Inside Out: Would You Rather- Chapter 1

A/N: HOLY SHISH! I got so many more reviews than I thought I would get. Seriously, I expected to get one, two the most. Instead I got 6.. Oh, okay. Regardless, I'm going to try and use literally everybody's request in this chapter, so no one will miss out. I'm sorry if I accidently skip your request, I can be stupid sometimes.


"Annd..we're out!" Announced Joy, as Riley closed her eyes and fell asleep. "Great job today guys!" The other emotions shifted sleepily, not really paying attention. The atmosphere seemed as bland as tofu. Disgust groaned lazily.

"Oh come on guys, today was a great day; we should be more happy!" Joy exclaimed, waving her arms. Suddenly a thoughtful expression consumed her face.

"Hey! I've got an idea! How about we play would you rather?" The emotions stopped, turned and stared at Joy.

"Would you rather?" Questioned Disgust, raising an eyebrow. "Why would we play that weird game?"

"It will be fun! We practically get to ask each other questions, and you get to choose your preferred answer! It's better to play than it sounds." Joy said, trying to keep the mood happy.

"But what if we can't pick? What if it's too hard?" Fear squeaked, hiding his head. Anger glared at him and Disgust rolled her eyes.

"I'm sure that won't happen! We'll have lots of fun, I promise!" Joy said, plastering on a big smile.

"Fine, we can play this stupid game, as long as I don't get dream duty!" Anger snapped, crossing his arms. Joy laughed.

"Very well Mr Blocky," The star said, getting a glare from Anger and a snigger from Disgust. "Okay, who wants to go first?" Fear squeaked and hid behind a pile of memories. Sadness bowed her head quietly. Joy's eyes set on her.

"Okay Sadness! Here's one for you, just give your preferred answer: would you rather have the power to make it rain forever or make people cry forever?" She asked, as everyone stared at Sadness. She looked away nervously.

"Whatever she chooses, I don't want to be apart of some cry land.." Said Disgust, putting her hands in front of her and cringing. Sadness laid on the floor and remained thoughtful.

"Um… It's very hard to choose.." She said, looking a little teary. The descion was making her stressful, and of course, sad. "I-I think I'd like.. Both.." The emotions stared at her in confusion. Disgust groaned and shook her head.

"Can she pick that? Are we breaking the rules?" Fear asked, hiding behind Anger. The brick punched him in the guts and sent him flying.

"Well…" Joy said, clearing her throat, turning her attention to the teardrop. "Are you sure you can't pick?" Sadness shook her head gloomily and trudged over to the corner, with all the mind manuals.

"Okay.. Fear, this one is for you!" Joy said, turning to Fear. He squeaked and jumped into Disgust's arms. She glared at him, followed by dropping him to the floor. He nervously got to his feet and acted like someone was going to arrest him. Joy had a mischievous glance on her face.

"Fear, would you rather kiss Anger and punch him really hard?" The star asked, even grabbing the attention of Sadness, who was reading about imagination land. Fear gulped and Anger stared at him, then at Joy.

"Uh… uh… uh…!" Fear squeaked, hiding his head in shame. Disgust cooed and pointed at him. "Now I have a reason to watch this."

"Um.. Kiss him!" Blurted out Fear, hiding behind a shelf and building a wall of memories in front of him.

"Um… Okay," Joy said, giving a weird look at Fear who seemed to be building the Great Wall of China. "Disgust, this one is for you: Would you rather eat the smelliest cheese or the moldiest?" Disgust cringed and put her hands in front of her.

"Don't even make me think about moldy cheese!" She said, looking like she was about to puke. Anger watched her with a smirk. Disgust clutched her forehead stressfully. "Smelliest!" She cried, before running out the room to go vomit. Anger watched her run out with a smirk.

"This one is for you, Anger," Said Joy, her glance turning to the brick. "Would you rather watch the most annoying baby show or the Triple Dent Gum commercial?" Anger gritted his teeth. Fear covered himself with memories, just in case a certain red emotion decided to give him a beating.

"Hmph.. Anything is better than that darned Gum commercial!" The red emotion snapped, crossing his arms. Joy clapped her hands.

"Okay! Now it's my turn! Somebody give me one!" Joy said, her arms making a welcoming position. She had a big smile on her face; it was like someone was going to give her 20 grand.

"You want a would you rather? I'll give you a would you rather!" Disgust cried, entering the room with sass in every step. Fear gasped at her sudden appearance. She stared at Joy. "Would you rather go on a date with Fear or Anger?" Joy blushed a little and tapped her chin. Sadness, from her lying down reading position looked up at her with interest. Disgust looked pretty satisfied with herself, while Fear and Anger looked quite disturbed. It was a rare thing to seem them both sharing the same feelings.

"Well," Joy said quietly, almost as soft as Sadness. Her hands were brought together and they twitched slightly. "Um.. No offence Anger, but I'd say Fear." She said, her face bright red. Fear blushed as well, and the two glanced at each other.

"And I've got one for you, Beanpole!" Anger snapped, as Fear squeaked and covered his face, his blushing turning to fright.

"Okay, would you rather go on a date with Disgust or Sadness?" He asked, smiling like the devil. Fear glanced at the female emotions. Disgust's eye twitched and Sadness pushed her face into a pillow, hiding her face.

"Er.. Sadness! Please don't give me anymore!" He screamed, hiding behind Joy. Sadness blushed and stared at him with empathy.

"Okay.. um.. Joy.." Said the blue one, looking at the star. She nodded boldly, ready to take her fate (wtf). "Would you rather have.. Um.. ice cream.. Or cupcakes?" The teardrop asked, her voice slightly higher and happier than usual. Disgust raised an eyebrow at this. Joy, who didn't seem to notice smiled brightly; one could swear the mention of sweet foods made her glow brighter.

"That's tricky, but I'm going to say ice-cream, because who doesn't love ice-cream?" Joy exclaimed, as Sadness went back to reading and blocking out the world. Joy turned her head to the broccoli. "This one is for you, Disgust!"

"Great." The green one replied, rolling her eyes. Joy ignored this. "Would you rather smell people's armpits or under their feet?" Disgust's face turned to horror and she stared at Joy with envy. Anger sat back to watch and enjoy the dose of comedy.

"God.. They're both so disgusting!" The green one cringed, and looked away. "Fine! Feet! I can't do armpits- ugh!" She looked like she was about to puke again. "Anger, would your rather-ugh, listen to Miley Cyrus or Justin Bieber?" She then ran away to go and vomit. The emotions stared at Anger with intrigue.

"I hate both of them!" Anger snapped, bringing his fists together. Fear hid behind a pile of books that Sadness had already read. Joy made a thoughtful position and stared at him.

"Justin Bieber because he doesn't swing on wrecking balls and lick things! Although I still hate him! The next one is for you, beanpole!" Anger snapped, turning to Fear. He screamed and knocked over the pile of books. Sadness sighed sadly.

"Would you rather be in a place full of vampires or clowns?" The brick asked evilly. Fear almost passed out. He hugged the fallen books as if they were his only protection. Sadness glanced strangely at him, as he stood behind her, grabbing all the books.

"Um.. Vampires! I don't even want to think about.. J-J-Jang.." He said, before passing out and landing on the reading Sadness. The blue emotion touched his nose, which caused him to scream and jump 50 feet in the air and Anger to burst out laughing.

"Joy!" Fear cried, running away from Sadness. "Would you rather.. Go to the zoo or beach?" Fear panted, side glaring at a mind manual that had landed on his face.

"Why does Joy get all the easy ones?" Complained Disgust, her hands on her hips. Fear gasped at her sudden appearance once again; where did she come from? Joy smirked thoughtfully.

"They both sound like a lot of fun.. Hm, probably the beach because swimming is so much fun! Although I do love the zoo." Joy said, looking at Fear with a smirk. He nodded happily, then his face turned to shock when he checked the time.

"Oh god! It's really late, we'll keep Riley up with all of this noise!" Fear squeaked, looking around nervously.

"Riley can't hear us, genius.." Disgust said, crossing her arms. Fear shook his head. "No, no. I mean, with us acting around, it will make her mentally excited and keep her physically awake."

"Good, this game is stupid anyway." Anger complained, getting up. Joy rolled her eyes; she wasn't believing any of that nonsense.

"We'll play again some other time, but for now, Sadness, you're on dream duty." Joy said, looking at the blue emotion. She was involved in her book. There was a large pile of books next to her; she had read the whole library.

"Goodnight." The teardrop put the book down, ready for a session of dream duty.


A/N: Hey yall! Thank you for reading, I had lots of fun writing this chapter. Of course, you can request as much as you want to me and you can pick any would you rather you like. Here are the credits:

-HollyAnne1084

-dodamonkey

-Guest (I didn't know your name)

-Korrasami 88

-Extreme Light 9

Thanks to all these people for requesting, and I'll see you later!

~Ponystories

P.S- Sorry if the chapter was a little short, would you rather is a quick game.