Warning: Disturbing sex scene
This story was equally written by myself and kpb1spoby
Spencer
"My friends are probably looking for me" she panted.
"No they're not, they know exactly what you're doing. You can cut the innocent virgin act, no one's buying it" Noel said as he untied her bikini. She closed her eyes as he pulled down her bottoms and pulled her all the way underneath him and entered her. For a guy that thought he was he was some kind sex god he had no idea what foreplay was. In the six months or so that they had been together she was pretty sure he hadn't once touched her clit. He never gave head and if she even hinted at it he acted offended and blew it off. Of course he got it all the time. As he pumped into her she wondered why she was even still with him. No she knew why. He was Noel Kahn no one broke up with Noel Kahn.
"What's the matter with you?" he asked "You're all quiet and shit"
"Nothing" she said because if a woman isn't acting like an animal in heat there must be something wrong with her. It couldn't possibly be that you suck at getting anyone off but yourself.
She pulled him close "Oh Noel" she whispered in his ear while simultaneously rolling her eyes "just keep going, I'm almost there." she put her hand between them so she could touch her own clit since she knew he wouldn't.
"Oh yeah" she cried out as she finally came with Noel cumming right after. They redressed as they got out of the car.
They walked into the party just as it was getting started. She could see all the usual people walking around, this was just the same as the last party and Spencer wanted to be here even less than the last party. This was going to be hell, she had to put on a pretty face and push through. Hanna was by the table in a black thin tank top and it looked like she had her tongue down some random guy's throat.
Spencer made her way into the kitchen and Alison was in there and it seemed that she had been waiting on her the whole night.
"Hey Ali." Spencer smiled.
"Hey Spencey," Ali usually didn't call her that unless she knew something that Spencer didn't.
"So what's the what?" She said taking a sip of her screwdriver.
"Oh nothing" she said still all smiles "where were you?"
"With Noel, doing my girlfriend duties" she said to rub it in because she knew Ali wanted Noel. Her smile faded.
"Have you seen Aria?" She asked in a lilting voice.
"No" she said firmly "I was with Noel"
"Find her!" She said "I need to talk to her"
"Okay" she said rolling her eyes and turning around and leaving.
"Have you seen Aria?" she asked around until someone pointed out the petite brunette that was currently being pinned against a wall by one of Noel's lacrosse buddies.
"Aria" Spencer said going over to her. "Ali wants you"
"For what, tell her I'm busy" Aria said drunkenly.
"Ok" she said pulling her away from the guy "I'm doing this for you and tomorrow you will thank me"
Spencer traced her way back to where she left Ali while holding Aria up. When she got back to the kitchen she was nowhere to be found.
"Hanna" she said pulling her from her flavor of the minute "Hanna!"
"What?!" she snapped irritated.
"Have you seen Ali?" she said.
"I think she is in the bathroom" Hanna said going back to her boy toy.
Spencer nodded tiredly, after she found Ali she'd find Noel and have him take her and Aria home.
Spencer went to the bathroom that Hanna had pointed to.
"Ali" Spencer called before entering the room. She was sorry she opened the door, no strike that she was sorry she had even come to this party. Noel, her noel had Ali bent over the bathroom sink fucking her from behind and from the looks of it he did know what a clit was for after all. Ali had a smug look on her face and Spencer could tell she had planned this. Spencer turned refusing to cry in front of them as she began to walk out of the party.
"Baby, baby" Noel called chasing after her. "Look it's just a party, we're all just having fun, it didn't mean anything" she was out into the parking lot before Noel caught up to her. He grabbed her arm.
"You believe me don't you?" he asked.
She nodded slightly not saying anything.
"Come back to the party" he said.
"No I'm tired I'm going home" she said pulling her arm away.
"Suit yourself" he said going back into the party.
Toby
Toby sat as he thought about Spencer, they had talked for the first time that he could remember. She was gorgeous, of course he knew that, he had always known that. Tonight just seemed like everything about her was heightened.
The shape of her body and the way that she walked. The simple little things he noticed. All the things that made him ache for her. The way her chestnut brown hair cascaded around her breasts. The way she looked when she leaned over and her pants wrapped around her hips. The way every time she wore a skirt with those knee high socks all he could think of was running his hand up her legs.
He knew that he would never have a chance at her. One, she has a boyfriend, Noel Kahn. Two, she was way out of his league. She just made everything look simple and easy. She was a popular girl that had a popular boyfriend and friends. If they were dating he would be the best he could be for her, he would care for her emotionally and physically. He would cherish her body always, he would hold her as much as she needed and kiss her in all the right places to make her feel loved.
He could just imagine how her body would feel against his. He knew it would feel heavenly, her skin would feel like silk. After thinking about being with Spencer made him horny, he was hard and needed to fix it.
He knew that Jenna was home and no one else was, she was one to always come onto him and thought it was perfectly fine. This was a time that he needed her, even if he still thought he was fucking Spencer.
He made his way into the house and up the stairs to Jenna's bedroom. The light was still on, she was still awake. The floorboard creaked almost as if it was trying to warn him not to do what he was about to do. He entered her room and closed the door locking it. She gave a knowing smile at the bulge in his sweatpants. She stood from the bed and was surprised when he yanked the tank top over her head and shoved her down on the bed yanking her panties down swiftly before dropping his pants and getting on top of her. He put a hand over her mouth. He didn't want to hear the things she would no doubt have to say about this. He didn't want to be called a "dirty boy" or a "naughty perv" like the way she always did. If it was really Spencer he would take his time and make sure she was completely satisfied and that she enjoyed every minute of it. It wasn't though and it wasn't like he was practicing. This was simply to get his hard on to go away. He thrusted into her roughly not caring if she enjoyed it or not. Although the way she was rolling her hips he was pretty sure she was enjoying herself. He let his moans out not bothering to hold them in the way he normally did. He just kept picturing Spencer until he finally came. He rolled off of her and panted as he started to put his clothes back on. She had an evil smile on her face. He was hoping to leave before she could elaborate.
"Look at what I've done to you toby, look at what I've turned you into, it felt good didn't it?"
He left the room disgusted with her and disgusted with himself. His next therapy appointment was Tuesday and he knew it was time to come clean.
On Monday morning Toby was at his locker when he heard a couple semi popular girls talking.
"Well I heard from Sherry that she walked in on Noel with Ali and they haven't talked since, I think they are going to break up." one of them said as if she had some authority although he highly doubted that any of Alison's posse had ever even so much as yelled "Move" at them.
"I heard that Spencer spent all of Sunday bawling her eyes out and torching his stuff." her friend added.
The buzz quieted down to nothing when Spencer entered the hallway. She looked pretty put together but he could tell with the dark circles under her eyes that she had had a long weekend.
Spencer
Emily and Aria showed up. Aria leaned against the lockers next to Spencer's and Emily put an arm around Spencer.
"Hey Spence" Ali said as she approached her friends. Hanna was standing behind Ali.
"Hi Ali" she said digging out books for her first class.
"We missed you at the beach yesterday" she said as if she genuinely wondered why she hadn't been there.
"My parents are really on me about these grades" she said "I needed to play catch up. I'm sure I didn't miss much" Besides you and Noel fucking behind my back some more.
As if thinking about him made him materialize Noel was behind her. She knew without looking that every student in the hall was watching them and however this played out it would be texted and whispered throughout the school in a matter of seconds.
"Hey baby" he said as the girls gave them some room. Noel put his arms around her waist.
"I am so sorry" he whispered in her ear before kissing her neck. "I was racked with guilt all weekend"
She said nothing in response.
"I have to get going" she said firmly.
"Are we okay?" He asked not letting go of her. "I couldn't live if I thought I hurt you"
"You didn't" she said simply. "I like to have fun too"
The remark left Noel stunned which had been her intention.
Toby
Toby fumed through the rest of the day. Noel had had the audacity, the fucking nerve to cheat on the most perfect girl in the world, and even more to go back to her and act like he was the victim. Toby didn't even know what he was doing when he purposely ran into him.
"Watch where you are going freak!" Noel said shoving him. That was all he needed. Noel had technically "thrown the first punch". Toby punched him a few times in the face before pushing him up against the lockers and sucker punching him. After that teachers pulled up them apart as the principal showed up fuming.
"Kahn! Cavanaugh! In my office! Now!" He yelled.
"He started it" Toby said once they were in the office. Their dads had arrived and they were telling him what happened.
"Principal Greene, does it look like my son started it?" Mr. Kahn said pointing to Toby who didn't even have a scratch on him.
"He shoved me" Toby said.
"He ran into me intentionally" Noel said angrily. As the principal went to speak his phone rang.
"Hmm….hmmm...interesting….okay thank you" The principal said before hanging up.
"Mr. Kahn, you are suspended for three days" he ordered. "Mr. Cavanaugh, next time I suggest that you be the bigger person, another violent outburst like this will not be tolerated, no matter who started it."
"Principal Greene," Noel said exasperated. "Look at me and look at him how am I the only one getting suspended?"
"I have a witness that said not only did you start it but you provoked him as well." The principal said.
"You're lucky," his dad said as they got in the car. "You have a bad temper and you need to control it."
"I know," he said "you won't have to worry about me much longer"
"What is that supposed to mean?" his dad asked.
"Nothing." he said staring straight ahead.
"You can tell me things I hope you know that," he said. Toby was sure this was his therapist's influence.
Okay, let's try it. "Dad, I've been boning your stepdaughter for the last 10 months, do you feel better now? Didn't think so."
"I know" he said flatly.
"I know I'm not normally the mushy kind but I love you Toby" he said sincerely.
"I love you too," he said, "no matter what happens."
Spencer
"Come on, Hastings, I got my ass kicked and I got suspended for it. The least you could do is give me a little." Noel said as he tried to put his hand up her shirt for the third time.
"You didn't get enough at the beach party." she asked angrily.
"Look babe, I didn't want to cause a thing between you and Ali but it was all her idea. She said you've been screwing some college kid on the side and you wouldn't care if we fucked." he said staring into her eyes. "You're the one I love she was just a piece of ass."
"If you love me then you'll wait for sex until I can trust you again."
"I just remembered I have to go do something," Noel said collecting his things from her bed where she was studying and getting ready to leave.
"Tell Ali I said hi," she said as he reached the door.
He left without another word.
The next morning Spencer asked her mom if she could stay home from school today. She agreed but told her she'd need a death certificate to get out of her therapy appointment this afternoon. Spencer rolled her eyes nodding. She knew if the school hadn't insisted on Spencer getting counseling that her parents never would have done it. They didn't believe in counseling. In fact when her friends asked her where she was going or what she was doing she was to say she had a private tennis lesson.
It was a warm summer-like afternoon when her mom pulled up to the doctor's office. Spencer was wearing a white tank top and a navy blue skirt with white knee highs and sneakers.
"Do you want me to come in with you?" she asked as she tucked a lock of hair behind her ear. She had a look of concern etched on her face.
"No, i'll be fine" she said.
"Ok, I'll be at that coffee shop down at the strip mall getting some work done. Call me when you're ready."
"Ok" she mumbled getting out of the car.
She followed the directory to the office. There was one person in the waiting room.
Toby Cavanaugh.
Spencer was all of a sudden a deer in headlights.
Shit shit shit! If he tells anyone at school I'm in therapy, I'll be a laughing stock. Calm down Hastings it's not like he hangs with your circle. Who would he tell? And who would believe him?
I decide I can't run and he's already seen me anyway. I sit there playing a game on my phone. I can't text or use any of my social media because I'm supposed to be playing tennis. I wait for the doctor to come out and take him away so I can breathe and not feel awkward.
It is the longest ten minutes of my life when the door finally opens and I sigh. I look up and the terror goes through me again as I lock eyes with Mona Vanderwaal.
She is the reason I am here. Well technically Alison was the reason I was here. She was the one that had actually cut Mona's hair but Ali had made it look like I did it and no one would go against her and tell the truth. Did the school counselor know that Mona went to this therapist? Surely there was some kind of conflict of interest in her counseling both of us.
Instead of going to the exit she walks over to Toby and sits whispering something to him. He in turn whispers something to her. I'm outnumbered here. I may be one of the most popular girls at Rosewood High but here, I am the outcast.
What do you think will happen next? Will Spencer dump Noel? Will Toby come clean with the therapist? Tune in next time to find out!
Please review and let us know what you think!