A/N-So I decided to carry on, this storys pretty fun to write.

Seducing Mr Cavanaugh

Chapter 2 - "He should have been a carpenter"

Spencer stood in front of the full length mirror, shaking her head in disapproval. Surely the reflection was being distorted or something. Last time Melissa had wore this dress she'd looked so hot and that was coming from Spencer, someone who hated to boost Melissa's ego with even more compliments. It was true though which added to the frustration ten times more. How could of it wrapped around Melissa's figure so perfectly but only hang on hers. She sighed, closing Melissa's closet. Practically everything she'd tried on had looked awful, she was seriously contemplating just going down in her underwear, at least that fit right.

Finally, with only ten minutes to go, she settled on just shorts and a vest top. At least simplicity didn't scream desperation. The same desperation she had previously shown in his classroom. Cringe. What other options did she have though?

Ding Dong

Okay, here goes, take two.

"So you made it then?" Spencer smiled pleasantly, swinging the door fully open to let him in.

"Yes. It would have been ten times easier if you hadn't run off without leaving an address though" He looked over to Spencer giving a hard stare. Expressing the annoyance of having to rampage through the school records.

"Ups"

At first Mr Cavanaugh had been a bit awkward, not knowing where to stand and awaiting Spencer's permission for any action. 10 minutes later and he was relaxed on the sofa, happily teaching. Probably because so far Spencer had made zero attempt to seem interested in anything other than maths. Even when he had flung his blazer off, she had controlled herself from staring too hard at his now visible muscles. A slower approach was her plan. To subtly change the educational topic to something more casual was her first task.

"Is it making more sense now Spencer?"

She nodded.

"Mmm, you're a great teacher. Is that what you always wanted to be? She asked

"I suppose so. What about this part?" He gestured to the textbook, almost ignoring her advances in conversation. It didn't stop her though.

"You don't sound so certain. Crystal clear"

"Well clearly not as certain as you on these circle theorems" He gave Spencer a look of suspicion.

From the moment he had opened the textbook it had been evident Spencer knew what she was doing. If he's been 100% honest he was aware of it even before entering the house. Every instinct inside of him was screaming run but curiosity overpowered. He was curious to what Spencer was doing, why she was doing it and just curious in general, about Spencer.

"And I have you to thanks for that. If only I could show my gratitude"

My Cavanaugh cleared his throat as her eyes scanned him up and down, lingering slightly on his crotch. Yep he should of stayed at home.

"Spenccerr"

"Yes sir?" Her smile was innocent and her eyebrow arched.

"Why am I here?" He spoke slowly and hesitantly, not sure if he actually wanted the answer.

Spencer paused momentarily, thinking very carefully of her next actions and words. So far she had creeped him out, failed to make conversation with him and just generally looked like a complete and utter dick. Her options were running low, well besides killing Alison. Right now she had pure hatred for that girl, could of she thought of a more twisted dare? Probably. I mean at least Mr Cavanaugh was hot, she could of chosen one of the weirdos from the science department.

She scooted up a little nearer to him, something Mr Cavanaugh looked completely uncomfortable with.

"I needed help"

Mr Cavanaugh just rolled his eyes. "You definitely don't need help in maths Spencer"

"Oh, well maybe I need help with something else"

Her response earned her another eye roll. "Yeah, like finding shorts that couldn't be classified as underwear" he mumbled quietly.

Spencer laughed. Silently applauding herself for wearing the shorts over the dress. Alison had always told her to show off her sexy hasting's legs, and a compliment was rare from Alison. It should have been an automatic action to choose shorts to wear.

Her next move was a little risky but he was already aware of her motives so did it really matter. Slowly she rolled down her shorts, stepping out of them when they eventually reached the bottom of her legs.

"Spencer! What th"

She cut him off with a finger to his lips.

"As you can see sir, there's a clear difference between my underwear and shorts"

Usually a beautiful girl stood in front of you wearing just underwear would be heaven, but not when it's your student. This right now is hell and he'll be booking a room if he doesn't stop thinking of how hot she looks.

"Put your shorts back on" He commanded, looking away.

Turning his eyes in the other direction only made things worse. She was now practically straddling over him, softly pushing his cheeks until she was looking into his beautiful blue eyes again.

"Oh, I love it when you tell me what to do" She said, flirtatiously winking at him.

"Spencer Hastings" He yelled, trying to jump up but she pushed him back down.

"You know I never actually got your name"

Was she seriously trying to have a casual conversation with him? How could anyone think this is normal, oh yeah I invited my teacher round last night, straddled him and didn't let him leave. Oh god. Why did he ever accept the job at Rosewood high. Why did he ever become a teacher. He should of been a carpenter.

"Shorts on now" He began again.

"Sure, after I get a name"

He sighed, rolling his eyes for the third time now. "Toby. It's Toby. Toby Cavanaugh"

Spencer smiled victoriously. Hey, at least she had a name now. She stumbled back up onto her feet, sliding her shorts back up. In the mean time, Toby had jumped from the sofa as quick as possible and was now gathering up his belongings. Wow she actually managed to scare him more.

"Same time tomorrow Tobes?" She called as he rushed himself out the door.

Expectantly, she didn't recieve a response.

A/N-Thanking everyone for the reviews, follows and faves. Apologies for the late update. Usually I'll update once a week but school had my busy this week. Hope you like it.