the kiss was soft and sweet but it slowly increased into an intense, deep kiss craving for more. Rin forced Nitori's lips opened and invaded his mouth, playing with the other's tongue. The other swimmers watched impatiently, finally Haruka moved towards the two and pulled Rin away.
"I thought we were sharing." Haruka bent down towards the younger's neck, sucking and slightly biting on his delicate skin. A mark built up as his tongue brushed over Nitori's skin and sucked. Makoto walked toward the others slowly, red building up on his cheeks.
"I guess I'll join in." He whispered as he avoided everyone else's looks. Makoto walked around patted Nitori in the back and spoke, "Hey could you maybe get on your knees?" He flashed a smiled. As Nitori was about to respond, still a little distracted by Haru's nibbles, Rin interrupted and threw something Makoto's way.
"No need to ask, just use this." Makoto grabbed what was thrown to him, Nitori wasn't able to see due to Haruka eyes looking into his own, as if he had some kind of power that prevented Nitori from looking away.
"Y-you're scaring me Nanase-san!" The young boy finally lost eye contact. He felt a sudden coldness against his neck, rattling of a metal chain was heard behind him.
"Get down then Nitori, if you can." Makoto pulled from the chain a little, making Nitori feel the coldness of the leather collar on his neck.
"Y-yes." Nitori stood on his knees and looked up the older boys surrounding him. Haruka was beginning to lower his pants when Rin interrupted.
"You can start from here Nitori," Rin moved Haruka out of the way and put down his own pants, exposing his underwear; "the others can use you after." He grabbed Nitori's silver hair and pulled the boy up and towards his crotch. "Come on you little whore." Rin smirked.
Nitori blushed and closed his eyes. He placed his mouth on Rin's crotch and felt his length through the fabric. He moved his lips applying pressure the best he could with only his mouth.
Makoto took the opportunity and sent kissed down the boy's spine. The soft kisses gave Nitori a warm sensation. He could feel Makoto's tongue down his spine and Rin's member harden under his mouth. Rin pulled Nitori's hair and pulled down his underwear, "Get to work cutie." He gave a fast smile as Nitori teased the hard dick with his small tongue.
Someone pushed Rin away, "Let me join in!" Nagisa stumbled, completely naked. "Can you please touch me Nitori!? Who cares about Rin-san, he's so blunt!" Nitori removed his mouth from Rin's body, he moved his mouth to Nagisa's much smaller member.
Meanwhile Makoto slowly covered the silver haired boy's back in soft kisses and lowered the boy's sweat pants; the chain was still in his hands. He hesitated for a moment but quickly moved the boys cheek out of the way and placed his mouth against Nitori's entrance and sucked. He pulled the chain back a little, wanting to hear Nitori's muffle gasps.
Nitori's sounds went straight to Makoto's crotch as he moved his tongue. Rin, desperate for friction, handed Makoto the blade that he had cut through Nitori's shirt with. "We'll have to cut the rope after all." Makoto did as he was told, and Nitori's hands were freed. Rin took one of the boy's wrists and grabbed a bottle of lube from the floor, putting some one Nitori's palm.
"Come on you know you want me." He whispered as he moved the smaller boy's hand to his erection. Nagisa's was back into Nitori's mouth and he could feel the vibrations from the silver haired moans coming from his throat. Finally Rei joined in for the first time. He walked towards the kneeled down boy and looked away. Without a word Rei lowered his pants and underwear and exposed his own dick. Nitori showed his palm to Rin, demanding lube, and began touching Rei, who was blushing more than any other. Haru looked from a side.
Makoto felt the pit in his stomach but resisted the urge of doing anything too forward. He moved his hand around the boy's waist and demanded lube from Rin, who now seemed to be the lube dispenser.
Nitori switched and placed his mouth around Rei's erection. His hands worked with different pressures on Rin and Nagisa. Haruka kept looking from a side, his erection was clear but he seemed to be looking at Makoto with lustful eyes. Rei blushed as he felt the warm mouth around his dick and moaned quietly.
From behind, Makoto slowly slit one finger into Nitori's entrance, the silver haired boy moaned with pleasure, his mouth still filled with Rei's hard dick. Haru still looked at Makoto from a distance away, as if waiting for something to happen. Another finger slipped into Nitori, this time the moan was loud and clear, Rei felt Nitori's mouth tighten around his member. Nagisa moved his throbbing dick from Nitori and moved around to Makoto who after a small exchange of words gave him the chain that led to Nitori's collar. Nagisa forcefully pulled, leading Nitori towards himself and leaving the others behind.
"I never agreed to share. I said I would be here for Rin-san's sake... and that penguin stuffed animal he bribed me with." Nagisa looked down at Nitori who looked incredibly innocent with the collar around his neck and his big blue eyes looking at the other. "My, you make such a cute pet!" A smirked appeared on the blond's face. He lowered himself to Nitroi''s height, placing his knees on the ground and moved closer to him. Nagisa's tongue wondered around Nitori's neck going over Haru's bites as their hard dicks rubbed against each other.
The group of taller guys looked baffled, everyone but Rei who was used to seeing Nagisa with such an aggressive attitude. Rei walked towards where the two bodies were enjoying themselves and took the chain from Nagisa's hand. "You might have not agreed to share but everyone else did, so you're going to have to adjust to the majority."
"Eeehh? I don't want to! He's so cute!" Rei and Nagisa argued as Rin approached them and placed himself behind Nitori, who was observing the argument. Rin placed his hands on Nitori's hips, the younger boy jumped, surprised to see his lover prepare to enter him.
"Wait a minute Matsuoka-senpai! Shouldn't we do something about-" His voice was cut off by a squeak that silenced the whole room. Rin slowly pushed inside of Nitori, feeling warmth all around his cock. The other four boys observed as Rin whispered into the other's ear. No one could make out his words besides the silver haired boy who nodded with an expression of pain on his face. Rin began thrusting and the smaller boy groaned quietly, still feeling the pain.
Haru finally walked towards the arguing couple and pushed Rei out of the way. He also kneeled down, and grabbed Nitori's arms placing them on his shoulders. Nitori's faced showed both pain and pleasure as his lover thrust into him. Haru moved closer to Nitori until the boy was sandwiched between Rin's sweaty body and Haruka's strong muscles. He moved his hand onto their members and began jerking them together. Nitori gasped for air as the pain from behind was replaced by pleasure and Hatuka's rough palm. The younger clawed on Haru's back, leaving red marks all over his flawless skin.
Nagisa observed from a side, next to Rei. He moved closer to the three boys and lifted Nitori's head with the chain, forcing the other to wrap his mouth around his hard cock as the blond whispered to himself, "I'm so close, I'm gonna come." Nitori was at his limit as well, taking pleasure from all sides wasn't something he was used to.
Quickly Rei and Makoto joined in and felt as Nitori's soft hands move along their throbbing boners. Rin, who hadn't said anything, was the first to come inside of Nitori with a loud grunt of pleasure. He moved himself away allowing Makoto to move from Nitori's hands to his ass, where he quickly entered him as well.
Nitori felt Makoto's dick inside of him. It was longer than Rin's but thinner, he though he enjoyed Rin better. Makoto came not long after, only thrusting two times or so, but this time he pulled out andcame all over Nitori's back, leaving a splatter of white streaks. Makoto came with a loud moan and with a strong bite on Nitori's neck, strong enough to make the boy cry out in pain and bleed from the spot. After that Nitori wasn't able to resist anymore, Nagisa joined, and they both came at the same time with loud moans, much louder than the other two. The silver haired boy was exhausted, yet Haru kept pumping their members together.
Rei took Nitori's mouth and came inside the small space. Nitori gagged, but he swallowed all that he could, feeling the acidic taste of Rei's cum on his tongue. Only Haruka was left, he pumped faster and stronger as Nitori's moans increased intensity. Finally his throbbing cock released and painted Nitori's chest with his seed. Haruka quickly got on his feet and walked to the door, "I'll be taking a shower now." He walked out and proceeded to the bathroom.
"And Nagisa told me I was blunt." Rin protested as he walked towards Nitori, and picked him up from the floor. "You must be tired."
Nitori closed his eyes and nodded. "Oi, don't fall asleep on me, you need to get all cleaned up." Rin walked out after Haru.
Nagisa broke the silence in the room once again, "Is Haru-san always like that?" He asked Makoto.
"How would I know!?" Makoto was caught by surprised. They all walked out of the room and cramped into the shower, trying to get clean.
Requested by anon, and writegirl-11