I won't lie. Shit gets kinky. Don't like it, don't read.
DPOV
"Ste….Stefan…?" Elena asked, not sure she had heard right.
"Yes, Elena. Stefan's home. Oh, didn't you get my text asking if you were busy tonight?" Stefan growled at her, his pants still dropped to the floor.
"What brother, you're just finished with her? Or have you guys been fucking the entire time I've been away and this was just a quickie? I could hear her from the drive without my vampire hearing" he spat at Damon.
"I, ah…" He was speechless for once, he had no idea what to say, he finally gets to fuck the one girl he's been pining after for a year, and they get caught. He should have listened to the warning in his head.
Stefan walked towards the bed, still fondling himself.
"Or maybe you compelled her? You bastard! And you fucking bitch! I told you to keep drinking your vervain tea in case your necklace fell off! Look where it got you, in this wanker's bed!" he yelled, he was furious, Damon had never seen him so mad.
"Stefan, no, it's not his fault, I just… No! You know what? I NEEDED TO BE FUCKED! You NEVER get me off! You're always so gentle and slow and, ARGH. I don't regret it at all!" Elena yelled at Stefan.
This took Damon by surprise. She didn't regret it? But wait, she just wanted to be fucked? This wasn't… anything more?
"Elena… You just wanted to use me?" Damon asked,
"Now isn't the time Damon!"
"No, go on, Elena" Stefan taunted "Tell him how you only love his cock and were just curious to see if he was any good in bed" Stefan sat on the bed and put his legs up, leaning against one of the posts at the end of the bed.
"Stefan, get off the bed" Damon said angrily. "I didn't compel her. She came on her own free will".
"Oh yeah?" Stefan asked "You want to be just like Kathrine, babe?" he said slyly, shifting to his hands and knees, crawling to Elena who had covered herself up.
"Why cover yourself? We've both seen you naked, now. Was this really your first time with Damon? Or have you been doing this every trip I've taken away?"
Elena was nervous, Damon could tell, there was something in Stefan's eyes… Elena didn't answer him, and he knew it was because she was scared.
"Stefan come on, leave her alone…. She made a mistake…" Damon started
"Oh no, she said it wasn't a mistake!" Stefan sneered as he sat atop Elena's legs.
"Damon?" Stefan asked casually.
"Brother?" Damon replied, unsure of what to do right now, he'd never seen Stefan so angry that he was not showing emotion.
"You know what we never did with Kathrine together? Fuck. We never fucked her at the same time". Stefan stated, matter-of-factly.
"Stefan, no!" Elena cried "I... I'm not a whore!" she said "I'm sorry, OK… I just… I needed it…"
"Being in a relationship with two guys isn't being a whore Elena. Nor is having a casual 3some" Stefan said with total confidence in his voice.
"Re…..relationship?" Elena was shaking
"Mmhmm" Stefan said, crawling up her body slowly, Damon still sitting, watching, and not wanting to make a wrong move to piss Stefan off even more.
"I still love you, god I still love you. We can make this work, we can share, don't you think, Damon? This time it won't be a secret to Damon and I. we can have you together" he stopped as he was looking into her eyes, he then quickly moved to her neck and started nibbling with his human teeth, gently, no were near enough pressure to break her skin. The bite mark Damon had left was on the other side of her neck.
"Stefan stop" Damon shouted trying to pull him off Elena, "You can't do this, it's rape…" he started
"It's not rape if she's willing, and OH! Can you smell that Damon? That's a new wave of arousal, coming from the one and only Elena…." Stefan said slowly.
Damon sniffed the air, and sure enough she smelled more aroused then she was when she first walked in the house
"Elena?" Damon asked
"I… God… This is so wrong" she cried "But fuck…. Yes I want you both.. I can't pick" she was so frustrated.
"Elena, I want you. Not Stefan" Damon stated. He was so confused now, much like Elena must have felt.
Stefan was now slowly kissing down Elena's cleavage and pulling the blanket off of her.
"Come on Damon, there are two breasts to play with…." Stefan said
"I… Elena?"
EPOV
She had no idea what was happening, but honestly she'd fantasised many times about having a 3way relationship with the Salvatore brothers. Damon would take her on adventures and enjoy life to its fullest extent while Stefan would watch movies with her and do all the romantic things.
It was only a fantasy. How she got into this position now she wasn't sure,
"Can… Can we try?" Elena stumbled out, aimed more towards Damon because Stefan was holding one breast, biting and sucking, and honestly she felt the other was a bit naked.
"Are… Are you sure you want this?"
"Shut up Damon. You know you want to fuck her again in that tight pussy! Did you enjoy it the first time? God it's so tight isn't it? That's because I popped that cherry! Too bad I couldn't make her scream like you did. Elena, did I ever even make you cum?" Stefan asked
"Nnnnn….No" she said honestly, not wanting to lie.
"Well, we'll have to change that. I can be just as rough as Damon, you know. Now I know you're not a fragile little girl" he sneered at her.
"Damon.. Please" she begged, and when he finally did join them on the bed, she knew it was firstly more about making sure Stefan didn't hurt her then sharing the love of his life with brother.
But as soon as he laid a hand on that naked glorious body, he was in the zone. If this was the only way he could have her, he'd have to comply, because hell yes he wanted to fuck her again, Elena could see it in his eyes.
Damon was licking at the wound he had created beforehand "Are you sure you want this, Elena. I can vervain him and take him downstairs" he stated extremely quietly, only so she would hear
She turned her head so she was nibbling on his neck now, "Yes, I want this, god I've fantasized about this since I meet both of you and heard about your cock…" she said
"Stop sharing secrets, Elena…." Stefan growled, oblivious as to what the two of them had said.
He was biting her hard nipple now laying to one side of Elena, and Damon was making his way down Elena's body, kissing and caressing, taking his time, unlike the first time before hand
"Damon, now isn't the time to be romantic. I want you to watch me fuck her like I just watched you. But first, go down on her" Stefan commanded
Damon quickly made his way down to Elena's dripping wet pussy, he started teasing her gently with his tongue, which made Elena arch her back. "OH god" she cried, as he put two fingers inside her and started nibbling on her clit
"Is that how you like it, Elena? His hands are better than my cock elena?" Stefan said in a sing song voice "Noooooo lying!" he winked.
"God yes his fingers feel so good inside of me!" she cried
Stefan sat up on the bed watching Damon suck and nibble on her clit, while he rocked his two fingers in and out of her pussy, even though they'd just had sex, she still tasted divine, a taste he'd never forget or get sick of, a taste that just screamed "Elena".
"Fuck his fingers, Elena. Just like on the couch, fuck his face, rock into his face…"
Damon stopped then "Wait, how long did you watch us for?" how had he not sensed it?
"Oh, I followed Elena here. At a distance. Keep going!" he yelled. Damon got back to his 'Job'.
Stefan started fucking his hand vigoursly "Argh, god, you need to teach me how to do that" he said to Damon, who had just smirked, yeah sure. Giving his brother sex lessons.
"Damon harder harder please!" she screamed, Damon could tell she was about to come, her hands were on her own breasts, pinching her nipples and pulling them upwards, pawing her breasts roughly
"Let go, Elena, come for me" Damon said against her skin, blowing gently on her clit
"Fuck yes" Stefan said "Make her cum and lap up those juices" he called,
Having Stefan there made Damon a little angry, he started growling which tipped Elena over the edge "Ah, oh, yes! Those… Vibra….ahh!" She screamed and she came hard around his fingers, he lapped up the juices, still finger fucking her "Shit, Damon, please, it's sensitive…." She cried once she came down from her high, trying to wiggle away from him. He just smirked and kissed her thigh.
Stefan coughed, "uh uh, sensitive or not, it's my turn to fuck you, or rather, you fuck me" he said as he laid down on the bed "Ride me, Elena" she nodded in agreement, getting up off the bed and kissing Stefan, nibbling down his neck and running her hands all over his chest, she just blocked out Damon – who wasn't entirely sure what to do now.
She hovered above Stefan's cock and took it in hand, slowly lowering herself down on it. Stefan let out a low moan "God, still so tight… so fucking tight" he moaned. Elena started riding his cock hard, going up and down, twisting her hips in circular motions, resting her hands on Stefan's chest. He was pushing up into her, harder than he had before when they had sex. Her tits were bouncing all over the place, leaving Stefan memorized his hands on hips, biting his own lip as he watched her.
He took one hand away and started playing with her sensitive clit, at first she shivered, still too sensitive to touch, but he persisted and it started to feel amazing, Stefan had never made her feel this way before.
DPOV
Damon watched what was happening in front of him, and suddenly all he wanted to do was something he may have only seen on porn, but he wanted to try it.
He got behind Elena while she was riding Stefan, she instantly tensed
"Don't worry, it'll be OK" he whispered, kissing her neck, and sliding his hands around her chest to play with her breasts "Slow down a bit" he whispered again.
"Come to join the party, brother?" Stefan moaned from down below,
"Mmmhmm, I'm going to try something I've never tried in my 160 plus years on this earth"
"You've never done anal?" Stefan said, laughing "Come on brother, you're more adventurous then me!"
"Not that" Damon said, shaking his head. "Stefan, sit against the head board, Elena, straddle him, but backwards" he said, letting Elena go, as he watched the two get into position.
"Damon?" Elena asked question.
"Just enjoy the ride, baby girl" he said crawling back up to her. He had his cock in hand, and he started teasing her clit with it
"Mmmm" Elena moaned "That feels great" she cried
"OK everyone still for a moment" Damon asked, he started nibbling Elena's neck, cock in hand, he gently started pushing into Elena's pussy
"wait…. What…" Elena started "Ahh… It hurts…" she cried out
"Don't worry, babe, it'll feel amazing in a minute" Stefan said from behind her.
They each stilled for a moment, while Elena adjusted to having two cocks inside her pussy. She looked down and god it looked so amazing.
"Don't look me in the eye, Stefan" Damon joked. His cock was touching Stefan cock, which was buried deep inside Elena, the friction it caused even though no one was moving felt amazing – even if it was his own brother.
"Mmmhmm k, please fuck me now" Elena begged, sandwiched between two amazingly hot guys, she had no idea how this would work.
"Stefan, you fuck her where you are, Elena, you stay still, let us do the work" he grinned, holding onto her hips, and Stefan holding her breasts, both men started moving inside of her
"Oh… oh fuck…" she called Damon's pubic bone was rubbing against her clit., Stefan's cock was going a shallow distance inside her, seeing as he was taking her from behind is cock didn't reach too far. Damon's cock was fucking her as before, though. Right deep inside her.
"I've never… I'm going to…" she cried. "Fuck yes" Stefan called from underneath her. "Come, Elena, come around our cocks, go on, The Salvatore cocks, buried deep inside Elena Gilbert, cum Elena…" he sang
Damon could feel her pussy tighten around their cocks, she put her hands on Damon's shoulders and pulled him close, slamming his body into hers, "mmmmahhhh" she cried, pulling his hair, he turned his head so he could nibble her neck. The moment his teeth grazed her heated neck, she let lose, she screamed in pleasure as she let go thrusting as much as she could to ride out her orgasm how she wanted, she was on cloud 9…. Pulling at Damon's hair again.
He could feel Stefan's cock throbbing and hear his gruff throaty moan, and he knew he was Cumming in her, too. This set Damon off, who pulled out a bit to cum only in the entrance of her pussy, as it shot out of his cock Elena cried
"Oh god that's so hot and feels so amazing", he knew it, he knew girls loved cum right on that spot. He sunk his cock in her a few more times, to pump out the rest of it, then slipped out and flopped down on the bed. Elena stayed on top of Stefan, who was gently caressing her, whispering sweet words in her ears.
SPOV
"I'm so sorry for scaring you… Elena… I didn't mean to hurt you" he coo'd after they'd come down from their high. He could just make out her face if he twisted his neck a little, she looked like she was high – pure bliss he guessed.
"I love you so much, baby girl… " he said again, still earning no response from Elena except for a small "mmmhmm".
"We…. We can make this work, all three of us, I promise…"
"Oh here comes broody emotional Stefan. Come on, man. Leave her alone for a moment, she needs to rest" Damon chuckled.
"Actually, I think I need to shower" She giggled.
"Amen to that" Damon said as he picked her up and vamped to the shower "I guess… I should invite you too?" He stopped and turned to Stefan, who was rather sad his girlfriend hadn't objected to having a shower with Damon
"Nah uh. There will be no sex for a while, this is simply a shower, don't get your hopes up, Mr." She joked at Damon.
"No it's fine, you too go... I guess I need to learn to share…" he sighed. Leaning back on the bed looking up at the canopy. If he had to share the girl to have the girl, so be it.