"Why are you making me do this Oliver? Your both my friends no matter how much Miley …doesn't…care…" Lilly slowed down the last part and looked at Oliver.

"See Lilly. You know she doesn't care at all, and you still want to be friends with that. Lilly are you too scared to speak up? Because I don't know you if that's it."

Lilly thought she was scared. She had no problem telling Miley how she felt, but how would she react, she'd find some way to get them to be friends again. So what's the point? It's happened before and she promised to change but it never happened.

"No Oliver, it's no that. I know she'll find a way to get us to be friends again, so what's the point?"

Oliver got up and started walking down to the beach.

"Oliver wait," Lilly said getting up and following him.

He kept walking down to the shoreline then walked along as the waves hit his feet.

Lilly did the same but ran up next to him.

"Oliver what did I say?"

"Nothing that's just it." He said looking at Lilly, still walking. "You didn't answer my question. You made up why you couldn't answer. Well your going to have to. I'm dead serious Lilly, I can't take Miley anymore. You've know her for at leased 4 years you known me what is it 13 years now?"

They stopped walking.

Why was he making me do this? Lilly thought. Was this a joke? He was my best friend, forever. Miley was just a friend.

"Lilly pad, remember that's what I used to call you to make you laugh?" He said chuckling as he grabbed her hands. "I just need the truth, and please answer this time?"

Lilly sighed.