Previously on Who to Choose?

・ Klaus, of course, wanted to kill Tyler, not only for vengeance but also, just maybe the chance to finally win Caroline's heart without Tyler being a distraction. The thing is, Tyler wasn't a distraction at all... Caroline was already in love with Klaus whether she wanted to admit or not.

・ It was set to pounce on us, teeth bared; its mouth was so open, that its gums were completely showing on the top and bottom. I wanted to run so badly, but I knew it was faster and it would catch us if we did.

・ Tyler suddenly revealed himself, walking up to them. Caroline ran towards him and kissed him all over his face; she was so happy. Though Tyler wasn't really showing happiness back towards her... She kissed him on the lips, but he wasn't kissing her back.

・ "I would kick your ass," Hayley cut her off mid-sentence, threateningly as she walked towards Caroline, a smirk spread on her face, "but I'm sure telling you to stop kissing my boyfriend will hurt you ten times more."

Who to Choose?

Chapter Two

Dear Diary,

Yes, you heard right, Hayley and Tyler were together. Can you believe that? He ran away from Caroline just to be with Hayley... Who would've known Tyler would be such a jerk? Actually, we did know this, but when he started with Caroline, he started to change. I guess he really didn't change. His true personality was hiding behind his fake one.

By just looking over at Caroline, I could see that her expression held confusion, depression, anger, and jealousy. She didn't know whether to cry, to scream, to fight Hayley or slap Tyler. She was just so dumbstruck, and she looked so hurt.

Seconds later, as soon as she realized that what was happening right in front of her was real, if she hadn't done it, then I would have. She went up to Tyler and slapped him across the face as hard as she could. Her face was starting to scrunch up again, ready to cry, but I could tell she stayed strong. She didn't want to look weak in front of Tyler. She wanted to look angry, disappointed, so he knew how much he broke her heart.

His face had only moved to side a little from the force exerted from Caroline's slap. His cheek was red and when he lifted his head back up, he cracked his neck and chuckled. He looked down at his feet, nodding his head.

"I guess I deserve that," he looked right back up at her, making direct eye contact.

Hayley was starting to charge toward Caroline and fight her for slapping her new boyfriend. This is where I had to step in. I walked right in front of Hayley, separating her from Caroline. I pushed her back a little with my left hand against her shoulder.

"Where do you think you're going, dog?" I hissed those words out to her. Never had I despised someone so much right now as much as I hated Hayley for being such a slut and stealing Tyler from Caroline.

"Why, Tyler, why? After I searched for you for months!" Caroline yelled at him, still not believing that Tyler betrayed her this way. "Was everything we had a lie? Were your feelings for me a lie?" her voice started to crack, but she kept her composure.

"No, no, no, no," Tyler got closer to Caroline and rubbed her arms up and down with his hands, trying to comfort her. "What we had was real, Care. I will never forget what we had," he looked directly into her eyes again to show her how sincere he was. "I just think that Klaus will never allow you and me to be together. He's going to track me down twenty-four/seven, and that's just not a life I want to live. I don't want to be scared to be with my girlfriend; I don't need someone in between and manipulating my relationship and my life."

Caroline shook her head. "So you only think about yourself," she nodded her head, chuckling sarcastically, "you never even thought about my feelings! What I wanted! No, you just go and run away with the first slut that appears on your doorstep! I thought you were better than that, Tyler."

"What the hell did you say about me, bitch?!" Hayley tried to push her way through Elena but to no avail. "Get out of my way!" she screeched at Elena and tried to punch her.

"You're not going anywhere near Caroline," I commanded, "you go near her, I kill you, so if I were you, I'd stay right where you're standing until they settle this... this situation," I squinted my eyes at her with hatred.

Caroline walked away from Tyler, shaking her head. I could tell she didn't want to speak or even look at him again. She was completely done with him.

"I have nothing else to say to you," she almost said in a whisper, her back faced towards Tyler, and her down, looking to the ground. "I don't ever want to see you again, Tyler. Go run away with your slut and never come back to Mystic Falls."

Tyler was about to complain to Caroline, but she raised her hand to stop him. "I said was done," she looked towards me and notified me that she was ready to leave. I nodded back to her and we ran off.

As soon as we were far enough away from Tyler and Hayley, Caroline started to cry. Tears were spilling down her face more than when she was giving up her search for Tyler. I've never seen her more sad than she is right now. What person could have the heart to do this to someone?

I shut mind up and realized that I did that... I did that to Stefan. Was he as sad as Caroline when he realized I was falling for his own brother, Damon? When he found out that Damon and I had slept together? When Damon and I started to date? How could I have been so heartless... so selfish, never thinking of Stefan's feelings... Here I was hating Hayley and Tyler when I did the exact same thing, only worse, because Stefan and Damon were brothers.

Caroline suddenly fell to the floor, sobbing. Her head in her arms as her entire body was lying across a field of green grass.

I stopped running immediately to go and comfort my best friend. I passed my hand through her hair, "Care, come on, you'll get through this. He's a jerk, he never deserved you," I never deserved Stefan, I sighed, the guilt eating me alive.

"You know what?" she sat down on the grass now, and she took out her cellphone. She started dialing a number. "He's gonna go and call the first slut that appears on his doorstep? I'll call someone, too, then," she placed the phone to her ear.

Who was she going to call? I thought to myself.

"Klaus?" she asked through the phone.

Oh no...

A/N: Finally decided to upload a chapter for this story! :) Not the longest chapter ever, but at least it's a start! :) I'm not sure where this story is going to lead to, but I guess I'll keep writing and see what path it ends up going to. I do want to thank everyone who read, favorited, followed, and reviewed! I actually got the idea of praising everyone individually from jessmat1312.

To Those who Reviewed

~ jessmat1312: No problem, you're story is amazing. :D Yes, I am also obsessed with Vampire Diaries; I think it's starting to become a problem. 0.0 lol I think you'll have to find out all your questions if you keep reading my story! Thanks for reviewing! :)

~ KlarolineMyMokingjay: I wish I could've updated sooner, but I didn't think this story was going to really hit it off. I'm literally just thinking YOLO right now for this story! Hope you're still interested in reading this story, and thank you for reviewing. :D

To Those who Favorited

Thank you so much to Klaroline66, KlarolineMyMokingjay, MartaS, desiredxwishes, liliqgrozeva , and marta1995!

To Those who Followed

Thank you so much to Klaroline66, KlarolineMyMokingjay, SomeUnknownPerson, desiredxwishes, jessmat1312, kaylayoung925, klauscarolines, liliqgrozeva, and melissah87!

Love,

~Fandom4Life16