Chapter 2

TUESDAY

Spencer was in her dorm room reading a book. She heard the door opened, and Toby stepped in. She was actually quite happy to see him, even though he was most likely here to see Abby. She would never admit that she was happy to see him, but she was. His presence was actually... enjoyable. And she rarely found ANYONE'S presence enjoyable.

"Toby?" She tried not to smile. "Abby's not here. She's with Aria again."

He smiled at her and quietly said, "Actually, I didn't come here to see Abby. I came here to see you, Spencer."

Her book nearly fell out of her hands? It felt a little weird that one of her best friend's boyfriends came to see HER and not his own girlfriend.

"Wh-what?" She gasped.

"I don't know. Abby's been pissing me off lately." Toby said, sighing. He sat down extremely close to her on her bed. "But I had a lot of fun with you yesterday. It's strange that I had more fun with with stubborn Hastings than my own girlfriend, huh?"

"It is," she chuckled, nodding her head in agreement. "You're not just saying that you had fun because we kissed...are you?"

"As much fun as it was to kiss you behind Abby's back: no. Arguing was fun. With Abby. I feel like it's just...too cliché and cheesy. With you, it's arguing... and I like that, it's fun. I like it when a girl fights back, and doesn't just agree with everything I say." He quietly said, his hand sliding across Spencer's thigh, and his hot breath blowing against her.

She was trying not to get aroused by the way she touched her, but she couldn't help it. His tone was so suggestive to her, and she didn't know if it was intentional or not. She fell back on the bed, getting out of his reach, teasing him.

Smirking, she huskily said, "And I like it when a guy can man up and take control himself..."

Before she knew it, he was hovering on top of her, nearly kissing her.

Quickly realizing that what she was doing was wrong, she shoved Toby off of her body.

"You're an ass, you know. I can't believe I almost fell for that. Not only are you dating someone, but also I told you that I'm never having sex with you!" She yelled, turning away from him.

Sighing, he said, "Sometimes I feel like I asked the wrong girl out. I feel stupid for trying to do something like that with you, but I still feel like dating Abby is a huge mistake."

"Mistake or not... This can never happen." She shook her head. "It's so incredibly wrong, ok? We can't be starting something that we can't finish."

"Spencer, I'm going to break up with Abby." He announced.

She looked at him wide-eyed, "You can't do that. Even if you broke up with her, I'm not going to date you! Not only would it rift my friendship with Abby, but I just can't see myself going out with you, Toby."

"That doesn't mean I don't still want to break up with her," he said, slightly hurt.

"Look, I think you should go." She told him, pointing at the door.

He sighed. He should have known that stubborn Hastings was too stubborn to want to date him. He should have kept his feelings bottled up, anyways. There was NOTHING between Spencer and him! It was all in his head. It was just a small flirt, and nothing more... He loved Abby, right?

"You're right," he nodded. "This was dumb of me. I'm leaving. Good night, Spencer. Tell me if Abby comes back from wherever she is."

When he headed back to his dorm room, all he could think about was Spencer. Was everything in his head? He should have known that he and her were just incompatible. They'd probably never EVER end up going out, anyways. Jake turned out the lights in their dorm room, and the college boys fell asleep quickly.

"This is insane," she whispered, moaning as he kissed down her neck. "It's sooo insane, Toby. But damn, you really dodged a bullet by breaking up with Abby."

He smiled as he continued kissing her neck.

"I know I did, Spencer." He said, pulling back from her neck. "It was totally worth going through all the trouble of breaking up with Abby to be with you, you know. I wouldn't regret breaking up with her at all. And I'll never regret tonight, either."

"Kiss me again!" She pleaded, pulling him in for another long and passionate kiss.

He threw his shirt over his head, only pulling back from the kiss for a second. She threw her tank top over her head, and it joined Toby's shirt on the floor. Once her shirt was removed, her bra-cradled breasts were revealed. He was eager to get that black bra off of her. She was just so gorgeous...

Sweat was trickling down his chest as he became aroused by the sight he saw. Abby always tried to seduce him into sex, but he never wanted to do it with her. When she tried to seduce him, it was never as amazing as the way Spencer did. She always made it so easy to get turned on. He never had sex with Abby, and he wasn't going to, now that he had broken up with her and had a girl that turned him on every second of the day.

He was just about to unhook that bra, and see what sexiness was under it...

"Dude!" Jake yelled, annoying by his roommate. "Stop moaning in your sleep! Are you really having a wet dream about Abby? You're the one who always says you're not in the mood to do it with HER!"

Toby was suddenly woken up by Jake RIGHT when his sexual fantasy was getting to the good part! He was quite disappointed that it wasn't real. He should have known that the only way he'd ever have sex with Spencer was in his own dreams...

"No, I wasn't dreaming about Abby. Jake, if I tell you something, will you swear not to tell anyone else?" Toby asked, sighing.

"Of course, Cavanaugh." Jake said, nodding. He turned the lights on, and looked at his conflicted looking friend / roommate. "You can tell me anything, man."

"I was having a... fantasy... about a girl... but not just any girl. I was having a fantasy about one of Abby's best friends: Spencer Hastings." Toby confessed.

"Seriously!? She's stubborn, but MAN, she's hot." Jake grinned. "Her friend Aria is even hotter."

"Aria...? Why are we talking about Aria Montgomery!?" Toby furrowed his eyebrows. "Jake, what do I do? I'm having all these fantasies about Spencer, but I'm supposed to be in love with Abby!"

"Get her drunk and have sex with her at my party," Jake suggested, laughing mildly.

Toby shot his roommate a death glare and said, "REALLY, Jake!?"

"I don't know what to tell you, man!" Jake sighed. "I'm no love expert, but I would go with the one you really love."

"I barely know Spencer, though." Toby said.

"Then Abby?" Jake suggested.

"But I don't think I really love Abby!" Toby argued.

"Dude, you know what choice you want. You want my decision to be Spencer, because YOU'RE leaning towards her. You already have your mind made up, you're just scared of what Abby's gonna think." Jake read him like an open book. "Good night, Cavanaugh."

Jake turned the lights off before trying to fall back asleep.

Meanwhile, Toby's little wet fantasy continued.

He knew who he really wanted.

But he didn't know how to handle this.

I know it's short. BUT PLEASE READ THIS!

Do you guys want Aria to be with Ezra or Jake? It's just a minor question, but I wanted her to be with Jake... I don't know you guys would like that, though...

But thanks for the reviews! You guys are awesome.