A/N: First of all thanks to all the reviews and alerts, they totally made my week. Thanks to my new beta Aura Sleepless for all her help, I really appreciate it. With that said sit back relax and enjoy.
Chapter 2:
"What?" Asked Finn, looking confusedly at all of his fellow gleeks. He had hoped for some support from them, but instead Sam and Puck looked like they were about to kill him. He never would have pegged them as homophobes. The rest of his "friends" (if he could call them that anymore) were just staring at him with their mouths gaping open. Even Tina and Mike, whom he had talked to at Breadstix on Friday night and had promised to help him, were just sitting there frozen.
"Not cool, you guys. I really expected you to be a little more supportive about this."
"Damn Hudson, not you too!" Puck growled angrily at his former best friend.
"What? What did I do?" Finn asked, feeling even more confused than before.
"Finn, it's just that you, Puck, and I just made the same confession and request to everyone in this room." Sam explained, trying to keep his cool.
"You mean you-?" He asked, pointing at Sam.
"Yeah." Sam responded, nodding his head.
"And you?" Finn said, now pointing at Puck.
"Head over heels for the princess, yeah," responded the mohawked jock.
"Damn it, Puck! First Quinn, then Rachel, now Kurt too!" Finn shouted, feeling queasy. "Are you going to go after everyone I'm interested in my entire life?"
In the far left corner of the choir room sat Lauren Zizes, opening a box of bonbons and whispering to Artie sitting next to her. "This is so much better than last week's episode of 'Gossip Girl'!" She said, to which Artie's only response was a roll of his eyes.
"I was interested in Quinn way before you, Hudson, you just made your move first and I decided to walk away. And Berry threw herself at me, not the other way around." Growled Puck. "I'm not gonna make the same mistake with Kurt. I'm not letting you have him without a fight." He said, stepping closer to Finn. "Besides, you are brothers now, Hudson. It's like incest or something. You should just give it up."
"It is not! I already asked my mom."
"Dude! You told your mom?"
"Not exactly..."
~~~
Hudmel Household
Saturday 1:45 pm
Finn stormed into the kitchen, looking for his mom. He had just realized that having these feelings for Kurt might be wrong since they were brothers now. And he really needed redemption, especially after what he had just done with Kurt's shirt.
"Mom, can I ask you something?" Asked Finn, trying to stay calm.
"Sure, what is it honey?" Carole responded, looking up from counter were she was chopping up onions for dinner.
"Uhhmmm..." He started. It took him a few moments to figure out the right way of saying this without giving himself away. "I have these two friends, Kinn and Furt, yeah that's it, and Furt really really likes Kinn, especially since he's been away for a while. But he is afraid of doing anything about it 'cause their parents just got married to each other and it might be incensuous"
"Incestuous, honey, and it wouldn't be wrong since they don't share the same blood. It'd be a little weird, especially for their parents, but not wrong" said Carole, looking at Finn skeptically.
"GREAT! Thanks mom!" Finn said hugging his mom tightly and kissing his her on the cheek, his face brightening up with a huge smile.
Finn was about to walk out of the kitchen when his mom said "Finn, honey, you know you can tell anything at all and I'll always love you no matter what, right?"
"I know mom." He said as he flashed his mom one last lopsided before leaving the room.
"...but that's not the point, dudes." Finn said but abruptly stopped when he heard Mercedes squeal into her cell phone.
"OMG, Bo, you are not gonna believe what just happen in Glee!" Mercedes started. "No, Puck didn't knock somebody else up."
Puck and Sam both froze as well when they realized who the sassy diva was talking to.
"No, Sam hasn't finally come clean about his hair yet. I know, I know. I don't know who he thinks he's fooling either."
Everything seemed to move in slow motion at this point for all three jocks as they all turned to face Mercedes. "Would you let me finish, white boy? Your new brother, Puck, and Sam just said..."
Mercedes never got to finish her sentence. Finn had taken the cell away from her and held it, looking at it as if it were a grenade about to go off. His eyes opened wide when he heard Kurt's voice calling, asking for his friend to continue. He panicked and threw the phone to Puck, who threw it to Sam as soon as it touched his hands.
Sam just stared at the phone in his hand his heart beating fast as he heard Kurt's voice calling out. He brought the cell up to his ear and could have sworn that his heart had been replaced by a humming bird for beating so fast as he said "Hello, Kurt."
Kurt's angelic voice came through the other line and, for a moment, he forgot everything. It took him a minute to realize that Kurt was asking him where Mercedes was. "Oh she... she had to go... help Tina clean up. She's just been slushied as she walked into the choir room". He lied, stepping back when he saw the furious look on Mercedes face as she tried to get up. Luckily Puck and Finn were smart enough to try and stop her.
"Oh, nothing important, she'll call you back later. Bye!" He hung up with a gulp when he saw Mercedes' face.
"What the hell is wrong with you guys?" Shouted Mercedes angrily.
"Sorry, Mercedes, we just want to be the ones to tell him how we feel." Said Finn, taking a cautious step back.
"Okay, I get it white boys. But don't think he has forgotten about the whole mess in the basement, Gigantor, or the whole duet thing either. He might forgive you, but a little serenading at your parents wedding ain't making him forget." She growled while poking the tall jock in the chest. Finn tried to mumble something about being afraid and jealous.
Puck couldn't stop himself from laughing at the terrified look on Finn's face, which turned the sassy diva's attention on him. "Oh, and don't even get me started on you, Puck, with your slushie facials and dumpster tossings." She said, glaring at him while she went up to Sam to retrieved her phone. The diva yanked her phone out of Sam's hand and glared at all three jocks.
"Fine, I won't say anything to him. For now. But don't expect any help from me. Kurt is my man, and I don't think any of you are good enough for him. If you were, you would have done something while he was still here. But I do want my Boo back, so I'll stay quiet, at least 'til he's back. Besides, you guys got two big problems before you can bring him back here and start wooing him. One is Karofsky. Kurt is not coming back as long as he is here. And two, Blaine. Now that's your main competition." The sassy diva ended.
All three of the jocks trapped Mercedes in a big hug, thanking her for her promise to remain silent.
Mr. Schue walked into the choir room at that moment. "Guys, please have a seat. I have an announcement to make." He said as everyone else sat down.
"Mr Schue, I swear, if you say you're in love with Kurt too, I'll burn this room down." Said an irritated Santana.
He gave her an awkward look and continued. "Okay... not exactly. It is about Kurt, though. I really think we should try to get him to come back. His voice gives the Warblers a wider vocal range, and, with that, a better song selection. We are lucky they weren't wise enough to use him during Sectionals, but we can't take that chance with Regionals."
Getting up from his seat, Puck threw an arm around Mr. Schue's shoulder and walked him towards the door.
"I'm so glad we are on the same page, Mr. S. Why don't you talk to Ms. Pillsbury or Ms. Holiday while we plan this out?" Puck said. Mr Schue tried to complain but Puck sighed "Mr. S., we are about to do some things that go against school rules, and, honestly, you are a pretty bad liar. So why don't you go for a bit while we take care of things?" He continued as he pushed Mr. Schue out of the choir room, locking the door behind him without giving the teacher a chance to complain.
Puck turned around with a wicked grin on his face, looking at all his fellow gleeks, and said "First stop, Karofsky. Artie, I'll need to borrow your wheelchair for a little while, my man. Let's get this party started."
I really hope you guys enjoyed this chapter. I still haven't decided who is gonna end up with Kurt, so let me know who you think is more worthy of him. Please Review they always make me smile.