Caroline's regret disappeared the instant that she stood up and Klaus's lips mashed against hers. As they kissed, Caroline once again was dragged into a surge of emotions that she would love to ignore.

Klaus only pulled away when he felt a high heeled shoe hit him in the side of the head.

"What the hell was that for?" Klaus asked, turning to glare at his sister.

"I called time like five minutes ago, but you guys just kept going," Rebekah responded. "And going and going and going…"

"I didn't hear," Caroline said honestly, knowing that if she were human a blush would be covering her face.

"Sure you didn't," Bonnie said sarcastically.

"I didn't," Caroline said defensively as the pair sat back down on the couch.

"Stefan, truth or dare?" Klaus asked.

"Dare," Stefan chose quickly.

A grin spread across Klaus's face as he said, "I dare you to do your version of the Charleston that you used to do all the time when you were drunk."

"No." Stefan and Rebekah said in perfect unison.

"Oh come on, you used to do it all the time," Klaus complained.

"I also used to kill people, but there's a reason that I stopped doing both," Stefan pointed out. "And I am nowhere near drunk enough for it. Besides, I wasn't the only one with a stupid version of it. I seem to remember you dancing just as horribly, just as often."

"So you're going to use one of your limits on a silly dance?" Klaus asked. "That we used to do all the time."

"Come on, Stefan," Elena said. "I want to see this dance."

"No," Stefan said sternly.

"Please," Elena begged. "For me?" She batted her eye lashes at him for dramatic effect.

Stefan grabbed his drink off of the table in front of him and chugged the rest before turning to Klaus and saying, "Only if I get to put my pants back on for this."

A grin spread across Klaus's face as he responded, "Fine by me."

"I can't believe that I'm doing this," Stefan muttered as he pulled his pants back on.

Once his pants were on, Stefan moved to where there was enough open space, sighed, and then began to do the dance causing everyone to laugh. By the time that he finished dancing, even Stefan was laughing like an idiot.

"I can't believe that I used to go out with you," Rebekah muttered. "And be seen with the pair of you,"

"His is even worse," Stefan pointed out as he took his pants back off and sat back down.

"Hey, that dance got me a lot of girls," Klaus argued.

"If anything got you the girls it certainly wasn't the dance," Rebekah responded. "They probably only talked to you because they thought that you were pretty and pitied you for being such a god-awful dancer. And because they were even drunker than you were."

"Klaus, your turn," Stefan said. "Truth or dare?"

"Dare," Klaus instantly responded.

"I dare you to your dance so that they can see that it was not what was getting you girls," Stefan responded with a smirk.

"It was," Klaus argued as Caroline slid off of him so that he could get up to dance.

Stefan hadn't been even slightly exaggerating about how bad the original's dance was. When it was done, Caroline was laughing hysterically as she lay across the whole couch blocking him from sitting down.

Long after everyone else's laughter had subsided, Caroline remained unable to stop herself.

"The only reason," Caroline said through her laughter as it finally began to die down a little. "That you ever got any girl after she saw that was because you're hot and she figured that after the other girls saw you dancing, there wouldn't be any competition."

Caroline managed to sit up as she calmed herself until she was no longer laughing, just grinning.

"Did you just call me hot?" Klaus asked with an arrogant smirk as he sat down.

"No," Caroline said, rolling her eyes as she sat back down on his lap. "I said that the only reason that a girl would talk to you is if she thought you were hot."

"No, I'm pretty sure that you said that the only reason that a girl would talk to me is because I am hot. And you're talking to me right now," Klaus responded happily. "Rebekah, truth or dare?"

"Dare," Rebekah responded.

"I dare you to cut up your favourite dress," Klaus told her with a smirk.

"No!" Rebekah shrieked, acting as if Klaus had told her to cut up her own face.

"Yes." Klaus responded, his smirk widening.

"Limit," Rebekah said through gritted teeth.

"Over a dress?" Klaus asked amusedly. "Fine, I dare you to let Damon cut up whichever one of your dresses he wants."

Rebekah narrowed her eyes at her brother. She didn't want to lose all of her limits while Klaus was still daring her, so she reluctantly muttered, "Fine." She turned to Damon and added, "I swear to god if you ruin my favourite I won't think twice about murdering you."

Damon headed upstairs with Rebekah shortly behind him. When they returned back downstairs, Damon was carrying a blue dress and a pair of scissors with an unhappy Rebekah right behind him.

"He said I can ruin whichever one I want, I'm not waiting twenty minutes for you to decide which one I can destroy," Damon argued. "Just be glad that I didn't pick the red one."

"But-" Rebekah stopped when Damon cut straight down the centre of the dress.

Damon decided that he had cut it up enough and stopped before Rebekah would snap and stake him. Damon simply dropped the remainder of the dress, put the scissors on the table, and then sat back down next to Elena.

"Oh calm down," Klaus said when he saw how angry Rebekah was. "He could have done a lot worse."

Rebekah shot her brother one last glare, and then turned to Elena with a smirk as she asked, "Stefan, truth or dare?"

"Dare," Stefan told her.

"I dare you to kiss me like you used to," She told him.

Without a single objection, Stefan immediately stood and headed towards her. That had been what he had been hoping to get away with since Rebekah had announced that they would be playing truth or dare.

Stefan placed his hand on the side of her face and pulled her towards him as he passionately mashed his lips against hers; within instants his tongue had found its way into her mouth.

The naked pair continued to kiss until Klaus threw the same shoe that had been thrown at his own head at his sister.

"Why'd you do that?" Rebekah asked after pulling away from Stefan.

"Because there's only so much that a brother can handle seeing. Either get a room or stop," Klaus told her.

Rebekah rolled her eyes as she sat back down where she had been before.

Stefan headed back to his spot, and then asked, "Matt, truth or dare?"

"Dare," Matt said.

"I don't think that Damon's kissed enough guys yet tonight," Stefan said with a smirk. "I dare you to make out with him for a minute."

"Oh come on," Damon complained as Matt headed over to him.

Matt reluctantly headed over to Damon and, after making sure that Rebekah would time it, he reluctantly pressed his lips against Damon's.

When Rebekah called time, Matt practically ran back to his spot before turning to ask, "Bonnie, truth or dare?"

"Dare," Bonnie chose.

"I dare you to let me take you to another room and blindfold you-" Matt began before being interrupted.

"Kinky." Damon commented, earning himself a glare from Matt.

"And then we'll choose someone and you have to figure out who it is just by touch when I bring you back," Matt told her.

"Still sounds kinky to me," Damon said with a smirk.

"Fine," Bonnie agreed, standing up and letting Matt lead her out of the room.

Matt tied her scarf over her eyes, and then Bonnie heard footsteps as he left the room. A few seconds later she heard his footsteps return, and then he led her back to the living room.

She heard multiple sets of footsteps as Matt made his way back to his spot and someone else walked over to her. The second set of footsteps lasted a few seconds longer, and then stopped in front of her.

Bonnie knew who it was before she even touched him. The other person was standing so close that she could easily recognize Jeremy just by smell.

That didn't mean that she couldn't pretend that she didn't know for a little while. Matt had just said that she had to figure it out just by touch, which meant that she would only be obeying the rules if she was to double check with her hands.

Bonnie reached out and felt her hand make contact with Jeremy's chest.

She slowly slid her hand up his chest and then up even more to cup the side of his face. She slowly stretched up to connect her lips with his.

After several long seconds of that, Caroline commented, "I'm pretty sure that she figured it out already."

"Maybe," Bonnie said with a smirk after pulling away from him. "I just wanted to make sure that it was Jeremy."

"Sure you did," Caroline said in a sarcastic tone as Bonnie removed her blindfold.

Bonnie and Jeremy went to sit down back and Bonnie was just about to ask someone else when two men walked into the room.

"What are you doing here?" Rebekah asked.

"Can't we come to celebrate our sister's birthday?" Elijah asked.

"So what is this, some kind of clothing optional party?" Kol asked with a grin as he pulled his shirt over his head and sat down on the couch in the empty spot where Caroline had been sitting before she had moved to Klaus's lap.

"We're playing truth or dare," Rebekah explained. "Everyone has three limits, if you use a fourth you leave."

"Well I guess that explains how Klaus got a girl in his lap," Kol said with a laugh, earning him an eye roll from the brother sitting next to him. "And hopefully his makeup situation… I'm in. But I won't be the one needing limits."

Kol grabbed someone else's drink off of the table in front of him and chugged the rest of it while Elijah continued to stand, looking around the room taking in the strange situation.

"Let me guess," Kol said, turning towards Elijah. "You're going to be boring and refuse to play… What kind of brother would you be refusing to play Rebekah's party game on her birthday?"

"Who said that I was refusing?" Elijah asked. "I was just trying to decide where to sit to be furthest from all of the naked guys and my naked sister."

A giant grin formed on Kol's face as Elijah sat down.

"Elijah, truth or dare?" Bonnie asked.

"Dare," Elijah chose.

"I'll give you an easy one," Bonnie said. "Shirt off."

Elijah stood, unbuttoned his shirt, dropped it to the floor, and then sat back down.

"Caroline, truth or dare?" He asked.

"Dare," Caroline chose.

"I dare you to take all of Klaus's clothes off," Elijah began. "You can use your hands until you get to his boxers, then you have to use your teeth."

Elena, who had been drinking when Elijah had spoken, began to choke on her drink in a combination of shock and laughter. Everyone had been expecting Elijah's dare to be something lame or at the very least mild. They were wrong.

Caroline got off of Klaus and said, "Get up."

"Someone's eager to get my pants off," Klaus said with a grin as he stood.

"Yeah, and it's your brother," Caroline retorted as she began to remove Klaus's shirt.

She dropped his shirt to floor, forcing herself to keep her eyes off of his chest, and then unbuttoned his pants, which she had to physically slide off since they were so tight. After that just his boxers were left, but Caroline refused to give anyone the satisfaction of her hesitating or showing her fear.

Instead she just crouched down and grabbed onto the elastic of his boxers with her teeth and began to pull them down.

Klaus stared down in awe as Caroline as she shimmied him out of his boxers using only her mouth. As she did so her eyes flicked up to meet his for just the shortest of seconds. Klaus wasn't sure if it was just the way that she was holding his boxers with her teeth, but he thought that he'd seen her give him a seductive smirk.

Once she had gotten his boxers down to his ankles, she let go of them and casually stood back up.

"Are you going to sit back down or just stand there smirking?" Caroline asked after a few seconds.

"You just can't wait to sit on me now that I'm naked, can you?" Klaus asked as he sat back down on the couch.

Caroline rolled her eyes at him before sitting back on top of him.

"Kol, truth or dare?" She asked.

"Dare," Kol chose.

Caroline knew that daring Kol to take his clothes off would just make him happy, so instead she decided to go in the opposite direction, "I dare you to put your shirt back on."

At first Caroline got questioning glances from some of the others in the room until Kol reacted.

As he put his shirt back on he grumbled, "I can't believe that I have to be the most clothed person here, even Elijah gets to wear less clothes than me."

At that point everyone was naked except for Kol, Bonnie, Jeremy, Matt, Caroline, and Elena (who was in just her bra and underwear). None of the girls were wearing overly covering clothes to begin with.

"Elena, truth or dare?" Kol asked.

"Dare," Elena chose despite her nervousness over what the original would ask.

"I dare you to take the rest of your clothes off and then strip someone of your choice," Kol told her. "It's not fair having the only naked girl be my sister."

Elena quickly removed the rest of her clothing, ignoring the stares from Kol and the Salvatores, and then began to head towards Caroline.

"You can't get the same dare twice," Elena said with a smirk as Caroline stood up, clearly understanding that she was the one who Elena had chosen. "So it looks like Klaus won't be able to dare you to put your clothes back on this time."

"You dared her to put her clothes back on?" Kol asked, turning to glare at his brother. "What the hell's wrong with you?"

Klaus didn't answer and Kol was soon distracted as Elena began to remove Caroline's clothes.

Once both girls were nude, they headed to sit back down without another word to each other.

Sitting on Klaus had become even more awkward for Caroline once they were both naked. Caroline made sure to sit even further down his legs than she had been before.

"Caroline, truth or dare?" Elena asked.

"Dare," Caroline chose.

"Not this again," Bonnie muttered to herself.

Meanwhile Damon and Klaus were both thrilled thinking 'Oh good, this again'.


A/N: Please read and review! Thanks for reading! Some of you said that you wanted Kol and Elijah, so here they are! If you have any dare sggestions that you'd like included tell me in a review and I might put it in.

A super special thanks to all of the lovely reviewers of the first chapter that motivated me to update this the next day: TOKILLAMOCKINGBIRDFAN, justine, ALD96, andreathelatinagirl, oehret, LiveEveryMoment, CharmedAndDangerous22, BiancaR, bunnykay, Lola, and the two anonymous guest reviewers :D