Chapter 2: Natsu…

Lucy sat up and crossed her legs. Natsu repeated the action.

Lucy's thought, I just did this. I always wanted this, but why now?

Natsu- "Are you okay Lucy? This was your first time, right?"

Lucy- "yes, I am okay."

Natsu- "what is next, for us? I want to be with you, but I know you just started dating Gray. If you want to be with him, I understand. What did this mean to you because it..."

Lucy kissed Natsu, before he finished his sentence, and he kissed her back.

Lucy-" idiot, why didn't you tell me you wanted to be with me before?" Natsu "I don't know, I guess, I thought you wouldn't feel the same way." Lucy- "I did feel the same way." Natsu- "Do you still?"

Lucy- "I don't know, I am confused right now. I know how I feel about you, but there is still Gray. I don't want to hurt anyone"

Natsu- "You can't make your decisions around anyone else. You should decide what you want, what makes you happy, and who makes you happy. If that's me, that would be amazing, because I am crazy about you Lucy. I really like you a lot."

Lucy- "Thanks Natsu" Lucy pulled Natsu to her and kissed him again. They both lay down, on her bed, and start making out.

At the guild

Gray is sitting by himself at a table.

Cana- "where's Lucy? She is normally here right now."

Gray- "Haven't seen her today." Gray sighed. "I'm going to see if she's home soon."

Gray walks out of the guild. He starts thinking about why Lucy isn't there. We were supposed to meet at the guild by now. I hope she's okay. Gray starts to walk faster, towards her place, with that last thought.

By the time he got to her place. The door was unlocked. He opened the door and went in.

"Lucy? Are you there?"-Gray

Lucy- "oh crap, I forget about Gray."

Natsu- "what do you want me to do?"

Lucy- "I don't know, hide"

Natsu- "okay"

Natsu hid by the side of her bed. By the time he was down, Gray reached her room. Lucy had gotten some of her clothes on, and she pushed Natsu's clothes, that were on the bed, to the floor where Natsu was.

Lucy was left mostly naked under her covers. Gray- "we were supposed to meet at the guild by now." Lucy- "Ah I must of over slept" she yawned.

Gray- "then you are okay?" Lucy- "yep" they both smiled. Lucy- "I should get dressed and we can go back to the guild." Gray- "Or, we could stay here like this." Gray sat on the bed and leaned down to kiss her. Gray's shirt was already off. They closed eyes. She kissed back and then remembered Natsu.

Natsu was still here. Natsu, the pink haired boy, that she had a magical night with. Natsu, the one she liked before Gray, the one who saved her, the one who drove her crazy, challenged her, and changed her in more ways then one.

In that moment, she realized who, she wanted to be with. She pulled away from Gray. He looked kind of surprised, but then he saw Natsu's scarf.

Gray- "Is this Natsu's scarf?"

Lucy- "yeah about that…"

Gray- "What is it doing here?" He knew that Natsu always showed up unannounced, but he never leaves without it. Is he here?

Lucy- "Gray, look, I don't think this is really going anywhere, you and me. I like someone else, and I think I'm starting to fall in love with him." Gray- "Natsu…"

Natsu was still hiding near the bed. He smiled at the love him part. He heard his name and sat up just on basic reflex.

Gray- "Natsu, what the heck! You better love her, or ill kick your ass. I want to for this, but Lucy's happiness means more to me. I won't fight you because of her." Natsu- "yeah, like you could beat me. I do love her though." Lucy smiled.

Gray- "Don't push your luck. I would win." Natsu and Grays stood next to each other. Natsu had flames surrounding him and Gray had ice.

Natsu- "

Lucy- "guys stop, this is unnecessary." Both stopped and looked at her. "I am sorry that I hurt you, Gray, but I am following my heart and its going towards Natsu."

Gray- "you don't need to apologize Lucy. I get it, you have known Natsu longer and have a special bond that we will never have. I am going to go back to the guild. Bye Lucy." Gray left her place. Walking away hurt Gray, a few tears fell and turned to ice.

A few hours later/

Natsu and Lucy cuddled under the sheets. They were both in a minimal amount of clothes after they had sex.

Flashback

Natsu- "you sure about this Lucy?"

Lucy- "never been surer about anything." Natsu smiled and kissed her. He flopped on her bed and started kissing her. He kissed her lips, her neck, and he was so gentle. Everything that just conspired between Gray, it all went away.

Lucy started taking of what little clothes she had on. He did the same. She turned to be on top of him. She gently slid down and he moved her to a spot where it fit just right. He guided her as they both started to form a rhythm. They went faster and faster. Lucy moaned a lot. Natsu grunted. They both were finishing completion. She exploded and him not far after.

Lucy collapsed, onto Natsu, breathing heavy. She turned on her back. Natsu pulled her to him, and he put his arms around her.

End flashback

Natsu- "I love you Lucy"

Lucy- "I love you too Natsu"

They kissed.

They decided to stay in for the day.

They kissed and talked till they fell asleep.

They wake up, a couple hours later, from hearing Happy say "Natsu!"

Authors note: I originally was going to stop around the Lucy choosing Natsu part, but why not write another sex scene, so I wrote one. I have Ideas for another part to the story, but I am not sure if I should start another story like a sequel to this story. Or if I should write more chapters here? Thoughts?