A/N: Thanks for all the reviews, favs and follows!

The title of this chapter is the title of a wonderful song by Landon Pigg. I first heard it because someone had used it for a Careese video, and it was so perfect for them and so beautiful in general that I had to find the song for myself. You all should check it out. It's really good stuff.


Falling In Love In A Coffee Shop

John was nervous.

The kaleidoscope of butterflies that had taken up residence in his stomach since he'd issued the invitation for Joss to meet him for coffee this morning had grown exponentially overnight. It was a state that rarely plagued him, but he found that the longer he sat here, watching the city begin a brand new day through the diner's huge windows, the more anxious he became.

Although the feeling was strange to him, he supposed he really shouldn't be all that surprised. Not when Joss Carter was involved. Because whenever she entered into the equation, things had a tendency to change. The way he thought. The way he felt. The little things that made life worth living that he normally wouldn't even have paid attention to.

When it came to her and her venerable place in his life, everything he thought he knew about himself and what he wanted and expected was suddenly not so simple anymore.

She made him feel things he had no business feeling and yearn for things he didn't deserve to have. She made him want impossibilities like legacies and longevity and happily ever after. Pipe dreams that had no place in his world.

He'd tried his best to fight against it, even going so far as to cut ties with her after that whole Riker's disaster. But the longer he'd tried to stay away from her, the more he'd found it untenable. Like the Earth's natural inclination to follow a pre-determined, unwavering path around the Sun, he'd found that his natural inclination was to gravitate toward his detective. He needed to be in her orbit, and it couldn't be from afar.

He needed to see her, talk to her, touch her.

He needed to know how her day went and how Taylor was faring as he grew from a boy into a man. He needed to hear the exasperation in her voice when he did something that annoyed her or see the delighted twinkle in her eyes when he said something that amused her.

He simply needed her.

It wasn't much more complicated than that. And no matter how inconvenient the truth was or how terrifying it might be, the moment he'd confessed some of what he felt for her in that morgue all those weeks ago, the more comfortable he felt embracing it. It was a fear he didn't think he wanted to run from anymore. Not after he'd almost been forced to live in a world without her in it.

The finite nature of life demanded it, and it was time he started listening.

After he'd taken his head out of his ass, things had fallen neatly into place. With Finch's help, decisions he'd been putting off for reasons that now seemed silly had been cemented.

The first has been the star and the second…

Automatically, his hand drifted to the portfolio that rested on the worn, red vinyl beside the dark fabric of his thigh. For what felt like the hundredth time during the fifteen short minutes he'd been waiting, he let his fingertips graze the surface. The black leather was smooth and cool to the touch, a tangible reminder that he was really going to do this. He was really going to share something with Joss that he'd had no intention of her finding out until it was absolutely unavoidable.

Sighing quietly, still edgy as hell but determined to see this through, John downed the last of his coffee, grimacing with distaste as the bitter, lukewarm liquid hit his tongue. He was contemplating whether to order a fresh cup from the tired-looking waitress wiping down the long counter or wait for Joss to arrive, when he felt it: a tingle of awareness, sharp and insistent, snaking up his spine.

His eyes shot to the door at the far end of the room and just as he suspected, Joss had appeared. He smiled. As always, his body knew she was near before his eyes could even provide him with visual confirmation. The feeling used to unsettle him, but he'd long since learned to treasure it.

Smile settling into a welcoming smirk as their gazes collided, he let his eyes meander over her as she made her way over to him. The smell of brewing coffee and frying bacon; the low babble of hungry patrons; the metallic clink of utensils scraping against ceramic all faded away into a silent void as his universe narrowed to a place where only she existed.

He didn't hear anything but the click of her boots on the scuffed white linoleum or see anything other than her wide, beautiful smile as she drew nearer.

As small as she was, she appeared even smaller bundled up tightly against the frosty winter morning. Her black wool coat was tucked firmly around her slim form, and a burnt-orange scarf, its long tasseled ends hanging all the way to her thighs, was wrapped protectively around the lower part of her face.

The wind had been playing freely in the glossy strands of her ebony hair, giving her a sexy, tousled look that conjured up thoughts of her waking up in his bed on a lazy Sunday morning.

For her part—and to her credit—Joss gave as good as she got, openly watching him watch her as she slid into the booth across from him.

"Good morning, Detective."

"Morning. Did I keep you waiting long?"

He watched as she uncoiled the knit scarf from around her neck, revealing her smooth brown skin in full. She was glowing, and it didn't escape his notice that she was turning more than a few heads even at seven o' clock in the morning. That didn't surprise him. She was absolutely gorgeous, the early hour only seeming to enhance the beauty she'd been naturally blessed with.

"Nope—you're right on time." As he waited for her to get settled, John signaled the waitress to bring them two fresh cups of coffee.

"How do you know I want coffee?" She pulled off her matching gloves then slid her coat down her arms, a coy smile turning up the corners of her full lips.

As she blew into her hands to warm them, his gaze strayed to her mouth. Memories of their one and only kiss flooded his brain. He could remember with perfect clarity how soft her lips were; how kissing her had felt like finally coming home.

With Herculean effort, he forced himself to focus on her eyes instead. "Because you always want coffee."

Joss flashed him a dimpled smile, wordlessly acknowledging his bull's-eye. They fell silent as the gray-haired waitress materialized beside the table and set two cups of steaming black coffee on the scratched Formica in front of them.

"And do you know how I take it?" she asked as soon as the older woman had turned on her sensible, rubber-soled shoes and hurried away. It was clear she was teasing him.

He decided to repay the favor.

"Joss, I wouldn't be very good at what I do if I didn't know how you take your coffee by now." He caught her gaze and held it. "And we both know I'm very good at what I do."

Her husky laugh touched him in places that shouldn't be touched in public, but it also spurred him on. Before he'd even realized his intentions, he was leaning forward to take up the unspoken challenge. Reaching across the table, he snagged the rounded handle of her cup and carefully pulled it toward him. The dark liquid sloshed gently against the sides then settled almost immediately as he carefully pushed his own cup off to one side.

He could feel her eyes watching him as he went to work. Choosing to let his actions speak for him, he quickly dressed her coffee with three packets of sugar, two tiny containers of plain half and half and one container of French vanilla-flavored creamer before sliding it back in front of her.

Looking duly impressed, Joss raised an arched brow and took a small, cautious sip. "Not bad."

"See?" he said in a low voice. "I know just how you like it."

John didn't bother to hide his pleased smirk as his comment had the intended effect. Another laugh bubbled out of her, a combination of surprise and delight mirrored in the slight widening of her eyes and the glimmer of amusement making them sparkle like chocolate diamonds.

Lifting his cup to his mouth, he hid a relieved smile behind the white ceramic as she continued to chuckle quietly. The second the double-entendre had left his mouth, he was afraid his teasing may have gone a step too far.

He was glad it hadn't.

John knew he was playing a dangerous game, perhaps even a foolish one, but at this point he didn't care. He was tired of denying himself what he wanted, and damn it all, he wanted her.

He just wasn't sure what he was going to do about it.

Joss relaxed back against the padded bench seat and reached up to tuck her hair behind her ear. The silver hoop hanging from her earlobe flashed under the bright ceiling lights, almost rivaling the brilliance of her smile, but not by much.

"So what'd you want to see me about? Got a new number?"

"Not yet."

Her eyebrows jumped upwards and then immediately lowered again as the beginnings of a perplexed frown caused that familiar furrow to appear right above the bridge of her nose. She tilted her head, and he watched entranced as the curled ends of her long hair tumbled around her shoulders.

"Then what's going on?"

Without giving himself a chance to change his mind, he silently placed the portfolio in the center of the table between them.

"Open it," he encouraged when she simply stared at it. He could practically see the wheels turning in her head as her sharp detective's brain tried to guess what was inside. "Unless you've developed X-ray vision since the last time I saw you, you're going to have to open it, Joss."

"What is it?" she asked cautiously, the elegant fingers wrapped around her cup tightening imperceptibly. It was almost as if she knew that the contents hidden beneath the rich leather cover had the potential to change their relationship forever.

"The only way to know is to open it."

"I'll know if you tell me," she shot back.

Amused, he shook his head, a small smile curling up one corner of his mouth. That was his Joss. Stubborn to the last.

"Has anyone ever told you that you're exceedingly obstinate?"

"There's a certain someone who loves to remind me of that every chance he gets." She picked up her coffee cup and took a small sip, nodding her head toward the object in question. "So what's in it? Is it something I shouldn't be seeing?"

"It's nothing illegal if that's what you're asking."

Seemingly resigned to the fact that he could be as stubborn as she was, she sighed. "Okay, John, I'll bite."

His stomach knotted anxiously as she slid her coffee out of the way and pulled the portfolio directly in front of her. As she flipped it open and stared down at the top page, he took a deep breath and let it out slowly, employing every tactic he knew to quell the nervous anticipation that had come roaring back with a vengeance.

"This is your Will," Joss said as she looked up at him, obviously confused.

"It is," he confirmed.

"I didn't know you had a Will."

"There are a lot of things you don't know about me, Detective."

"Are you trying to tell me something?" Despite the teasing note that she'd injected into her voice, he could tell that this sudden shift in their conversation had taken her aback.

"Actually, I am. Keep reading."

She bowed her dark head again and began to read, taking in what were to be the last set of instructions he'd ever give. With her attention diverted for the moment, he let himself greedily drink his fill. He let his eyes trace down the gentle slope of her nose and over the plush curve of her pursed lips before moving lower to follow the taut fabric of her navy button-down where it cradled the swell of her full breasts.

"You made Fusco your Executor if anything happens to Finch?" She looked up at him, one eyebrow cocked in disbelief.

"Well, it damn sure isn't going to be Shaw." He gave her a reassuring nod when she only continued to stare at him doubtfully. "Trust me—there's a method to my madness."

"Uh-huh." She returned her attention to the papers in front of her, and he waited for it.

Suddenly, her head snapped up again, and he knew she'd reached the first of two huge pronouncements.

Floored, Joss' brown eyes were wide as she stared across the bisque-colored tabletop at him. "You're giving Finch and I the power to decide…" she trailed off as if she didn't even want to finish the sentence.

"The legal power to remove me from life support if I'm ever incapacitated to that degree, yes," he finished for her. "I've also expressed the wish that you both become my Guardians if that ever becomes necessary."

With a vehemence that surprised him, Joss shook her head and pushed the portfolio away from her. "I can't do this."

Noticing that her hands were trembling slightly, he reached across the table and gave them a soft squeeze. "It's okay. I promise." He pulled his hand away and gently pushed the portfolio back to her. "Go on…keep going."

She looked at him for a long moment, the desire to argue with him evident in her eyes, but he could also see her innate curiosity getting the better of her. Finally, reluctantly, she lowered her head and resumed reading.

It didn't take long.

John knew the exact moment that she'd reached the biggest item in the document because she froze, her chest literally stilling as she sucked in a surprised breath and held it. Slowly, she closed the portfolio, the soft thwap that it made sounding impossibly loud amongst the ambient noise surrounding them.

Joss stared down at the onyx cover, not saying a word as time seemed to slow to a crawl. For once, he wasn't sure what she was thinking and was almost afraid to ask.

"Joss?" he said warily after a she'd been silent for almost a full minute. "Are you okay?"

She finally looked up at him, the telltale wetness in her eyes setting him back on his heels. "What do you think, John?"

"Given that you're going to become a very rich woman one day, I'd like to think you're happy."

Blinking back her tears, she shook her head incredulously, as if he'd just said something extraordinarily stupid. "You are so clueless sometimes, you know that?"

Mystified, John frowned at the irritation in her voice. He hadn't known what to expect when she found out that he was leaving her with an inheritance large enough to guarantee that she'd never have to work again, but it hadn't been…this. She almost seemed angry at him.

"I don't understand why you're so upset."

"Of course, you don't," she retorted, her voice low, but no less intense. "You don't understand why I'm upset because you don't expect anyone to give a damn." She slapped her hand down on top of the portfolio as if it had personally wronged her. "This isn't even you. You're not John Rooney. You're not even John Reese. You're John Lew—" Realizing what she was about to say, she cut herself off in mid-sentence, furtively glancing around the now crowded diner as if she expected to catch someone eavesdropping.

No one was paying them any undue attention of course, but at the moment, that was the farthest thing from his mind. He'd frozen in shock as the realization that she knew exactly who he was—who he really was—slammed into him. He was hit even harder by the knowledge that he didn't care. He liked the idea that she knew who he was before he'd turned into the killing machine that she'd come to know so well.

"So you know." It wasn't a question.

Joss nodded. "I've known since New Rochelle."

"You never told me."

"Would it have made any difference in our…" She paused, seeming to carefully weigh her words. "Would it have made a difference?"

"No," John answered without even having to think about it. And it was true. It wouldn't have.

Although he was curious to know just how she'd managed to dig up information the Agency had worked so hard to suppress, he held his tongue. Now wasn't the time. One day he'd ask and one day she'd tell him, but today wasn't that day.

Today, they had more vital things to talk about.

"Are you going to tell my why you're so upset that I'm leaving you all my money?" Placing his forearms on the table, he leaned forward, drawn to her despite himself. "You seem more upset about that than you do about being named my Guardian."

"I thought Finch was the rich one," she said in lieu of answering his question.

John sighed with exasperation, but decided to play along. For now.

"Finch is an incredibly generous employer and a magician at investing," he explained, fiddling with the handle of his coffee cup. "I used to give away nearly all of my salary, but after Riker's I decided that I wanted to do something more…important with my money."

"There's nothing more important than giving to charity."

"Yes…there is, Joss." John looked her directly in the eye, refusing to release her. "You. You're more important."

"John—"

He plowed ahead, unwilling to let her downplay what he'd just confessed to her. "You risked everything to get me out of Riker's. You risked everything to help with the numbers when you had no idea where we were getting our information. You trusted us…you trusted me…and for that you deserve the ultimate show of trust. So I'm leaving you everything I have. It's why I didn't make you an Executor."

"I don't know what to say." She looked distinctly overwhelmed.

"You can start by telling me what's got you so upset. If it makes you feel better, I'm leaving a substantial amount to several shelters around the city. And it's all legal, so you don't have to worry about that either."

"It's not the legality."

"Then what is it?" He wasn't going to let this go, even if they had to sit here all day. "If you ever need money, at least you know how to get your hands on some," he joked, hoping to make her feel more at ease about the bomb he'd just dropped on her.

It had the complete opposite effect.

Disapproval radiated off her body in waves as she visibly stiffened. She glared across the table at him. "That's not funny, John."

"Maybe if you tell me what's wrong, I wouldn't have to make bad jokes."

"Fine—you want to know?" Hands balled into tiny fists, she sat forward, mirroring his posture. "Thinking about your Will means thinking about you dying. And yes, I know it's irrational, but I don't care. I also know it's hard for you to accept the fact that people care about you." Her eyes were flashing at him now. "Well, too damn bad, John. If losing you means getting rich I don't want the money, okay? Is that clear enough for you?"

Despite her obvious irritation, John grinned. He couldn't help it. Knowing that this incredible woman cared about him so much was both humbling and gratifying. "Crystal."

"Good." She paused, then, "Are you sure you want to do this? What if you meet someone…?"

She let the rest of the question dangle in the air between them, heavy with unspoken—and likely unintended—meaning.

"I am and I won't," he answered with conviction, needing her to know beyond any doubt that he was serious. "And even if I did, she could never be you."

A light blush stole across her cheeks as she looked down and away before her eyes settled on his again.

"Thank you for thinking of me," she said softly.

"You don't have to thank me, Joss." He didn't try to hide the sentiment in either his voice or his eyes, wanting to let her know that she wasn't in this place by herself. "This is my way of thanking you for…everything."

"I don't want to have to collect for a very long time though."

"I'll do everything in my power to make sure you won't have to."

After a small hesitation, she ventured, "You promise?"

John answered without any hesitation at all, "You have my word."