The next day at school, Puck was making his way down to English.

Puck was thinking, "Man, who needs English class anyways. I know how to speak English isn't that good enough."

Then that's when he noticed Rachel Berry with Finn Hudson. They were walking hand in hand and then Finn must have said something funny because Rachel started laughing. It seemed like yesterday didn't even happen.

"Why does Hudson always get everything? He gets to be captain of the football team and he always gets the best girlfriends. I'm sure that I could charm my way in to Quinn's heart but being in a relationship with Quinn also comes with a lot of issues which I do not want. If only I could get Rachel. I thought for sure that she was a goner when I gave her that kiss yesterday. Maybe I should have gone for the lips. No because then that would be crossing the line with Hudson and trust me I don't need any more drama with that kid. Plus if I got Rachel that would make Mom happy since I finally found a good Jewish girl. Hopefully the song I sing for glee club today will make her fall for me," thought Puck as he walked in to the classroom.

"Alright Mercedes are you ready," asked Mr. Schuester.

"I was born ready Mr. Schue," Mercedes replied.

Mercedes

At last
my love has come along
my lonely days over
and life is like a song

Ooh At last
the skies above are blue
well my heart was wrapped up in clover
the night I looked at you

I found a dream
that I could speak to
a dream that I could call my own
I found a thrill
to press my cheek to
a thrill that I have never known

well

You smile
you smile
oh and then the spell was cast
and here we are in heaven
for you are mine at last

I found a dream
that I could speak to
a dream that I
could call my own
I found a thrill
to press my cheek to
a thrill that I have never known

well

You smile
you smile
oh and then the spell was cast
and here we are in heaven
for you are mine at last

ooo yea
you are mine
you are mine
at last
at last
at last
at last

"Wow, you sure brought it Mercedes," Mr. Schuester said and Mercedes finally took her seat as the applause finally quieted down.

"Woah wait a second was that a wink to Sam," Santana thought, "No it can't be there's no way. They're like completely opposites aren't they? But they have been sitting next to each other in glee club but maybe that's just a coincidence."

Mr. Schuester then interrupted her thoughts saying, "Puck, you're up."

Puck said, "I know I've had a streak of singing songs only by Jewish singers but I've decided to try something different."

Puck

She rolls the window down And she Talks over the sound Of the cars that pass us by And I don't know why But she's changed my mind

Would you look at her She looks at me She's got me thinking about her constantly But she don't know how I feel And as she carries on without a doubt I wonder if she's figured out I'm crazy for this girl
Yeah, I'm crazy for this girl

While singing a million things were running through Puck's mind. "Will Rachel know it's for her? Will Finn know and then make a big deal out of it? Or will Rachel think that he's just singing the song just because it was assigned? Get a hold of yourself Puck! Concentrate on the song and DON'T mess up," Puck says to himself in his head.

She was the one to hold me
The night
The sky fell down
And what was I thinking when
The world didn't end
Why didn't I know what I know now

Would you look at her
She looks at me
She's got me thinking about her constantly
But she don't know how I feel

As she carries on without a doubt
I wonder if she'll figure out
I'm crazy for this girl
I'm crazy for this girl

Right now
Face to face
All my fears
Pushed aside
And right now
I'm ready to spend the rest of my life
With you

Would you look at her
She looks at me
She's got me thinking about her constantly
But she don't know how I feel
As she carries on without a doubt
I wonder if she's figured out
I'm crazy for this girl
I'm crazy for this girl

Would you look at her
She looks at me
She's got me thinking about her constantly
But she don't know how I feel
And as she carries on without a doubt
I wonder if she's figured out
I'm crazy for this girl
I'm crazy for this girl

Puck finished the song looking at Rachel and then she blushed. Finn seemed to have no idea what was going on between Puck and Rachel but thought that Puck did a pretty good job on the song.

"Mission Accomplished," Puck said in his head.

Puck not only got Rachel's attention but he also got Quinn Fabray's attention.

"So I was thinking that we could grab maybe dinner sometime," Quinn said to Puck walking out of the choir room.

"I'm not sure if that's a good idea Quinn," Puck answered.

"You're turning down a girl who's as popular and pretty as me. Man you must really love her," Quinn said.

"Yeah I do," Puck said.

"Well if you change your mind, my offer still stands and you have my number," said Quinn.

"Okay I'll keep that in mind," said Puck walking to his car in the parking lot.

"Who is Rachel hugging," Puck asked Kurt.

"It's Jesse. He's back once again to be her knight in shining armor but I don't think that Finn is going to take this well," answered Kurt.

"Yeah that makes two of us," Puck said before realizing what was coming out of his mouth.

"What," Kurt asked.

"You know the first time he egged her then the last time he got Finn and himself kicked out of prom. Every time he comes around there's always trouble," Puck said.

"Oh, I guess when you put it that way you're right," said Kurt.

"Nice save," Puck said in his head.

"Well I'm going to see what he wants," Puck said walking towards Rachel and Jesse.

"I don't think that that's a good idea," Kurt said to Puck, "But of course you don't care about what I think."

"What do you think you're doing here punk," Puck said to Jesse.

"Well I came home for a break from New York and I decided to see how Rachel, I mean everyone is doing," Jesse answered.

"Well we were fine until you walked back in to the picture," Puck said getting close to Jesse's face.

"Well I don't think that Rachel minds. Do you Rachel," asked Jesse turning away from Puck's face looking at Rachel.

"This is actually getting pretty hot," Quinn said in the background.

"Well Finn is my boyfriend but as long as you are here as a friend then I guess I don't mind," said Rachel.

"See we're just friends so you can back off," Jesse said to Puck.

"Whatever but if you mess with us again, you're going to wish that you were never born," Puck said.

"Was that a threat," Jesse asked.

"I don't know was it," Puck answered while he was walking away to his car.

"Now that that's out of the way, will you grab a coffee with me to catch up," Jesse asked.

That's when Finn walked up and put his arm around Rachel's shoulder.

"Hey I'm sorry Mr. Schue wanted to talk to me about Spanish and what is his doing here," said Finn.

"It's nothing he is only here as a friend right Jesse," Rachel said.

"Right well I gotta go so I'll maybe talk to you later Rachel about meeting up and it was nice to see everyone especially you Finn," Jesse said.

Jesse then got in to his Range Rover which he still had from winning Nationals and drove off.

Will Rachel choose Finn, Puck, or maybe even Jesse since he's back in town? I do not own Glee or any of it's characters. The two songs were At Last by Etta James and I"m Crazy For This Girl by Lifehouse. Please review!