The next day at school, Chloe walked to her locker where she found a love-struck Timmy writing something on a piece of paper.

"What're you doing Timmy?" asked Chloe.

"I'm trying to write a poem," Timmy answered, not even looking up. "Hey, what rhymes with Isabella?"

"Who's Isabella?"

Timmy face immediately turned bright red when he looked up prompting Chloe to turn around to see what he was looking at. To Chloe's surprise, Timmy was staring at Isabella. Isabella walked up to Timmy, who greeted her with gibberish. Isabella giggled at Timmy's inability to speak English as Chloe asked him, "Who is this girl, Timmy?"

"Huh? Oh, this is Isabella, our new neighbor," Timmy explained.

Isabella stretched her hand towards Chloe and said, "Nice to meet you."

Chloe shook her hand and said, "Likewise."

"Hey, Isabella, since you're new here, how about I give you a tour of the school?" Timmy eagerly suggested.

"That sounds great," said Isabella.

"Great! Let's go!" said Timmy.

Timmy led Isabella down the hallway as Cosmo and Wanda poofed in Chloe's hands as textbooks.

"Guys, is that the girl I wished for Timmy?" asked Chloe.

"Yep, that's her," said Cosmo.

Chloe was confused. She wished that Timmy had a girlfriend, but even though Timmy has a crush on her, they didn't seem to be more then friends.

"I don't get it Cosmo," said Chloe. "How come they're not dating?"

"Because, Chloe, if they were immediately together then Timmy would figure out that something was wrong and would have immediately realized that you made a pity wish for him," Cosmo explained.

"It wasn't a pity wish," said an offended Chloe. "I just wanted Timmy to be happy."

"Anyway," Cosmo continued, "If Timmy found out your wish then he would be mad at us and would be sad that he need magic to find love."

Wanda poofed up a notepad and started to jolt down her thoughts.

"Febuary, Cosmo thought a wish through," Wanda spoke as she wrote down her thoughts.

Wanda poofed the notepad away and added, "But you know Cosmo, Timmy used magic to help his love life before."

"Yeah, but Timmy wouldn't be mad if he was the one to make the wish," said Cosmo.

Wanda poofed the notepad back into her hands and wrote down, "Cosmo really thought this wish through."

Later during recess, Chloe, Chester and AJ talked about Valentine's Dance until AJ realized something was wrong.

"Hey, where's Timmy?" asked AJ.

"He's probably still mad at us," said Chester. "He's probably wants to be alone for a while."

As if on cue, Timmy walked up to his friends with Isabella. Chester and AJ were shocked that a girl, besides Tootie or Chloe, was around Timmy and wasn't insulting him.

"Hey guys, meet my new neighbor Isabella," said Timmy.

"Nice to meet you," said Isabella.

"A girl's hanging around Timmy!" AJ fearfully shouted. "It's the sign of the apocalypse!"

An equally scared Chester grabbed a bullhorn and shouted into it, "Everybody to the shelter!"

All the kids ran into the school leaving Timmy, Chloe and Isabella as the only ones on the playground. Isabella was confused by what just happened and asked Timmy why they ran away.

"They do that every time something unnatural happens to me," explained Timmy. "In this case, it's you hanging around me."

"Why would that be unnatural?" asked Isabella.

"The girls here don't like me," said Timmy. "They probably would have acted that way with Chloe if everyone didn't feel like she was being forced on me."

"Everyone thought I was forced on you?" asked Chloe.

Chloe was surprised to hear that. She never though she was forced on Timmy. But then she thought about how on her first day she was seated next to Timmy, assigned a locker near his, moved to the house across his and was told to share Cosmo and Wanda with him. She began to think that maybe she was forced on Timmy.

"You know they all ran like the aliens from Plant Kerx did from Crash Nebula," Isabella pointed out.

Timmy was shocked to hear her say that. He never heard a girl talk about Crash Nebula before.

"Y-You watch Crash Nebula?" asked Timmy.

"Mm-hmm," Isabella said with a nod. "I even have the complete series box set. It's next to my comic book collection."

Timmy was shocked to hear her say that. Girl that do read comic books don't announce it openly.

"Y-You have a comic book collection?" asked Timmy.

"Mm-hmm," Isabella said. "It's right under my video game shelf."

That was the last thing Timmy heard before he fainted. Timmy later woke up in the infirmary with Cosmo, Wanda and Chloe.

Timmy sat up, rubbed his head and asked what happened to him.

"You fainted after Isabella told you about her video game shelf," Chloe explained.

Timmy face lit up as he remembered what he heard and excitedly told his companions, "I can't believe it. A girl that gives me the time of the day and shares my interests! It almost as if she was made for me!"

To Timmy's surprise, Cosmo and Wanda started whistling a suspicious tune.

"Um, Timmy… what if she was made for you?" asked Chloe.

"What do you mean?" asked Timmy.

"Hypothetically speaking, what if someone wished for you to have the perfect girlfriend?"

"You know I was just thinking about wishing that yesterday before I met Isabella."

Hearing Timmy say that made Chloe hopeful that he wouldn't get mad at her for her wish.

"So you wouldn't have mind if someone made that wish for you?" asked Chloe.

"Well that same night I thought about my previous love related wishes and that it would be pathetic for me to wish me a girlfriend," said Timmy.

"Really? That seems like something you would wish for," said Cosmo.

"I did say after my previous love related wishes," said Timmy. "Anyway, I guess if someone did make that wish for me and I found out then I would feel bad that I would need magic to find love and that I was pitied on. Why do you ask?"

"N-No reason," said a nervous Chloe.

Timmy jumped out of the infirmary bed and said, "I'm going to go find Isabella now. See ya."

Timmy ran out of the infirmary as Chloe began to feel guilty about her wish.

"Maybe I shouldn't have made that wish," said Chloe.

"Don't feel bad, Chloe," said Wanda. "You only made that wish to make Timmy happy."

"But what if Timmy finds out the truth?" asked Chloe. "I could lose my only friend."

"I'm sure Timmy would understand," said Wanda.

"Yeah, I mean he forgave you when your first wish destroyed his Crimson Chin comics," said Cosmo.

Cosmo reminding her of that made Chloe feel even more guilty. Wanda shot an angry look at Cosmo who wondered why.