This story won the voting on my dA account :).
I have written this one last year and it was a lot of fun to write
Part 2 will follow soon ;)

Fun in the cage

Part 1

Another day dawned in the cage and Sam didn't know how long he had been in there.

Any sense of time he had lost, like his brother Adam who was sitting not far away from him on the other side of the cage, talking with Archangel Michael.

Sam growled.

At least Adam had a conversation partner who didn't want to mutilate him.

Another growl left his lips, mingled with gloating laughter and he looked up, looked right into Lucifer's grinning face and the fallen angel tightened the bonds around his wrists to make sure he wouldn't escape.

Great, another day of torture had just begun…

Not long ago Lucifer had thrown him onto a table and had tied him up, arms raised above his head and his legs were bound to the end of the table.

He had begged Adam and even Michael (which was not a wise decision) for help, but none of them had paid attention to him. Michael had only glared at him and Adam had shrugged his shoulders with the words "It is your own fault. Now deal with the consequences".

And now he lay there, tied up and waiting for the torture to start.

And it looked like it would be another day filled with a lot of pain when he looked at all those torture devices Lucifer had placed on a small table next to him.

He shuddered slightly and closed his eyes.

He didn't want to see it.

He just wished Lucifer would get it over with but no, the fallen angel loved to keep him waiting to torture him even more. He knew the anticipation would drive him crazy.

"Damn I forgot something."

Sam dared to open an eye and he saw how Lucifer turned around, looking at him with a broad, evil grin on his face.

"I'll get it quickly. Don't run away Sammy. Not that you could..."

Sam rolled his eyes and let his head fall back.

With a chuckle Lucifer turned around and went to the end of the table.

He bent down to pick something up he had lost before.

The moment he bent down Sam started to giggle.

At least it sounded like a giggle to him.

He stopped in his movements to listen but Sam was quiet and he thought he had just imagined it. He shrugged his shoulders and bent down again…and again Sam started to giggle, louder this time and he squirmed slightly in his bonds.

"Sammy~. Are you making fun of me?"

The hunter shook his head no, biting his lower lip to prevent himself from giggling.

But that wasn't so easy, because every time Lucifer bent down, his wingtips brushed over his bare feet and he couldn't help but giggle every time it happened.

"You're laughing at me!" the fallen angel growled and he stood up, turning his head and glaring at Sam.

"No…I am not laughing at you. Just…don't!"

"What? Don't what Sammy?"

Sam blushed and tried to hide his face in his arm, lips twisting into another grin when Lucifer moved one of his wings.

"Get your stupid wings away from my feet!" Sam finally yelled before he started giggling again.

Lucifer raised his brow and looked at his wings which were brushing softly up and down the young humans twitching feet and finally it made "click" inside his head and his lips curled up into a sinister grin when realization hit him.

"Ohhh I see~," he teased, finally turning around.

"Little Sammy here is a bit ticklish huh?"

"No! I am not!"

"No?"

"GAH! H-hey! NO! Go awahahahy!"

Sam immediately burst out into loud laugher, back arching off the table when nimble fingers danced over his soles. Again gloating laughter filled the air, mixed with his own and blunt nails scratching over his soft soles, making him buck and almost scream with laughter.

"Look at that. Who had thought that the mighty Sam Winchester would be so ticklish~?" Lucifer teased and his grin widened when he could see how a little tear already streamed down Sam's cheek.

"S-SHUT UP!" Sam yelled through his loud laughter, hands pulling desperately at his bonds, feet twisting back and forth, but he couldn't escape.

"Oh no Sammy. I have just found the perfect torture method for you and believe me: I will take my time."

"You bastahahard! STOP IT!"

Lucifer only laughed and he raked his nails up and down his soles, grinning evilly as he watched how Sam lost it completely now, laughing, screaming and shrieking, all the while squirming wildly.

Even Michael and Adam looked up now.

Michael shook his head and rolled his eyes as he mumbled a quiet "He is acting worse than a fledgling…" to himself and Adam just grinned at this sight.

Meanwhile Sam was in tears and he couldn't barely breathe from laughing so much and Lucifer decided to give him a little break and he pulled his hands back, grinning like a Cheshire cat.

While Sam tried to get some air back in his lungs the fallen angel straddled his legs, cracking his knuckles and spreading his wings out.

"You insulted my pretty wings earlier Sammy, remember? I'll make you regret your choice of words…"

The break was over the moment Lucifer pushed up his shirt and soft wings made contact with his sides and ribs, slowly brushing up and down, making the muscles underneath the skin twitch and Sam giggle.

"What's wrong Sammy? Too ticklish for that~?"

Sam tried to glare at him but the goofy grin on his face took the venom out of his looks and he slowly let his head fall back, closed his eyes and let his laughter go the moment fingers started to prod his ribs, slowly walking up until they reached his armpits.

"Yeah, that's right Sammy. Laugh!" Lucifer said, grinning evilly when Sam screamed and arched his back again when his fingers wiggled into his armpits. He pulled his wings back and his eyes started to sparkle.

"Do you know what my brother did to me when I was a small fledgling?"

Sam shook his head, still laughing loudly.

"Do you want to find out?"

Again he shook his head and the angel's grin widened.

"Too bad for you. I am going to show you so or so."

And Sam's laughter grew a few octaves when the archangel nuzzled his belly with his face, rubbing his nose against the soft skin and grinning when he noticed the small squeaks that mingled with Sam's ticklish laughter every time his nose brushed over an extra sensitive spot.

"I think I can get used to this kind of torture. What do you think Sammy~?" he teased, giving Sam a quick, teasingly lick over his belly button and nails scratching under his arms.

"A-ADAM! HELP MEHEHEHE! PLEAHAHAHSE!" Sam shrieked in his desperation, ignoring the devil's teasing question and another scream left his lips when Lucifer blew tiny raspberries all over his quivering belly, all the while laughing along with him.

Adam chuckled and turned his head to Michael, curiosity sparkling in his eyes.

"You really did this to your brother?"

He could see how the mighty Archangel blushed and how his stoic facade crumbled.

"Maybe?" was all he said and he tried to hide the tiny smile that was about to appear on his face when he thought back at long gone times.

"No way!" Adam laughed.

"You mean Lucifer…the frigging Devil!...is ticklish?"

Michael had to bite his lower lip now to keep his stoic expression and he just nodded his head.

Adam laughed and a mischievous sparkle appeared in his eyes.

"What about you? Are you ticklish too?"

The Archangel narrowed his eyes as he turned his head and watched Adam how he reached his hand out, fingers ready to poke at his side and he quickly grabbed the hand with his own.

"Don't even think about it if you can't take the echo that will come back to you, little human."

Adam shuddered and he quickly pulled his hand back.

"Wise choice…" Michael said and he was full on grinning now.

Both of them turned their heads back to Sam and Lucifer and had to laugh when the hunter let out a girlish shriek the moment Lucifer wiggled a finger inside his belly button.

"What do you think how long that will last?"

Michael's grin widened and he leaned back and crossed his arms behind his head.

"This will last until Lucifer feels bored."

"And how long is that?"

"Very long."

"Poor Sam…"

Michael grinned at him.

"I wouldn't worry about Sam. You should worry about yourself."

"What? Why?"

"Guess who will be his next target?"

"No!"

"Oh yes. And I am happy to help!"

Adams eyes widened and he crawled away from the angel, a nervous smile on his face.

"I am so looking forward to it," God's oldest angel said and his grin widened even more.

"I'll get you back! Archangel or not!"

"I would love to see you try, little human."

"I'll ask Lucifer for help."

"I'll get both of you at the same time!"

The young human grumbled and crossed his arms before his chest, pouting.

"Stupid angels…" he mumbled to himself.

"What was that?"

"Nothing…"

"You will regret that later. Now let's just watch this spectacle there…and you can see what will happen to you later."

"I am looking forward to it…" Adam grumbled with much sarcasm in his voice.

Michael just grinned.