Noah and I were walking back to the choir room thinking everyone was still going to be there. We turned the last corner and I gripped his hand tighter suddenly afraid of what was going to happen. I was going to have to explain to Finn that I can't marry him and that if I would have it would have been a big mistake. How is it possible to deliver news like that without hurting the other person? You can't. Noah squeezed my hand back as he walked through the open door and I followed him hiding myself from the others for as long as possible. I quickly noted that Finn, Quinn, Mike, Tina, and Mr. Shue were the only ones left in the room before Finn got to his feet and started walking towards us. The only other time I had ever seen him so mad was when I told him the Noah was the father of Beth and not him. "You have got to be kidding me? Rachel, you are seriously throwing everything we have away because you had one dream about Puck?" Finn yelled motioning to my hand wrapped around Noah's. "This isn't just about the dream Finn. I have always had feeling for Noah; I tried to keep them deep down because I truly thought you were the one for me but I was wrong. I'm sorry Finn but I never should have agreed to marry you." I told him and gently as I could because I did love Finn as a friend and wanted to hurt him as little as possible He didn't seem to grasp that though. "You can't be in a relationship with someone like him. He sleeps with anything that walks and doesn't know the true meaning of love. Just wait until he decides he is done with you and he will drop you just like all of the others." Finn spat at us and I felt Noah start to move towards him. I put my free hand on his forearm then to warn him to stay still and sighed a little when he took the hint and moved back. "I'm not going to leave her and she is not just a random hook up. I have always had feelings for Rachel and I won't let you stand in our way anymore." Noah said as Finn started to walk towards him pulling his fist back. Mr. Shue stepped in then and made us all sit down.

"You guys just need to calmly talk this out." Tina commented and I saw Finn turn around angrily towards her. "We don't need your opinions! Why are you even here?" He asked and soon regretted it when he saw the anger in Mike's eyes for snapping at Tina. "Hey! Don't you dare snap at her! We are here to support you guys because believe it or not, we are the most stable couple in the whole school and know what we are talking about. First, we have been in a love triangle before and sadly someone does get hurt and in this case it is you Finn. Second, don't try to change their minds. It is obvious Puck and Rachel are happy together so just let them be." Mike finished and everyone just stared into different areas of the room for a minute. "Are you guys completely sure about this? Do you really want to make a big decision like this based off a dream?" Mr. Shue asked us when we had calmed down a bit. "I'm completely sure about this and my decision isn't just because of the dream." Noah answered still holding my hand in his lap. "Puck, are you saying that you have had feelings for Rachel this whole time?" Noah started nodding his head before he started to talk. "Yeah I have, I don't know why but Rachel has always been at a different level than any other girl. I would do anything for her." He finished talking and looked back over to me wiping a tear from the corner of my eye. I didn't realize I had started to cry. "Oh please you are just saying that!" Finn cut in rolling his eyes at Noah's comment. "It's true. Puck chose glee over football, all of the kisses, and extra things he did were for her. Puck never would have sung Run Joey Run if it would have been me or Tina asking him to do it. And don't forget that it was Puck that was leading the attack on Jesse two years ago." Quinn said looking at Puck with a smile.

"I just want to know why staying here with me is such a terrible thing but you be more than willing to do it for him?" Finn asked as the shook faded away and all that was left was hurt. "It's not the thought of being here that is wrong, its being here with you. Staying in Lima with you means that I would have never gone to New York and I never would have been able to try for my childhood dream. I knew you never wanted to go to New York but I thought I could change your mind. It was wrong of me to try. It wasn't fair for me to drag you on through my dream and never let you have one of your own. For that I am very sorry Finn. Noah is different though, he wants to try his talent out in the world as well. He knows what it's like to dream about seeing you name in lights and wants it just as bad as I do. I'm not saying I want to stay in New York forever but I do want to live every second out there that I can." I replied hoping he understood. "You would really go with her to New York?" Finn asked Noah. "I will be going to New York with her even if that means having to work as a bartender every night." Finn stood up then and nodded his head a little. "I understand why you did this but it doesn't mean I'm ok with it just yet." I stood up and walked towards him slipping the ring off my finger and gently laid it in the palm of his hand. "I'm very sorry Finn", I said giving him a hug and he gently wrapped his arms around me. His arms fell as I pulled away and he headed straight for the door with everyone else following behind shortly after. "That went better that I thought. What do you want to do now?" Noah asked me while he picked up our bags. "Let's go for a ride." He said to me holding his arm out for me and we walked out to his truck.

I pulled into an empty space on the lookout hill to the far north of town. Grabbing Rachel's hand, I opened my door and climbed out of the cab. I put the tailgate down and climbed into the back with Rachel. She settled down in a spot in between my legs. We sat there for a minute not talking but just enjoying the silence and each other's company. "What are we doing Noah?" She asked me in a quiet voice that I almost didn't hear over the wind. "I'm not sure Rachel. I know what I want and that I'm in love with you though." I answered back and then kissed the top of her head. "I love you too Noah, I'm sorry it took me so long to realize it." I told him as I turned around to face him and running my hands over his Mohawk. "I'm sorry for being a jerk to you. Do you have any plans set up for New York?" I asked her. "I plan on moving into an apartment this summer with Kurt and you. I will attend NYADA and audition for plays and shows in my free time. What do you plan on doing in New York with me?" "Well even though I will be attending school to be a coach just in case." I told her giving her my best smile causing her to lean her forehead against mine. "I would still like to try my hand at being a musician. Is that crazy?" I asked her and she just shook her head back and forth a few times. "Not at all, I think you would be a brilliant musician and I can't wait for our future to happen." She admitted before she pulled her face to mine and started to kiss me again. "What happens if you have a dream tonight about your sorority girls? Will you forget about me?" She asked trying not to blush or look embarrassed. I pulled her face into my hands and kissed her nose. "It won't happen, Rachel. I am in love with you and that isn't going to change ever. I'm not leaving you no matter what. Do you understand babe?" She nodded as fast as she could with tears rolling down her cheeks and I pulled her in so I had her lying on the truck bed and I was leaning on top of her.

We had been making out off and on for a few minutes before I noticed how dark it was becoming and that we needed to head back to the school. "We should probably head back. I have to watch Emma tonight while my mom is at work." I told her and we started to make our way back into the truck and headed to the school parking lot so she could pick her car up. "Do you want me to pick you up in the…" I started to ask her when her phone started going off. "Santana sent me a text. According to her Jacob has already posted on his blog about us." She told me and I started internally cursing him. Rachel pulled the blog up on her phone so we could read it real quick.

Jewfro here! The new gossip around McKinley is the Rachel Berry has dumped Finn Hudson for the other hot jew of the school Noah Puckerman. This rumor has been confirmed by a few students as well as the camera that I have hidden on the theater stage. I will let you know if any new details come up but I'm sure tomorrow will be quite horrible for the two young love birds.

"Oh no, everyone is going to pick on me tomorrow!" Rachel said starting to panic by pacing back and forth in between the two cars. "Babe it is ok. We will get through tomorrow no problem and if anyone comes near you, I will kill them. I promise." I told her as I held onto the top of her shoulders. "I love you no matter what. Nothing any stupid person says will change that." I told her as she started to cry again. "I love you too Noah. I better get going so I can tell my dads the news before they hear about it from someone else." I helped her get into her car and waved to her as she drove off.

I made it to my house and saw my mom and sister sitting in the living room. "Noah you're here!" Emma shouted jumping up and giving me a hug. "Yeah, yeah now go upstairs and brush your teeth for bed." I told her as my mom just stared at me. "So I got a call from Carol this afternoon. Would you care to tell me how you broke up Finn and Rachel's engagement?" She asked and I sat down next to her knowing I wouldn't be able to avoid this conversation. "What do you want me to say mom? I love her and she loves me. I'm not going to apologize for that." I said as I sat back on the couch rubbing my hands over the top of my head and face. "I'm not going to tell you to apologize, Noah. You just need to think about what you are doing and be careful but between you and me… I couldn't be happier! I think Rachel is wonderful and just think of the adorable grandbabies you two will give me." She said as she started to grab her bag and head out the door. "I will see you tomorrow." Blowing me and Emma, who had just come back from the bathroom, a kiss before closing the door behind her.

I was laying in bed thinking about everything that happened today and couldn't help but smile. Less than 24 hours ago the girl that I had a crush on but didn't really know it was engaged to another guy and I was miserable. Now my future is bright and great all thanks to the small burnet and the dream from last night. I sent Rachel a text then as I was starting to fall asleep. Good night babe I will pick you up for school in the morning. I laid there just staring up at my ceiling when I heard my phone go off. Can't wait Love you night. I turned over and fell asleep with a smile on my face.

I don't own anything Glee just love the show! Thank you so much for your great comments! It was going to be a one-shot story at first but decided to extend it because of the comments! Thanks