Disclaimer: First of all this story is collaboration between Me, Wizardly Vampirefied, Secondly we DO NOT own Glee; it belongs to Ryan Murphy and Fox. Thirdly please review, it makes us happy.

Summery: Will and Carl were best friends since Middle school, but when something happened between them in college, they stopped hanging out. What happens when Carl comes back and is now dating the woman Will is madly in love with, Emma, and the people around them slowly start to uncover Will and Carl's secret past.

Chapter 2: Woke Up New

Beep beep beeeep. 'Oh God, turn that infuriating contraption off.' Beep beep beeeep. 'Someone turn off that damn radio!' Beep beep beeeep. 'FUCK! Shut the fuck up you fucking alarm!' Beep beep beeeep.

"FUCK!" Carl shouted, waking up from his beautiful slumber. It was 8am on a Monday morning, meaning he had psychology in two hours. He opened his eyes and looked over to Will's bed, which was made neatly and sported both of their clothes. 'Odd but not unusual. Will is a clean guy.' He took in a deep breath and let the tempting smell of coffee awaken him fully. "Will?" He asked, getting out of bed. Feeling his balls move freely, he realised he was fully nude. 'Oh my. Well, Will won't care.' He stood up and walked towards their wide kitchen to find himself with Will's ass. 'That's weird. He's naked too.' "Hey, bro!" Will turned around, exposing his full naked body. His eyes widened at seeing his best friend Carl nude.

"Carl! Uh, why aren't you wearing pants?" Will asked.

"The same could be asked of you, no?" Carl replied, walking over to grab a mug with coffee. He smacked Will's butt playfully. He sat in the living room and grabbed the paper. Will walked over and sat next to him.

"Carl, do you remember anything of what happened last night?" Carl laughed.

"Of course I do, Will! We went to a party and got hammered, came back here, got naked, and slept." Will stared at him intently.

"Slept. What do you mean by that?"

"Slept. As in the action of sleeping. As in the action of closing your eyes, falling unconscious, dreaming, and waking up the next day."

"Oh. Is that all you remember?"

"What is this, 20 Questions?" Carl asked, adjusting. He lifted his leg up, unconsciously giving Will a full view of his junk.

"Carl." Will's eyes gazed from his crotch to his face.

"What? Did my dick grow three inches overnight?" Carl asked sarcastically, looking down at the circumcised best friend between his legs.

"Carl." Will shut his eyes. "There's a video you need to see." Will walked over to the TV and pressed play on the camcorder. A video of Carl and Will popped up.

Carl stared at the flat-screen in amazement and disbelief as he and Will started a 69 and worse, ended it. Carl shut his eyes after, moving from the couch to the loveseat.

"Turn that shit off." Carl said, grimacing.

"That's where it ended." Will said, turning off the TV.

"Dude, what the fuck happened? I'm not a fucking fag!"

"I'm not either. But what happened last night was weird."

"Last night? That's what happened?"

"Yes, Carl. Last night we blew each other."

"How the FUCK did that happen?" Carl asked, bolting up.

"I don't know." Will replied, looking down. He hated himself for letting something so stupid like that happen. But it wasn't only his fault. Carl was the one that pushed him on the bed and started first. Will just followed along. 'Don't tell him that, Will. We don't want to cause more of a disaster.' When Will looked up, Carl was standing in front of him, now wearing jeans and an 'Ohio State' shirt.

"Where are you going?" Will asked.

"First off, can you please cover your dick?" Carl asked in disgust. Will looked shocked. Carl has only said that the day they discovered Will was uncircumcised, and it was because Carl thought it was weird. "Second, I'm going to class. You know, the place where people learn how not to do stupid shit?"

"You're not blaming this on me, are you?" Will asked accusingly, standing up.

"It sure as hell wasn't my idea." Will bit his tongue and watched Carl open the door and leave their dorm. He wasn't happy with Carl at all, but he understood why Carl felt that way. Will grabbed the camcorder to delete the video, but let it play once more. He surprised himself when he realised his member's reaction. 'Oh fuck no.' Will shut his eyes angrily and then looked down at the stiff appendage. He then stormed into the bathroom, camcorder in hand.

Carl stormed out into the streets of Columbus, he still had 2 hours until his class started and had no real places to go, He walked slowly through campus, so lost in his thoughts that he didn't notice the blonde woman jog up behind him.

"Hey Carl" Terri said, trying to make eye contact with him. "Are you okay?" She asked when she noticed that he was avoiding her cheerful gaze.

"Yeah Terri, I'm-I'm fine" He stuttered

"You sure?"

"DAMN TERRI, COULD YOU JUST STOP BEING TO DAMN IRRRATATING AND LEAVE!" He shouted and left her standing in the middle of the sidewalk.

What is his problem? She thought to herself. Maybe Will would know.

Terri turned quick on her heels and headed towards Will and Carls dorm.

Will threw his head back as he sat on the toilet seat. In his left hand was the camcorder; his right hand grasping his member. "Oh yes." Will moaned. He stroked himself rapidly and grunted, his inner animal coming out. He clenched his teeth and tightened his grip, feeling a rush inside of his body. He thrust his hips as he came, letting the wave of tranquility take him over. He slowly opened his eyes to see his girlfriend Terri stares back at him, shocked.
"Uh, hi, Terri"

"Hey, Will, What ya got there?" Terri asked with a knowing but still curious look on her face.

"Uh, What, oh this? This-This is n-nothing" He stuttered, still in shock.

"Oh really?"

"Uh yeah, don't worry about it" Will pulled his boxers up and quickly left the bathroom, hoping to leave the awkwardness behind.

"So, I ran into Carl before o came over here"

"You don't say, uh what he say?"

"He seemed really pissed; he yelled at me, do you know whats wrong with him?"

"Oh, oh no I-I don't-"she started, Will looked down at the camcorder that was still in his left hand. "And it defiantly has NOTHING to do with whats on this camera.

Terri stared at Will for a minute and watched as he tried to avoid her gaze just like Carl had done only 30 minutes earlier. "Will?" she finally asked

"… Yes?"

"Whats on the camera?"

"What camera?"

"The one in your hand"

He looked down at the camera "Oh this camera! Oh there's nothing on THIS camera" Will said nervously

"Oh, then you wont mind if a do this!" Terri walks up and snatches the camera from Will's now weak grip. She paced around the dorm room watching the footage in awe. When the tape finally ended, Terri stopped and looked up at Will. It was silent for a moment but Terri was the one to finally break the silence.

"What is this, Will?"

"I can explain, Terri, it's not what you think"

"Okay, I'm not mad, Will but what happened? Is this why Carl is so pissed?

"Yes, that's why"

"Okay, so how'd it happen?"

"Alright, well we went to that party last night and we started drinking, a lot, we started drinking a lot, we were talking to this girl and when she left we decided to come back here I guess and one thing lead to another…: he looked down :That's what happened"

Terri walked over to him and placed a hand under his chin, forcing Will to look at her.

"What would you say if I told you that you sleeping with another guy is kind of hot? She giggled

"Terri! This is serious and that's gross" Will couldn't help but laugh along with her

"Well you need to talk to Carl about this if you plan to get your friendship back"

"I know Ill talk to him after his Psych class.

Terri gave Will a short but passionate kiss on the lips and left the dorm room, quietly laughing to herself.

Carl hasn't been able to think about anything other than that video all day, he isn't gay, he knows that, there are many different women who can confirm this, it was just a one time mistake, a mistake that isn't worth losing an awesome friendship over, but why is it bothering him so much, he'll never know.

The door to the dorm slams shut as Carl tried to release some of his frustration, he spotted Will sitting on the couch and let out a breath he didn't know he was holding.

"Hey" Will said, keeping his eyes on the television screen

"Hi" Carl replied, his voice barely audible

Will stood up and looked at Carl "Hey, man, I think we need to talk about… well you know" he said staring at his shoes.

"Yeah"

"So, I was thinking that we should just put this whole thing behind us and move on"

"…"

"I mean… it was a one time thing and a mistake so, what do you say?"

"Um, well, I g-guess we can do that" Carl looked up at Will with a smile "We cool, Bro?"

"Yeah we're cool" Carl put his hand up for a high five, Will looked at Carl than Carl's hand and back at Carl and laughed, slapping his hand forcefully.