The Apple siblings were horrified because Grand Pear is their maternal grandfather. Goldie told them that no one ever called their mom "Pear Butter" and her cutie mark was a preserved jar. Goldie wanted to tell them more about their family history, but was too busy with her annual cat-grooming, "Your Dad and his buddy Burnt Oak were thick as thieves in the old days," she continued, "Y'all should talk to him."

"Burnt Oak" Apple Jack replied, "The Fire Sales Pony"

"We haven't seen him back in a while." Apple Bloom recalled.

After they got back to Ponyville, they found Bright Mac's former best friend, "Burnt Oak" selling firewood. "We were wondering if y'all could tell us about our dad," asked Big Mac.

Burnt Oak explained that one time where they did a plowing contest and Bright Mac would've won if he wasn't distracted by Pear Butter's Beauty. He got so distracted, he accidentally knocked over the water silo. Bright Mac couldn't bare let Pear Butter, so he told Grand Pear everything. It was there that he started working on a new silo.

At the Sugarcube Corner, Mrs. Cake gave Athena and Ethan some complimentary milkshakes. "In the days when I was Chiffon Swirl," Mrs. Cake explained, "My best friend, "Pear Butter" and I did numerous baking tests together from taste testing to temperature. If it weren't for her, I wouldn't have gotten my Cutie Mark"

"Adorable" Ethan smiled.

"You want to know what's more adorable?" asked Mrs. Cake, "She explained her feelings to Bright Mac in a song. I hear Athena plays the piano. So maybe you can play the piano version of it."

Athena saw the lyrics and wanted to play it, "Now the question is" she asked, "Where am I going to find a piano?"

"PIANO DELIVERY!" shouted Athena, "PIANO DELIVERY"

"Pinkie," asked Ethan, "What are you doing here?"

"Mezzo Forte has broken her hooves and asked me to deliver pianos for her." Pinkie explained, "Mrs. Cake wanted a piano so they can have live entertainment at the Sugarcube Corner."

"That's perfect" Athena smiled as she started to play.

We're far apart in every way

But you're the best part of my day

And sure as I breathe the air

I know we are the perfect pair

On a prickly path that goes on for miles

But it's worth it just to see you smile

And I cannot be pulled apart

From the hold, you have on my heart

And even if the world tells us it's wrong

You're in my head like a catchy song

The seasons change and leaves may fall

But I'll be with you through them all

And rain or shine, you'll always be mine

On a prickly path that goes on for miles

You're the only one who makes it all worthwhile

And you should not blame me, too

If I can't help fallin' in love with you...

Athena cried tears of joy because it was the most beautiful country song she'd ever heard. "That's the good news," Mrs. Cake said as her smile turned into a frown.

"What's the bad news?" asked Ethan."

"Not long after that" Mrs. Cake replied, "The Pears decided to move."

Everyone was shocked, "I'm gonna go," Pinkie said as she left.