A/N: Back for second part of story. This is my 40th story and I decided to dedicate this to my fellow Smytheberry shippers. You know who you are. :) Enjoy!

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee, characters or song lyrics.

Six months later in New York...

Rachel was in the loft and had his gotten off work at the Spotlight Diner as a Singing Waitress. She was busy with school, work, auditoning for roles on Broadway. She was awaiting to hear about results for her second callback for Beauty and the Beast. She was auditioning to play Belle. Brody Weston was auditioning to play The Beast. It has been six months since the day she left Lima, Ohio behind along with family, friends, and most importantly Sebastian. When she first got on the plane she hated him for what he had done. But, as time went on she realized how hard it must have been for him and how much he loved her. This is how a man loves someone. Didn't make her feel better though.

She tried to date but could never get Sebastian out of her head or her heart. Rachel was in her room getting dressed to go out with Kurt, Sam, and Blaine. They were headed to a popular NYADA hangout, Callbacks. Best Karaoke spot around.

Kurt: Diva will you please hurry up!

Blaine: Kurt, hun, please calm down.

Sam: I'm a little short in cash.

Blaine: We got you covered. *whispering to Sam*"plus we have a surprise for Rachel. Or someone special acrually. She needs to hurry up.

Sam: Who? Finn is in the Army.

Kurt: Not Finn...

Sam: Oh?!

Blaine: Ahhhh...

Rachel finally emerged from the bedroom in black high shorts, heels, black tank top and white jacks. Her hair was cascading in waves and wearing light make-up.

Sam: Wow Rach, you look sexy as hell.

Kurt: Why you never dressed this way in high school I'll never know.

Blaine: Lets get going!

Rachel: I'm coming, I'm coming.

Blaine: Who knows if all goes as planned you'll be screaming that later!

Rachel:*smacking Blaine playfully * Blaine Devon Anderson! Perv much?

Sam: Puck and Santana have corrupted him.

Rachel: *singing* Don't you want me baby...

Blaine: Hahaha

A half hour later, the group of friends were at a table near the stage at Callbacks. It wad Rachel's turn with Sam.

I Told You So (A/N: Carrie Underwood/Randy Travis)

(Sam)
Suppose I called you up tonight
And told you that I love you
And suppose I said I wanna come back home
And suppose I cried and said I think I've finally learned my lesson
And I'm tired of spending all my time alone

(Rachel)
If I told you that I realized you're all I ever wanted
And it's killing me to be so far away
Would you tell me that you love me too
And would we cry together
Or would you simply laugh at me and say

(Rachel)

I told you so

(Sam)
Oh, I told you so
I told you someday you'd come crawling back and asking me to take you in
I told you so
But you had to go
Now I've found somebody new and you will never break my heart in two again

(Rachel)

If I got down on my knees and told you I was yours forever
Would you get down on yours too and take my hand
Would we get that old time feeling
Would we laugh and talk for hours
The way we did when our love first began
Would you tell me that you've missed me too

(Sam)
And that you've been so lonely
And you've waited for the day that I returned
And we'd live and love forever
And that I'm your one and only
Or would you say the tables finally turned

(Rachel)

Would you say I told you so

(Sam)
Oh, I told you so
I told you someday you'd come crawling back and asking me to take you in
I told you so
But you had to go
Now I found somebody new and you will never break my heart in two again

(Rachel)

Now I found somebody new and you will never break my heart in two again

Rachel hugged Sam, and bowed to the crowd who were applauding.

Announcer: We have one more and this person wants to be anonymous for some reason.

Rachel walked to the restroom, and soon someone approached the stage. As she came out of restroom she heard a familiar voice coming from the stage.

?: I would like to ask someone special to join me on stage. Rachel Berry, will you come help me with this song?

Rachel looked up and saw a tall, dark haired man with beautiful eyes and that smile..she took in a sharp breath..it couldn't be...

Rachel: Sebastian? How? *she looked at her friends who smirked* you guys knew?

Kurt: Yes Diva.

Blaine: Surprise!

Sam: Go get your Warbler!

Sebastian: Rachel? Please?

Rachel didn't know what to think or how to feel. A part of her wanted to hit him and then kiss him until there wasn't a tomorrow, and the other wanted to run away.

"Remind Me"
(A/N: Brad Paisley with Carrie Underwood)

[Sebastian:]
We didn't care if people stared
We'd make out in a crowd somewhere
Somebody'd tell us to get a room
It's hard to believe that was me and you
Now we keep saying that we're okay
But I don't want to settle for good not great
I miss the way that it felt back then I wanna feel that way again

[Sebastian:] Been so long that you'd forget the way I used to kiss your neck
[Rachel:] Remind me, remind me
[Sebastian:] So on fire so in love. Way back when we couldn't get enough
[Rachel:] Remind me, remind me

[Rachel:]
Remember the airport dropping me off
We were kissing goodbye and we couldn't stop
[Sebastian:] I felt bad cause you missed your flight
[Rachel and Sebastian:] But that meant we had one more night

[Rachel:]
Do you remember how it used to be
We'd turn out the lights and we didn't just sleep
[Sebastian:] Remind me, baby, remind me
[Rachel:]
Oh, so on fire so in love
That look in your eyes that I miss so much
[Sebastian:] Remind me, baby, remind me

[Sebastian:] I wanna feel that way
[Rachel:] Yeah, I wanna hold you close
[Sebastian and Rachel ]
Oh, if you still love me
Don't just assume I know

[Rachel:] Baby, remind me, remind me

[Rachel:] Do you remember the way it felt?
[Sebastian:] You mean back when we couldn't control ourselves
[Rachel:] Remind me
[Sebastian:] Yeah, remind me
[Rachel:]
All those things that you used to do
That made me fall in love with you
Remind me, oh, baby, remind me

[Sebastian:]
Yeah, you'd wake up in my old t-shirt
All those mornings I was late for work
Remind me

[Sebastian and Rachel ] Oh, baby, remind me

[Rachel:] Oh, baby, remind me, baby, remind me
[Sebastian:] Yeah, you'd wake up in my old t-shirt
[Rachel:] Remind me, yeah, oh
[Sebastian:] Baby, remind me

Rachel had tears streaming, she remembered every moment and every second with Sebastian. No matter how many times she wanted to forget him, she couldn't.

Sebastian: Do you know how much I love you?

Rachel: Remind me...

Sebastian smiled and pulled Rachel into a hard kiss. The crowd cheered. They continued to kiss and Sebastian held her not wanting to let go.

Rachel: How long are you here for?

Sebastian: Forever...if you will have me?

Rachel: What do you think?

Sebastian: I'm home, where I belong. I'll never let go again. I love you Rachel Barbra Berry, hopefully Mrs. Smythe-Berry.

Rachel: I love you too. Now you can continue to remind me at home how much you want me.

Sebastian smirked. "Lead the way baby."

They walked past the guys and smiled.

Sam: Hurt her, I break you.

Blaine: Get a room you two. I don't want to hear you.

Kurt: Use a condom, and a muzzle for meerkat.

Rachel: A muzzle won't be necessary or actually it could be..*winking at Sebastian *

Blaine: Scandalous!

Sebastian: Kinky!

Rachel: Shut up and kiss me Sebastian.

Sebastian kissed her.

Blaine: My eyes! You're dead Smythe.

Sebastian: What a way to go though..pure bliss. Later Klaine and Trout Mouth.

Sebastian picked up Rachel bridal style leaving Callbacks.

Rachel: Is this necessary?

Sebastian: May as well practice the Future Mrs. Sebastian Smythe-Berry.

Rachel: I love the sound of that.

Sebastian: Me too.

*Kiss*

Rachel: We are endgame, Smythe.

Soon arrived at home and well you know what happened from there...

The End

A/N: I hope you enjoyed the story! Happy 40th story to me lol jk