Thank you to those who reviewed, follow, and added my story to their favorites. I'm not sure where I'm really going with this but I'll continue to write...here's a chapter about the girls relationship.

Chapter 2: Lies and Truth

She smiles after looking at herself on the mirror. She's just finished applying blush, lip-gloss, and mascara on. She wore a pencil skirt and a white silky blouse. Her hair was down and curled with a little bow attached on her head.

She turns around as she sees her father standing by her door. "Hi, daddy."

"Where are you going looking so pretty?" Puck asked.

"A date. It's a Friday night. I'm allowed to spend the night out." Beth responds.

"Be home at eleven-fifteen sharp." Puck says.

"You're the best, daddy! Thank you!" Beth hugs her father.

Beth looks at her father worrying about the curious look on his face. "Daddy? I'll be fine. We've gone out on late dates before."

Puck nods. "I know. It's not about that, sweetheart."

"Then what is that look about?" Beth asked.

"Did you say anything to Rachel that would make her upset?" Puck asked.

Beth shrugs her shoulders.

"Beth..." Puck says. "You can't keep treating Rachel like that. She's your step-mom. She loves you."

Beth shook her head. "No she's not. She's my half-sister. She and I shared the same mother."

"So is this what it's about?" Puck asked concerned.

"I haven't reached out to her because I'm afraid she's going to replace Mom. I know it's been seven years, daddy but I can't let that happen. There's a special place in my heart for Mom."

"But Rachel's tried to be there for you. She's still there for you but you keep shutting her off."

"What do you want me to do?" Beth asked.

"I want you to give her a chance. She's a wonderful person, Beth. She doesn't want to replace your mom. You've been a little harsh to her."

Beth sighs. "I'll think about it, daddy." She says standing up. "I've got to go. Aaron's outside waiting for me. Bye, daddy. I love you." Beth says giving her father a hug and a kiss.

"Get home safe, sweetheart. Don't do anything stupid." Puck warns her.

"Daddy..." Beth cries and leaves the room. Puck took a deep breath. Aaron Samuels. That guy isn't on my good list. Hopefully Beth will think about what I've told her. She better. And she better be home by curfew.

Maybe things will get better for Rachel and Beth.

The very next morning breakfast was made by Puck. He made chocolate chips pancakes for everyone along with eggs. Everyone came down except Beth. Puck was worried that she might of missed her curfew and was wondering if Emily knew anything.

"Did anyone hear Beth come home last night?" Puck asked.

Emily shrugs her shoulders.

'You know me, Noah. I sleep like a baby." Rachel says. Puck sighs. Usually he would hear Beth come home on late curfews on a Friday night. He shrugs it off thinking he fell asleep early knowing he was tired from a long week of work.

"Her pancake is getting cold." Emily says. "Just like she always is." She adds. Puck raises an eyebrow. "Last night she said I didn't have a life because I never get invited to extremely cool parties." Emily sighs.

Puck listens to Emily carefully. "She told you that?" He asked.

Emily nods. "So when she said she was going out on a late date, she lied to you." Emily smirks.

Rachel glances at Emily than at Puck. "Is this all true?"

"Why would I lie? I care about her, believe it or not, but I do. I don't know anything about the party but I know she was there." Emily continued. Rachel saw the anger on Puck's face.

The three of them became silent as they saw Beth coming down the stairs. She greets them with a weak smile, puts syrup on her pancake, and takes a bite. She couldn't help but notice how her family was staring at her. "Good morning?" She greets them.

Rachel places her hand on Puck's shoulder. "Good morning." Emily gives Beth a fake smile.

"How was your date?" Puck asked.

"Lovely, daddy. Aaron took me to the movies, dinner at Breadsticks, and we laid on the sand of the lake looking at the stars. It was an amazing night." Beth says.

"What'd you have for dinner?" Puck continues to ask his daughter about her "Special Night"

"Alfredo pasta." Beth responds. "We ate chocolate cake for dessert. He was so sweet last night. He gave me a goodnight kiss." Beth smiles.

Puck had enough. Beth has never lied to him like this before. "You can quit the act, Beth."

Beth looks at her father confusingly.

"I told them that you went out to a party." Emily smirks.

"You what? You promised you wouldn't tell!" Beth screams.

"Yeah, but then I thought that it isn't right how you treat me like I'm a nobody when actually I'm your sister." Emily argues.

Beth rolls her eyes. She then looks at her father. "Daddy? I'm really sorry but I had to lie to you. All that stuff I said isn't true! It never happened. I had to make up an excuse because I know you wouldn't of let me go. It was held by this senior with no parents supervising the party. You'd flip out and I already said I could go. Did you really think I would be going to the movies dressed the way I was dressed?" Beth asked.

Puck took a deep breath. "You're right. I wouldn't of let you go..." He says. "But you know this is you're first time lying to me. Beth? I'm disappointed in you."

"I said I was sorry, daddy!" Beth apologizes. "If it makes you feel better I came home before two o'clock."

"Did you drink?" Puck asked.

"No, daddy. Aaron didn't drink either. We're both very responsible."

"But you lie..." Puck says.

"I'm sorry! I just had to go! If I didn't go, my reputation would go down the drain!"

Rachel clears her throat. "Noah? I think you need to stay cool. She already apologized and was honest about the time she came home. Most teenage daughters aren't like that." She looks at Beth, hoping Beth would mouth a thank you to her but didn't.

Puck nods. "Okay, fine. You're grounded for the next two weekends. You're not allowed to make plans with your friends or Aaron." Puck knew this day would come. Puck knew he would have to ground his daughter at one point of her life.

"But I apologized! Daddy, please!" Beth cries.

"No, Beth...You're grounded. And for the next two weekends I'll be the one getting a hold of your phone."

"What?!" Beth yells. "This is ridiculous! I can't believe this is happening. I can't believe you're grounding me for the first time!" And just like that Beth storms out and upstairs to her room.

"Do you want me to-" Rachel asked but Puck shook his head before she finished.

"No. She'll be angry for a while but you shouldn't check on her." Puck says

"Daddy? Would you like me to go?" Emily asked. "Mommy grounded me for having a fit with Mr. Schu a couple months ago."

Puck shrugs. "I guess... be careful, pumpkin."

Emily smiles. "Thanks for breakfast." She heads upstairs to Beth's room.

She was hoping she'd be able to actually talk to Beth and not have a cat fight.

Emily hesitates to knock on Beth's door. She was the one who offers so it took her ten minutes to finally knock on the door. "Go away!" Beth screams. Emily shook her head and opens the unlock door.

Beth glares at her sister. "You should of kept your mouth shut. You're the last person who I want to see." Beth says.

"I was just looking out for you. I know you don't care about me but I care about you. You're my sister and I was worried about you last night."

"Aaron and I were having a life. It's something you don't have." Beth glares. Emily folds her arms and nods. "I've been grounded before. Mom grounded me a couple months ago with that Mr. Schu thing, remember?"

"Yeah, so? You were only grounded one weekend and it didn't matter anyways because you didn't have any major plans."

Emily ignores what Beth has said. "I came up here because I want to make a truth."

"A truth?" Beth asked.

"I couldn't stand when you lied to Daddy like that. I had to tell him the truth and I'm sorry. " Emily pauses. "If you keep doing this then Daddy would continue to ground you. So I call a truth." She pauses as she hesitates to continue. "Join Glee Club."

Beth looks at her sister. "What?"

"Join Glee Club." Emily repeats herself.

"Why? That club is full of losers."

"I know you have a voice in you, Beth. I've heard you sing and hum in the shower. You're really, good. Mr. Schu says he'd be more than welcome to gain a member or two. I know Aaron's secret. He's a singer just like you are. You two would be perfect for Glee."

"No, no...We have a reputation to live up for. Glee Club will ruin our lives."

"Fine." Emily says. "Then I'd just have to continue to rat you out..."

Beth sighs. "Okay, fine! I'll join Glee club...when can I audition?"

"Tomorrow at exactly three o'clock. You know where the choir room is so don't be late." Emily walked out of the room.

Me join Glee Club? Is she insane? What is she thinking? If I join Glee Club then I'll be having slushy facials attacks every day.

My life will be over after tomorrow at three o'clock. Great...

Let me know what you think. I haven't really thought about Puck's career in life but here Rachel still teaches vocal coaching at George Peterson (I made the school up) What do you think Puck should be?

Please read and review. Thank you! :)