Evy woke up sputtering and coughing. She was so confused as to why she was wet that she wasn't scared. Not at first. Once she had opened her eyes, she realized that she wasn't in the motel room where she'd fallen asleep. She didn't remember Sammy picking her up and moving her, and she couldn't see or hear him either. Just as she was about to really feel scared, an unfamiliar voice spoke.

"Get up, kid."

Evy scrambled to the nearest wall. She finally got a good look around. She was in what looked to be a jail cell, with nothing but a bed inside. She had Squish, and she squeezed him to her tightly. Just outside the cell was a man she had seen before, but she couldn't quite remember where. He was looking inside at her, and she asked with a shaky voice,

"Who are you?"

"Don't worry about that." The unfamiliar man said. "First, tell me who you are."

"No." Evy said. She was trying to be brave but it was hard. "I not supposed to talk to strangers."

"Now look here, kid." The man said impatiently. "I'm not going to hurt you. Not as long as you do what we tell you."

Evy scrunched her eyes in confusion. "Who's we?" she asked.

"Uh uh. You first." He said. "Who are you?"

"I'm not telling you that." Evy insisted.

"Alright. Fine." The man said. "Let's see how much you have to say when I come back."

"You're leaving me here alone?" Evy asked quietly.

The man laughed. "What? Are you scared?" He looked Evy up and down. She looked tiny and frail, certainly no match for anything. "It's no surprise. Little baby like you."

As scared as she was, Evy immediately went on the defensive. "I'm not a baby!" she said loudly.

"Whatever, kid." The man said. "Look, just tell me who you are and I'll bring you something to eat."

Evy finally remembered where she'd seen the man before. "You were at the motel when we got our room tonight."

"Yep." He said simply.

"Where's my family?" Evy asked. "My daddy and brothers?"

The man suddenly started to smile. When Sammy smiled at her, or even Daddy or Dean, it made her feel better when she was scared. But not this time. Evy knew that, no matter what he said, the man would try to hurt her at some point. Evy squeezed Squish tighter.

"Your family asked me to take you." He told Evy. "They waited until you were asleep and begged me to do it."

She'd been trying not to cry, but Evy couldn't help it now. "That's not true!" she said, her first tears starting to slip out. "They love me. They wouldn't do that."

"Whatever, kid." He said. "I'll be back."

The man turned and walked out into another room. Evy was sniffing and crying more and more. She was scared and shaking. She wanted Sammy to pick her up and hold her, tell her that everything would be okay. She knew he hadn't let her be taken, and that he and Daddy and Dean were looking for her. But until they found her she had to be brave.

"I'm scared, Sammy." She said. "Come help me, please."

Evy wiped some more tears away, before looking down at Squish in her arms. Some of her own tears had fallen on his face, and he was still wet from when the scary man had poured water on them to wake her up. But to Evy, Squish was crying too. Evy thought of Sammy again, how he would wipe the tears from her face when she was sad or scared, and she decided to try that now for Squish.

"Don't be scared, Squish." Evy said brokenly as she wiped his face. "Sammy'll find us. I'll keep you safe till then."

Evy pulled Squish to her, wrapping him in a hug. She started crying harder, until she got an idea. She took some deep breaths to try and stop crying, then started singing to herself and to Squish.

"Don't you feel it growing, day by day, people getting ready for the news…"

Evy eventually fell asleep again, clutching Squish tightly to her, and praying hard for someone to come and help her.