Wilbur walked to Carrie's house to try and talk with her. When he got there, Winnie and Wally were talking to Carrie.
"You have to take Wilbur back!" Winnie said.
"Why should I do that? He's a horrible person!" Carrie said.
"You were the only one that ever made him happy! He was the nicest brother ever when he met you. I saw him cry for the first time ever when he lost you!" Wally said.
"That's not gonna make me take him back!" She said.
"Please Carrie! I've been lost without you!" Wilbur said.
"What are you doing here?! I told you we're finished Wilbur!" She said.
Wilbur started crying.
"Carrie please, I didn't mean to yell at Willie in front of you! I'm so sorry." He said.
Carrie wasn't buying any of it.
"I don't want to date a guy as mean as you!" She said.
At this point, Winnie knew her plan to help Wilbur get Carrie back wasn't going to work, so she decided to head home. However, she wasn't paying attention and tripped on a rock. She fell into the pond near Carrie's house and tried to get out, but she couldn't.
"HELP! HELP!" Winnie screamed. Wilbur and Wally started freaking out.
"Winnie doesn't know how to swim! Someone help!" Wally yelled.
Winnie began sinking in the water. Wilbur took off his shirt and ran to the pond
"HANG ON WINNIE!" Wilbur screamed diving into the pond. He grabbed her before she sank to the bottom and they both resurfaced. Winnie coughed up water and began crying loudly because she thought she was gonna die. Wilbur pulled her out of the pond and for the first time ever, hugged her.
"Shhh, it's okay little sis. You're safe." He said.
Winnie hugged Wilbur tightly.
"W-Why did you save me?" Winnie asked.
"Believe it or not little sis, I love you very much. I don't know what I would do if I lost you." Wilbur said.
He kissed his little sister on the forehead and Carrie teared up at the heartwarming moment. She walked over to Wilbur and kissed him on the cheek.
"That was amazing my zing!" She said.
Wilbur was surprised. Carrie called him her zing!
"Let's try this again. I missed you so much! Let's start dating again!" She said.
Wilbur smiled.
"I missed you too!" He said.
The two noticed Winnie was still coughing and crying.
"Bring her inside. My dad knows how to deal with this stuff." Carrie said.
"Thanks, come on Wally!" Wilbur said.
Wilbur carried Winnie inside the house.
"Dad! Come down here, it's an emergency!" Carrie called.
Carrie's father, Arthur, came down the stairs.
"What's going on?! What are you doing here?!" He asked.
"My little sister fell in the pond! She's not looking too good." Wilbur said.
Winnie continued coughing up water.
"Lay her down on the sofa and give her some room." Arthur said.
Wilbur walked over to the sofa, laid Winnie down, and stepped back. Arthur walked up to her.
"Hey there, you feeling okay?" He asked.
Winnie coughed and said "Not really."
"Just lay still. I'll call your parents." Arthur said.
"Is my baby sister going to be okay?" Wilbur asked.
"She'll be fine. Just give her some rest until your parents get here." Arthur said.
"Okay." Wilbur said.
"…You're my hero, Wilbur." Winnie said.
"Shh, don't talk, rest up. Mom and Dad will be here soon." Wilbur said.
Arthur went to the kitchen phone and called Winnie and Wilbur's parents. An hour later, Wayne and Wanda walked in and hugged Winnie tightly. Winnie and Wilbur's younger siblings were with them, but they had no idea what was going on. Once Winnie felt a little better, she sat up on the sofa and looked at Wilbur.
"Wilbur's the best big brother ever!" She said. This surprised everyone, especially Willa, Wanye, and Sunny.
"Why do you say that sis?" Willa asked.
"He saved my life!" Winnie said.
All of Winnie's younger siblings gasped.
"How did he save your life sis?" Wanye asked.
"I was walking by the pond near Carrie's house and fell in! Wilbur pulled me out before I sank to the bottom!" She said.
"Wow! That must have been scary sis!" Willie said.
"It was! I thought I was gonna die!" She said.
Willie went over to Winnie and hugged her tightly.
"I'm glad you're safe big sister! I don't know what I would do if I lost you." Sunny said.
"Me too!" Willa said.
Wanda went over to Wilbur and hugged him.
"I'm proud of you for saving your sisters life Wilbur." She said.
"It was nothing. I did what any other big brother would do." Wilbur said.
Winnie went over to Wilbur and hugged him tightly.
"No Wilbur, you're a hero. I'll always be grateful for what you did. I'm lucky to have a big brother like you!" Winnie said.
Wilbur smiled, returned the hug, and kissed Winnie on the forehead.
"Thanks sis." He said.
Everyone teared up at the heartwarming moment between Wilbur and Winnie, especially Wayne. He never thought he'd see the day when Wilbur and Winnie finally started getting along. Everything worked out in the end. Wilbur was a hero, he got his girlfriend back, and his family respected him now. Things couldn't be much better for him, until a little mishap that occurred between him and Carrie a few months after they got back together.