A/N: Chapter two! Hope everyone is liking the story, especially this chapter because I was not pleased with how the Sam and Artie thing was handled in the lights out episode and I wanted them to apologize for being douchebags. Also, I know I usually go with the whole "Marley is the victim and Ryder is the knight in shining armor" thing, but I wanted to try something new with this story, especially after the vulnernability that Ryder showed during lights out. Anyway, I own nothing related to Glee and I would love it if y'all could leave a review :)

Ryder's POV

Katie, I'm done with this! You keep blowing me off and expect to keep whatever this is up. I don't know if I can trust you anymore.

Ryder typed into his phone's touch screen, hoping that maybe "Katie" would finally reveal his or hers true identity.

A few seconds later, he received a reply. What's wrong babe? the message read simply. Ryder groaned in frustration. Before he could reply back, he was interrupted by someone. He turned around to see Mr. Schue, who tapped him on the shoulder.

"Hey Ryder, do you have a few minutes to chat?" he asked him.

"Um, yeah. I guess. What is this about?" Ryder asked as he followed him into the choir room.

"I just wanted to see how you're doing after what you said a few days ago in Glee club about being molested." he prompted.

"Oh, I guess I'm doing fine." Ryder shrugged.

"Okay then, you mentioned that you wanted to tell everyone before the person you told could reveal it to the whole school, why do you think that person would do that?" Mr. Schue asked him as they sat down on the stools.

"I don't know, but this person's been good at getting me to tell every single detail about my life and I feel like I don't even know them anymore." Ryder said stiffly.

"If I may ask, who is this person you're referring to?" he asked.

"I don't know. She was just some girl who friended me on Facebook after Valentine's day. We started talking, and things sort of got out of control." Ryder mumbled.

"Wait, you've never met her face to face? Ryder, why would you trust her then?" the teacher questioned.

"I don't know, I guess I was lonely. I mean, I pretty much got rejected by the only girl I've ever liked and her boyfriend just sort of rubbed it my face. Talking to Katie was like talking to Marley, except that Katie actually gave me the time of day." he replied, turning red at the last part.

"Ohhhh, I see." Mr. Schue replied sympathetically. "I know what that whole thing feels like, the same thing happened with me and Ms. Pillsbury only differently. Unrequited love sucks, doesn't it?" Mr. Schue chuckled. "So do you have any idea who's behind this?" he asked.

"No. I almost thought it was someone in the Glee club when a phone went off when I tried to call Katie during the lockdown, but I asked everyone and it wasn't them. It could be someone lying to me, but who would do something like that?" Ryder replied.

"I don't know. But I'll help you get to the bottom of this and make sure they get punished for this." Mr. Schue promised. Then, they were interrupted by the sound of two people entering the room. It was Sam and Artie.

"Hey, I hope we weren't interrupting anything." Artie asked.

"No, not at all. I'm glad you guys dropped by." Mr. Schue replied.

"Anyways Ryder, we wanted to apologize for being douche bags. We didn't realize how that could mess with you and all the girls ripped us a new one and we realized that what we said was really insensitive. It took a lot of balls to admit something like that and we shouldn't have turned it into a joke." Sam said sincerely.

"Um, thanks guys, it means a lot for you to say that." Ryder sighed.

"Yeah, and we didn't realize that it hurt even more after the whole catfish thing and we wanted to let you know, that we'll also help you find out who's doing this. Blaine and Marley are also helping, so we should be able to find the culprit in no time." Artie said confidently.

"Why are you all helping me? I mean, this is my problem, I don't want to burden you when we should be focused on regionals." Ryder mumbled.

"Because, it's not cool to use someone like this Katie chick has been using you. And we're a family in this Glee club. We all sort of lost focus on that when we ignored Marley's eating disorder during sectionals, and we lost because we forgot to look out for each other, and that's not happening again." Sam replied.

"Thanks guys, but the only way we're ever going to find Katie, we're going to have to get the dude who hosts Catfish to help." Ryder said dejectedly.

"No we don't. Just trust us. We'll find the catfish." Artie replied.

"Okay then, where do we start?" Ryder said as he felt his spirits lift with Artie and Sam's confidence.