Anyone who wanted more, well you're in luck because I've decided to turn this into a multi-chapter complete with plot and everything! lol Since I was so inspired I wrote up this chapter for you all.
And again, I do not condone teacher/student relations. This is a work of fantasy between fictional characters (which I do not own because I don't own anything) and nothing more. :) Enjoy!
They've been 'studying' together for just over a week now and so far it seems like no one has caught on. No one looked at Finn or Rachel strangely, no one ever caught the flirty glances or innuendoes they used with each other. In fact, Rachel was such a good actress that for an entire period the second day of their affair Finn thought she had changed her mind about being with him until he got a text from her letting him know that the only reason she had declined 'extra help on her essay' after school was because Kurt had been around. Kurt knew that she had already finished the latest essay they had been assigned and would have grown suspicious if she had agreed.
It didn't stop her from showing up at Finn's apartment after glee that day however...and every week day since their first time. If Finn could he would take her on the weekend too but as her dads were home, they would figure out something was up. But now it was their second Friday in Finn's bedroom and he had just finished up giving Rachel her third orgasm of the day when he made the mistake of saying four words that could completely change everything.
"We should go out." Rachel froze underneath him and he could instantly tell he'd said the wrong thing. "I mean, if you want to. We don't have to. It's just, usually when I have this much sex with a woman we've already gotten past the first date, ya know?"
Rachel relaxed a little and licked her lips before speaking. "Finn, I would love to go out with you," his face brightened at her words, "but," but there was always a but, "I'm your student and everyone in this town knows it. I may be 18 but I know McKinley would still fire you if they found out we were together and I don't want to jeopardize your career any more than I already have. Maybe after graduation. People would still talk I'm sure but we wouldn't have to hide then and you wouldn't get in trouble." She toyed with his hair as she shattered his idea.
He gave her a sad half-smile. "Yeah, it was a stupid idea. Sorry, I should think before I talk." Finn looked away from her.
Rachel turned his face back to stare into his eyes. "It wasn't stupid, Finn. Believe me, I would love to be able to run around Lima screaming 'Finn Hudson is my boyfriend' at the top of my lungs because I'm just so happy to be with you, but I'm trying to think about this realistically. A date right now isn't realistic."
Finn smiled bigger. "I'm your boyfriend?"
Rachel blushed and bit her lip. "If you'd like to be. I know I can't be seen in public with you and we can't speak openly about our relationship to anyone but I only want to be with you and I hope you feel the same way."
"I do. I just want to be with you. I'd love to be your boyfriend." Rachel smiled the biggest and brightest smile he'd ever seen and he could feel his heart melt completely.
"Finn Hudson, I am so proud to call you my boyfriend. You have no idea." She pulled his head down and kissed him deeply, smiles building on both of their faces.
This new label on what they were begged yet another question. "What are you doing for Valentine's Day?" he asked when their kiss broke.
Rachel contemplated the day which was next Tuesday. "I have glee rehearsal but other than that it's just another day."
"I know we can't go out, but would you like to come over to celebrate?" Finn asked sheepishly.
Rachel grinned broadly. "Like I have every other day since we started?"
"Plus, homemade dinner." He cocked his eyebrow playfully at her. "Believe it or not, I can cook. Maybe not 5-star chef quality but enough that my mom hasn't made me dinner since I was eighteen. Well, other than during holidays. I know you're vegan so I can make...something."
"I'd like that. Of course I'll come over to celebrate with you." She pulled Finn's face down to hers and began kissing him deeply again. Rachel could feel Finn's fingers roaming over her body and his hardening erection against her inner thigh.
"Can we go for four?" he mumbled against her lips.
"Uh huh," she whined, nodding her head slightly until she could feel his hardness slide into her. Her breath hitched and her head flew back.
Finn found a steady rhythm as he pumped in and out of her, eliciting delicious moans which were making it hard for him to keep from coming on the spot. It was a little crazy to him how strongly he felt for Rachel. He wasn't a man-whore but he wasn't a saintly virgin either. Finn had had his share of relationships in the past and while he had feelings for those women they were nowhere on the level of what he felt for the tiny beauty writhing around under him, scraping her nails down his back and screaming out his name and how he made her feel 'so good'. No, Rachel was something else entirely which was unfortunate for only one reason, until June she would be his student.
Finn still couldn't wrap his mind around what he had done. He knew on the surface it was wrong and that he could get into serious trouble but when he was with Rachel, none of that mattered. She didn't seem like a teenager and he didn't feel like an adult. He just hoped once graduation rolled around that they would be able to be together in every way. Finn hated not being able to be seen in public with her, not being able to kiss her or hold her hand whenever he wanted, being called Mr. Hudson when he wanted her to call him Finn. Graduation was not coming fast enough.
But he could worry about that later. For now, he would take being with her like this, making love in his bed whenever possible, watching movies and eating Chinese food, just learning little things about each other. Until graduation that would be enough.
"Oh God, F-f-finn, you feel s-so goooood," she moaned out as he brushed against her g-spot repeatedly.
"You're amazing," he grunted out when she clenched tightly around him. His right hand found her breast and squeezed while his left moved to her back to cradle her against him. Then she unexpectedly flipped them over so she was now on top.
Rachel loved to ride Finn and watch his reaction to everything she did. He actually loved when she was on top unlike Jesse who had always wanted to have sex the same way, him on top in missionary while she just lied there like a blowup doll. With Finn, sex was engaging and almost a sport. They continuously tried to outdo themselves and find new and interesting ways to get it on. Rachel often wondered if that was the difference between a boy and a man or if Finn was just the best lover ever despite age. It was probably a combination of both.
"G'uh, baby, you're so hot," Finn groaned as he felt her sink down on him again, her hands splayed out over his lower abdomen for support. He moved her legs so her feet were by his head and gripped her thighs while she moved her body back and forth. He widened her thighs and licked his lips at the sight of her body engulfing his dick again and again.
She let out a deep grunt with her last movement and began to orgasm for the fourth time that afternoon. She clutched Finn's body firmly; afraid she would lose herself so much she might float away. If she had known that sex with Finn would lead to such a state of joyous intoxication, she would have made her feelings for him known much sooner.
Her release triggered Finn's and he came inside her making that puckered 'O' she loved so much. He trembled under her while his body came down from the natural high and Rachel lifted herself off him. They were both a mess and she needed a shower before she could go home to her dads but first they needed another cuddle period.
"I love when you come inside me," Rachel stated as she folded herself into Finn. He wrapped his arms around her and kissed her temple. "I feel so much more connected to you then."
"I like it too. Makes things a bit messier but I like gettin' you dirty." They both chuckled until Rachel sighed.
"Speaking of dirty I should get cleaned up and go home. My dads will be home soon."
Finn held her tighter and whined. "Not yet. What time is it?" He looked over at his clock and saw that it was nearing 6:30 pm. "Damn. I hate having to share you."
Rachel leaned up and pecked his lips, rubbing her nose against his and stroking his cheek. "It's only until Monday. Maybe if we both get in to school a little early we could fit in some under-the-desk fellatio," she replied flirtatiously. At her words she could feel Finn getting hard again.
"Let's agree on seven and I can bend you over my desk too." He gripped her ass tightly forcing a little squeal from her.
She licked her lips and stared at him with sultry eyes. "Can you call me a bad girl for forgetting my homework and spank me with your ruler too?"
Finn's eyes widened significantly. "You're a little kinky girl, aren't you?" He smiled broadly while Rachel blushed and tried to cover her face in minor embarrassment.
"I'm sorry, that was too much. I shouldn't-"
"Rach, I think it's so hot. Don't be embarrassed." He pulled her hand from her face and kissed her fingertips. "I will do anything you're comfortable with and I'll never push you to do something you aren't comfortable with."
"You're the best." Rachel leaned forward to capture his lips again. "I wish I could take back my first time and save it for you. You're perfect."
Finn smirked. "I'm not."
"Yes, you are. You're a gentleman and you actually care about people and you're passionate and kind. Not to mention your sexual prowess. You are a very amiable lover."
"Well I always aim to please." Rachel smiled at him. Finn looked contemplative for a moment.
"What?" Rachel asked, wondering what his expression could mean.
"It's nothing; we can talk about it later. You have to get home." Finn pulled away from Rachel and sat up, swinging his legs over the side of the bed to pick up his boxers.
Now Rachel was really concerned. She moved closer to Finn and placed her chin on his shoulder, sliding her hands from his back to his front. Tenderly, Rachel kissed his shoulder and pressed her bare chest against his warm skin. "We can talk about it now. I can just tell my dads I went to the store if they ask where I was."
Finn's mouth twitched and he looked nervously at the wall. "It's really not that big of a deal..."
"If it's got you like this it must be. You can tell or ask me anything. I don't mind." She comfortingly ran her fingers up and down Finn's chest until his hand fell over hers to stop her and intertwine their fingers.
His head dropped slightly as he sighed. "It's really stupid and you're gonna think I'm weird and a little petty even but, I know you weren't a virgin the first time we were together, you told me that, obviously, and I could kind of tell that anyway. It's just…I wonder who you were with before me. Chances are he was a guy at school and I find myself wondering if I know him, if I have him in any of my classes, and I kinda feel..." Finn paused letting Rachel absorb his thoughts.
"Are you jealous?" she asked with a hint of humor in her voice.
Finn shrugged and glanced back at her over his shoulder. "Maybe...a little...yes. I just hate the thought that someone else was with you and I know that's not fair of me considering I have my own past partners but, I just kind of want to know who he or they are." He looked back down at his hand holding Rachel's and squeezed tighter.
Rachel sat up on her knees letting the sheet completely fall away from her body and crawled into Finn's lap. He knew they were having a serious moment but he couldn't stop himself from staring at her boobs. They were just so perfect.
"Finn, my eyes are up here," Rachel mocked, pointing to her eyes with a little giggle. He tore his gaze away and gulped.
"Sorry. I just really love your boobs."
Rachel pinked at his compliment. "Thank you. It's always nice to meet a fan." They both chuckled and Rachel wrapped her arms around Finn's neck as he cupped her backside with both hands. She turned serious again. "If you really want to know I'll tell you who it was."
Finn nodded. "I would and I will tell you about my past women too if you want. Just so we're even."
"If you want to." Rachel shrugged and steadied herself to tell him about Jesse. "I've only been with one other guy before you. He was my boyfriend up until about Thanksgiving this past year. He graduated last year and was accepted to UCLA and we were going to try to make the long distance thing work because I really liked him. We had so much in common and our musical chemistry was amazing. I was even willing to ignore the fact that the sex we had was always horrible because I thought I loved him and I thought he loved me. But then he sent me a text message basically telling me he fucked some sorority slut and we were over because they were going out now. She ended up getting pregnant and they now live in Lima Heights Adjacent because her family disowned her, cutting off her college fund and Jesse was too stupid to realize he had to attend all his classes in order to pass them so he was put on academic probation."
"Wait, Jesse? As in Jesse St. James?" Finn asked incredulously. "That douchebag was your boyfriend?" Finn was appalled by this notion. He couldn't believe Rachel would ever be into someone as pretentious and obnoxious as Jesse St. James.
"You know him?" Rachel's eyebrow shot up quickly. "I didn't think you would since he graduated last year and you started here so late in the year."
"He was in one of the classes I took over for when Miss Michaels had her nervous breakdown and had to go to rehab. He thought he knew everything better than everyone. I wanted to punch off the shit-eating grin he had on his face every day. That dick had no respect for anyone. Why would you date him?"
Rachel looked guilty and shrugged her shoulders a little. "I didn't know how big of a jerk he was when I first met him. He seemed nice and he was into me and I had never had a boyfriend before so when he asked me out I accepted. Things started out great but then he started pressuring me for more and I wasn't entirely ready but I gave myself to him anyway because I didn't want to be alone. It was better to be unhappy with him than unhappy by myself."
Finn brushed some hair out of Rachel's face and grazed his thumb back and forth over her cheek. "I'm sorry he treated you that way. God, he is such a dick!"
Rachel couldn't help but laugh at Finn's audacity. "I was bitter for a while but I'm not really anymore. I have you now and you're a thousand times the man Jesse is, in every way." She glanced downward suggestively and the corner of Finn's mouth twitched upward. "You make me feel like a sexy woman while he made me feel like an ugly stiff piece of wood and I never found out if his tongue was talented at all, but it probably wasn't, and he never made me orgasm…ever."
"You mean, he never…?" Finn glanced down and Rachel shook her head. "What a dick? Well it's his loss because you taste fantastic." She giggled and he smiled at her. "It's true. The best I've ever had."
"How many have you had?" she asked curiously.
Now it was Finn's turn to divulge into the past. "Counting the one-night-stand I had to try to get over my last girlfriend, five. The last one though, that was a mistake and it was just straight-up sex one time. I was pissed off and lonely and thought sleeping with anyone else would make the hurt go away but it just made me feel like shit."
"Why would your girlfriend break up with you?"
"She thought I was boring because I never wanted to go out and party with her. Going to clubs and getting wasted every night was fun in college but I had to grow up a little once I graduated because I needed a job. I mean, I'm still working on getting my masters now so I really don't have time to party. Apparently she couldn't handle that and needed someone 'funner' so she broke up with me."
Rachel looked at him sympathetically. "I'm sorry. That's horrible."
He shot her a weak smile. "It's okay. If we hadn't of broken up I never would have left Cincinnati to come here when I learned about the potential job opportunity from an old professor of mine. Then we wouldn't be sitting here right now."
"Well if that's the case then I'm glad she wasn't mature enough for you because I like sitting here with you." She wiggled her body and snuggled in closer to him. "I guess we shouldn't regret the past because everything that happened led us to each other."
"You're right. We can't change the past, we can only look toward the future and I really hope that you might be in my future." Finn ran his hands over Rachel's back as she lifted her head to look into his face.
"I would like that, very much." She pressed her forehead to his, lightly kissing his lips before deepening it and pressing him back down onto the bed. Finn began to roll them over until Rachel's phone started playing 'Don't Rain On My Parade'. He groaned when he realized it was probably her fathers and pulled away from her. She got up and hastily ran for her purse sitting on Finn's dresser. He laid out on his bed with his head propped against the wall as he enjoyed the view of Rachel's ass while she dug around for her phone.
"Hello?" she greeted innocently. Finn could hear a voice on the other end of the line but couldn't make out any words. "Daddy, I'll be home soon. I just went to the store to buy some soy milk and ice cream since we're low. Did you need anything else while I'm out?" Rachel turned around to look at Finn and made a face while she mimed talking with her hand. "Okay, I should be home in about 20 minutes. Bye Daddy." She hung up the phone and chucked it back in her purse before pouting at Finn. "I really do have to go now. My father was not happy coming home to an empty house."
Finn got off the bed and finally put his boxers on then walked over to her, wrapping his arms around her small body. "Sorry, I got you in trouble. I'll have to work on my timing for having deep conversations."
Rachel grinned at him. "You didn't get me in trouble. I wanted to be here. I'd really love to stay but I can't." She leaned up and pecked him on the lips again before pulling away from him and finding her clothes. "I guess I'll just have to skip the shower. Hopefully my fathers' sense of smell won't be too tuned in to sex."
While he watched her dart around his room picking up her various discarded items of clothing, Finn pondered his weekend. It was only two days without her but it seemed like it would be a lifetime. How had he fallen so hard so fast for this woman?
"Hey, what's your favorite food?" he asked randomly, remembering he needed to find a vegan recipe to make dinner for Rachel on Tuesday.
She threw her shirt on and pulled her hair out from the collar. "I really enjoy pasta dishes…and Chinese food. My dads and I are pretty dedicated to Chinese take-out."
"Cool. I'll see what I can make then." Rachel walked over to him and gave him a hug again. "Thanks for coming over."
"Thanks for having me." She smiled up at him then pulled away and grabbed her purse. They both walked out to the living room and front door where Finn gave her another scorching kiss before letting her leave.
"I'll see you Monday at seven in my classroom." He smirked at her. "And if you're a minute late I'll definitely have to see to it that you get a spanking."
Rachel smirked back. "Oh I hope so. Naughtiness deserves punishment. You can't let me get away with anything." She giggled and kissed him again then finally opened the door to leave. "Bye Finn. I'll see you Monday." She waved goodbye and closed the door behind her and like that she was gone for over two whole days.
Finn couldn't remember the last time he'd been so anxious for a Monday.