If you asked Puck when he became Puck he would have told you it was when his dad left him. But if you asked Noah when he turned to Puck he would have told you that it was when his true love Robin was taken away from him. But now that she is back. Puck is forced to face the truth that his love is not the sweet girl she used to be. Puck soon finds himself in a world of trouble, mystery and murder. I do not own glee. Season 1 rewrite.
Finn
People always wondered why Finn hanged around a guy like Puck. Those two were best friends since kindergarten. But no one knows that the only reason he hanged around Puck was to make Finn look like the golden boy. Finn knew when Robin ever came back she would be highly disappointed in Puck and run straight into Finn's arms. He hated how Puck got to her first. He knew he was better. He was the good boy. He was the captain of the football team. He was teacher's favorite. He was Lima's Golden Boy. So why did Puck get the most perfect girl in the world.
He knew he shouldn't be thinking about Robin as his since he gotten together with Quinn but the only reason he got with Quinn was to rub it in Puck's face. Since he knew Puck had wanted to bang the blonde. But Finn already knows that Quinn cheated on him with Puck. And he couldn't think of a perfect time for him to do it. It was because according to his mother, Robin had returned to Lima. Finn knew he could make this into his favor. Being the victim knowing that Robin would feel sorry for him and be highly disappointed in Puck. Finn knew it was wrong for him to be in love with Robin but he couldn't help it. He had been in love with her since he first saw her in kindergarten.
Flashback
Finn was excited for his first day in kindergarten. As he walked in the classroom he couldn't help but stare at the most beautiful girl he ever laid eyes on. She had tanned skin with chocolate eyes with a hint of grey. She had long wavy brown hair. And she had a bright smile on her face. She was laughing with a kid with a weird haircut. "Ummm Hi I'm Finn. And I just wanted to say that you are very pretty." Finn mumbled as he stared at the beauty but also aware of that the kid with the weird haircut was glaring at him. "Hi Finn. I am Robin. This is my best friend Noah. Umm thanks you are pretty cute yourself but I don't think Noah likes you calling me pretty, he gets pretty jealous." Robin replied with a small blush on her cheeks. "Damn right I don't. Listen here dude if you wanna hang with us you need to keep your eyes away from my girl. Alright? Plus its Puck. Only Robin can call me Noah." Puck sneered. Finn knew right then and there that this guy was going to be his rival for Robin's heart. So Finn gave a lope-sided smile towards them and sat down next to Robin trying to get to know them more. All thru the day Finn was basically found on the right side of Robin since the left side was Puck's place. Finn learned a lot thru out the day. Like Robin nicknamed was birdy by her grandfather. That Puck was going to married her when they finished college. He wasn't so happy about that one. Also learned that Robin was a really good singer and dancer. He even was surprised when he found out that she beat Rachel Berry in competition even though she was a last minute entry. But he knew right now if he wanted Robin he had to be her 2nd best friend. And hopefully pushed Puck out of her heart.
End of Flashback
Finn was walking to his first class till he heard yelling in the girls' bathroom. He saw Rachel ran out with slushie covering her. Knowing that Puck must have gotten to her again. He would go comfort her but he really didn't care about her. If Finn was being honest he only used her so that Quinn would cheat on him with Puck. Too busy watching Rachel run away he didn't notice that someone was walking across from him till he collided with her. Finn couldn't believe his eyes. It was the same loving eyes he dreamt about. Knowing that he can set his plan in motion finally because under him was her. The one he wanted along. Robin. "Hey Finn. Long time no see."
