AN: I've gotten such incredibly great response on the first part, and I'm all flattered! Thank you so much everyone! Here's part two. It's shorter but it's pretty much just smut. I hope you guys enjoy!
Rachel had no idea for how long they had been sleeping when she suddenly woke up with a start in the middle of the night. It was pitch dark and she almost panicked because she was sweating so much and she felt all out of breath. When her eyes got used to the darkness, she immediately calmed down and put her head back on the pillow with a sigh.
After a while she remembered how sweaty she felt, so she decided she should get up from the bed and go to the bathroom to cool off. She grabbed the blankets to get them off of her, when she remembered Finn was there with her. She also remembered what had happened before they went to sleep. With a smile, she watched him in the darkness. He was really silent, barely breathing. She had to lean in to his face to hear if he was still breathing.
Carefully, she climbed out of bed, staggering around her room after her pajamas. She didn't find it, but she found Finn's t-shirt, and she knew he wouldn't mind that she borrowed it. She had tons of his t-shirts hidden in her closet anyway. She put it on, loving how it smelled of him and the cologne he had put on in honor of their first sleepover. Then she snuck away to the bathroom.
She had been dreaming something, and she felt tired and drained although she had probably been sleeping for hours already. She was so sweaty and felt dirtier than ever. Her hair was sticking to her forehead and she felt as if she had just had the greatest sex ever… in her dreams. She blushed at the awkwardness of it, since Finn had been right there beside her all the time she had been dreaming.
She drank some water and looked at herself in the mirror, telling herself that she looked awful. She tried fixing up her hair by taking out her braids, not that Finn would notice because he was still asleep and it was dark, but she wanted to feel good about herself before going back to sleep. When she thought she looked decent enough, she returned back to the bed, carefully climbing in beside Finn, trying to get as close to him as she could.
"Hey." he suddenly whispered, startling her.
"I didn't know you were awake." she whispered back, almost too fast, earning a silent chuckle from him. "Did I wake you?"
"Hard to sleep with the noises you were making." he said, stretching his body a little, indifferently wrapping his arms around her with a little groan.
"Noises?" she asked, looking at him.
"Yeah, you were probably dreaming or something." he said, and she could tell he was grinning. "Sounded like a great dream." he added with a lower whisper.
"What did I do…?" she asked, and he just chuckled at her. "Finn, seriously, what did I do?"
She felt Finn's hands on her hip, touching the hem of his t-shirt that she was now wearing. "Steal my shirt, obviously…" he said, and she could tell from his voice that he was still grinning.
"I couldn't find my own." she said, looking at him innocently. "But that wasn't what I meant. What did I do?"
Finn was still grinning, and she could swear that she saw it despite the darkness of the room. He still avoided answering her question, but she felt how his hands had found their way inside the t-shirt, caressing her back slowly. They both lay silent for a moment while Finn's hands slowly roamed over her body as if he was warming her up.
He prevented her from caressing him back with her hands, but she decided to tease him back by slowly stroking her leg against his, smiling at how his breath sped up every time she got a bit too high up. They were both breathing heavily, looking at each other in the darkness while silently competing in who teased whom the most.
"Was I good?" he suddenly asked, moving closer and closer, tracing circles with his fingers just below her breasts now. She looked at him, not really understanding what he meant. "In the dream, I mean." His hand found her breast, starting to massage it lightly, listening to her breaths getting heavier.
"What…?" she breathed, scolding herself for almost losing it already.
"You were kind of saying my name there…" he said, leaning down to her neck, starting to kiss her softly there. She didn't say anything, but he knew that if she could have, she would've told him that he was lying. He knew Rachel wasn't one to admit something embarrassing she had done, and dreaming about sex with your boyfriend while you're sleeping with him can be pretty embarrassing, even for Rachel Berry.
Finn had listened to it with great interest after waking up to her breathing heavily, whimpering his name. He didn't want her to feel embarrassed about it, although he knew he would've wanted to bury himself alive if he had been dreaming of having sex with her. "So… was I any good?" he whispered, scraping his teeth lightly over the special spot in her neck.
She hissed, almost losing her breath at the sensation of him massaging her breast while nibbling at her neck. "Y-yes…" she whispered, earning a few soft licks from him at the spot he just had been biting carefully. "Finn…"
He moved up to kissing her mouth instead, giving her lips the most passionate treatment over and over again. After their lips parted, he decided it was time to get rid of his t-shirt that was the only piece of clothing separating them from total nakedness. In one quick movement, he pulled it over her head, before returning to kissing her lips and pleasuring her breasts with both hands.
She whimpered into the kiss, almost like the way she had in her sleep, and he felt himself hardening under the blankets just upon hearing it. He wrapped his arms around her and pulled her closer to him, moving his hands to run through her hair as he noticed she had taken out her braids.
She felt his hardened member stroking the inside of her legs, growing really excited down there herself, and she had to break their kiss just so that she could breathe. His hand had found her breast again, caressing it while watching her intently. She knew that he was enjoying the sight of her going almost crazy by his touch, and she felt she was losing their little competition, so she started drawing little circles on his chest with her fingers, moving lower and lower, hearing how husky his breaths got.
"Rachel…" he whispered, leaning in to pleasure her neck again, and she lost track of where her hands were for a moment. She soon found the trail of hair on his abdomen, tickling it teasingly, making him lose his breath, having to pause his kissing for a while. She moved lower down until her hands were just hovering above his length, and she grinned when hearing how his breath hitched a little.
She drew her hand over his shaft in the most teasing way she could with her hands trembling like mad, and he almost bit her hard in the shoulder. "Sh– sorry, Rachel." he hissed, breathing heavily. She just smiled, stroking him again, going painfully slowly. "T-tease…!" he moaned into her neck, and she had to giggle at how vulnerable he sounded.
She wrapped her hand around his length entirely, starting to move a bit faster, picking up a good rhythm. He started moaning into her neck, and it almost drove her crazy. If she didn't stop, he was going to come all over her and her bed, so he had to grab her wrist to make her stop. She smiled at how thoughtful he was, but she was just as disappointed as he was to not be able to continue. His head had slipped off her shoulder and he was now leaning down at the pillow, panting heavily. "God, Rachel…" he breathed, trying to get himself back together.
After a short while of just lying down, waiting for Finn to calm down a bit, he suddenly returned to kissing her collarbone. She had almost fallen asleep while waiting, and she was surprised to suddenly feel him over her. She closed her eyes, loving the magic he worked on her. She breathed heavily through her nose, and he kept his eyes on her all the time, to see how she was reacting. He moved lower and lower until he reached her left nipple, swirling his tongue skillfully around it, making Rachel writhe under him.
He looked up at her, knowing that she still had her eyes closed. After working on her left nipple for a while, he moved over to her right one and gave it the same treatment, Rachel starting to whimper in the way he wanted her to. He started kissing his way down her body, and the closer he got, the louder she moaned. He climbed over her, positioning himself between her legs. He looked at her with a smirk on his face, moving his hand slowly over her folds, making her moan his name. He was so turned on by just hearing her say his name that way, that it was hard to keep the pace slow so that he could get his revenge.
"Finn…" she said pleadingly, and without further hesitation, he immediately inserted one finger in her. He started moving the digit slowly in and out of her, and she moaned his name time after time. He leaned up slightly so that he could give her mouth some attention as well, inserting a second finger into her clit as he kissed her, just to have her moaning into his mouth.
He left her mouth, starting to work really slowly, curling his fingers inside her, making her almost scream his name. He continued doing so until he felt her walls tightened around his fingers, her juices soaking them when she climaxed. He continued moving his fingers slowly inside her until her breath steadied. He moved up to lie beside her, licking off her juices from his fingers with a cocky smirk on his face, feeling that he had won. She curled up beside him, letting him wrap his arms around her as she was still breathing heavily.
"I believe I won." he said.
"No, we're just getting started." she said into his chest, giving his skin a suckling kiss there, knowing that it'd leave a mark. He didn't say anything, but he knew that he had something he'd have to explain to everyone who saw him topless after that.
Rachel didn't bother to give his upper body any more pleasure. Instead she climbed on top of him and slid herself down his body, grinding herself painfully against his erection. He made a sound that sounded like somewhat of a groan, but she could hear the pleasure he felt in it. She settled between his legs, looking up at his face, seeing that he was smirking at her. "I'm going to wipe that smile off of your face, Hudson." she said seductively to him, grabbing his erection without any forewarning, causing him to moan out loud. "Told you." she said, starting to slowly move her hand, making sure he felt every single move she made.
"Shit, Rachel…" he hissed, his entire body tensing up.
"Watch your tongue, Hudson." she said with a smirk, and he let out a chuckled moan at how cocky she suddenly was acting. He knew Rachel wasn't really the cocky kind when it came to sex. She liked it very simple and loving, but Finn's cocky games would always inspire her to return some of that cockiness, and she was so good at it.
She leaned her head down to his length, giving his tip a sharp lick, trying hard not to just suck the orgasm out of him. His hips buckled as he felt her tongue on him, and she squeezed him lightly, her touch telling him to calm down in that equally cocky way that her voice could. She then took him in her mouth, swirling her tongue over him slowly, slowly. "Rachel…" he hissed, gripping the sheets under him. "P-please – oh god!" She took him deeper into her mouth, starting to suck him off in the most heavenly way. "R-Rachel!" Finn said warningly.
She had to smile at how his tone of voice could tell when he was about to come. She kept sucking, his moans growing louder and louder, until he finally came, his seeds spilling into her mouth. She was usually very keen on not to swallow any of his sperm, but she had done it a few times by mistake when he didn't warn her. Now she just did it to tease him even more, because she knew that he'd feel so beaten when she did. She kept sucking him a little afterwards, letting him ride out his high, until she felt his hands in her hair, knowing it was the signal for her to stop.
With a smile on her face she crawled up to lie beside him. "Beat you." she said, wiping off her mouth with the back of her hand. He had his head almost buried in the pillow, sweat running down his forehead. She giggled at the sight of him being so drained.
For a moment they just lay there watching each other, Finn trying to steady his breathing while she ran her hands through his hair softly. "You know what?" she whispered.
"What?" he breathed, smiling at her.
"You're pretty nice to have a sleepover with."
He smiled at her, raising his head to give her a kiss on the lips. "You're pretty damn perfect to have a sleepover with." he said, nuzzling his nose against hers.
She kissed him again, wrapping her arms around his neck. "We should do this more often." she said after their lips parted.
"We should do this every day." he whispered, wrapping his arms around her waist, pulling her even closer.
"Yeah, I'd like to hear you dream dirty dreams." she said, laughing.
"Maybe you will. This sleepover isn't over yet, is it?"
She shook her head. "We have to say good night first, don't we?"
He hugged her, giving her a soft kiss on the cheek. "Good night, Rachel."
"Good night, Finn."
They both fell asleep once again, this time in each others' arms, closer than ever. They were holding onto each other tightly, knowing that this sleepover was soon over – but they both still had plans for the morning.
AN: Part three will be written as soon as I've gotten response on this one! Don't forget to review and let me know what you think!