Olivia5k5: as u may tell I like to use PLL ideas in HOA stories

Izzi08: we all luv Jara

Fabes999: thnx I got the idea from PLL book 9

Luvhoa: thanks I think ur stories r awesome 2

SibunaMT: Thnx it's October the month of scariness

Alfie's P.O.V

I gasped as the ghost told Fabian and I the story of her death, I couldn't believe it my girlfriend, Amber Millington, was evil and wasn't even the real Amber she was Rosie. "Hey, guys what are you doing out here" A voice shouted, Rosie, I thought, the ghost quickly faded into the dark night. Well at least I'm not the only one with a murdering past.

"Beau, what are you doing out here?" Amber asked innocently, she flashed us a smile then turned to Fabian "Nina's looking for you" He nodded and walked away.

"I was just walking around, seeing how far you kept the dead" I lied, if she killed someone just to take over real Amber's life.

"Okay, come on karaoke's about start" Rosie dragged me back to her mansion. When we got back she ran to the stage and started singing Katy Perry's Last Friday Night. How can someone so innocent, be so evil, I thought.

Fabian's P.O.V

Two murderers, living under one roof, dating, this'll be fun. I thought bitterly, the rest of the night was a blur. When we got home I put on my pajamas and went to bed.

Fabian you must stop Rosie, she's getting suspicious of Alfie, she won't hesitate when it comes to killing someone, and you have to go to Isaac from Osiris house. He knows that Rosie and I are twins. I have to go, but you have to tell Alfie and Nina.

I shot up in bed, it was Saturday, so I ran up the stairs, into Nina's room, and woke her up. "Nina I need to tell you something" She stood up; I grabbed her hand and dragged her into my room.

"What?" Nina asked sleepily "You're acting like Amber" She rubbed her eyes, and stared at me waiting for me to start talking.

"Your roommate is a murderer" I blurted out; I covered my mouth with my hand.

"Amber's not Amber, she's Rosie Millington Amber's twin" I said.

"What are you talking about?" Nina asked, her head cocked to the side

I grabbed her hand and lead her to Alfie and Jerome's room, Jerome wasn't there, so it was just Alfie "Alfie tell Nina about real Amber, not our Amber" I told him, I sat down on Jerome's bed, Nina sat next to me and leaned her head on my shoulder (I forgot to say they're dating)

"The Amber we know is not the real one, and she's the twin, Rosie. In the summer of 6th and 7th grade when their mom said it was time to go Rosie ran downstairs saying "I'm Amber Millington and I'm fabulous" Amber raced after her but it was too late, they were piling into the car and left her, on winter vacation, they were playing dolls they both grabbed the same one, they started fighting for it, until Rosie walked into the kitchen, when she came back, Amber was sitting with her dolls, she pretended that one was Rosie so she tugged it's head off and after Rosie saw that, she stabbed Amber with a knife, Amber heard her laughing as she took her last breaths. Amber watched as her parents fell for her fake crying over her dead sister, they searched for a year until they found her in a hole, buried behind their house, under her pool and she had a proper funeral." Alfie explained, getting more nervous every second and looking at the door every-so-often.

There was a knock at the door, and Amber poked her head in "Hey, so I was going to check on Alfie cause he seemed kind of weird last night, but I heard you guys telling the story, and I just wanted to say, it was a joke" Amber explained, Nina jumped off the bed and hugged Amber.

"Thank God, you aren't really a murderer"

"Well come on, breakfast is ready" Amber said cheerfully and walked out the door.

I couldn't help, but feel like she was lying and had everyone wrapped around her finger. I looked at Alfie, remembering his secret. "I can't believe you" I said and stomped out of his room.

I walked into the dining room and saw Jerome and Mara holding hands and Joy and Eddie closer than usual and constantly kissing. Suddenly Patricia came in holding hands with a blonde guy. Mick was the only one alone "Um, when did everyone, but Mick get in a relationship?"

"Last night" They said in unison.

Amber's P.O.V

After breakfast I went to mine and Nina's room. I guess I should say I'm actually Rosie, I said I was Amber cause they locked me up in a mental hospital and when I came back I swore I would be the normal twin and it happened. I'm normal, well as normal as you can be when you try to keep the secret that I killed my twin sister and our neighbor who saw me do it.

Now let me tell you the real story, cause you can't tell anyone, so I don't care that I tell you.

I had just turned ten, Amber was the popular twin and I was the loser. We were swimming in our pool, when I had a perfect idea. I put my hand on her head and pushed her down, she tried to swim up, but I held her down, until I heard the back door open she sprang up quickly "What the hell is wrong with you!" My mom had thought she was me for a while, until our brother, Eric, reveled the truth, and then they sent me to the mental hospital.

Until the summer between 6th and 7th grade, I got to visit, our mom said it was time for Amber to go to her new boarding school, I stole her clothes, put them on, and ran down the steps yelling "I'm Amber Millington and I'm fabulous" As Amber came down we were piling into the car and drove off and well you heard the rest of the story. Why go over it again, right?

Amber puts finger to lips and the screen goes black

Ok chapter 2 is over, hmmm 2 secrets in this story and there's only supposed to be one weird right? Oh well