Thanks for those who started following this story and to those who favorited it! It means a lot! I know last chapter was pretty short, but this one is much longer. Sorry the focus is mostly on the OC's right now, but I promise Kurt, Blaine, Rachel, etc will be main parts of this story very soon. Probably starting next chapter.
Thanks for reading! Hope you enjoy this chapter!
"Okay, pull yourself together, Elizabeth." Elizabeth said to herself, trying to pull herself together, and failing miserably. She gave up trying to be strong about this and finally left the bathroom.
Elizabeth made her way into her room and curled up in her bed. She stayed there for what felt like hours, but was probably only about twenty minutes.
How was she supposed to do this? She was too young to handle this. Elizabeth had wanted to go to NYU and study dance for college, what was she going to do now? She didn't even want to think about what her fathers would think. They would be so disappointed in her, she didn't know how she was going to handle this.
As she laid in her bed and stared up at the celling, she heard a voice coming from outside.
"Thanks for the ride!" It was her younger sister, Aria. Aria was twelve years old and biologically Blaine's while Elizabeth was biologically Kurt's. She had just come home from soccer, and was given a ride home from her friends parents.
"Lizzie!" Aria called to her, "I'm home! Are daddy and papa home yet?"
"Not yet!" Elizabeth successfully called back to her sister without her voice shaking.
Elizabeth heard Arias footsteps coming up the stairs and making their way into her bedroom.
"What are you doing?" Aria asked, seeing her sister bundled up in multiple blankets and hiding from the world.
"Get out of here, pipsqueak. I don't feel very well." Elizabeth responded.
"Alright, alright." Aria put her hands up in mock surrender, "do you need anything?"
"No, I'll be fine. Thanks."
Aria left the room without another word, and after a few minutes to herself, Elizabeth heard a shout from down the hall. She shot up from her bed and ran down the hallway to find Aria.
"Ari? You okay?" Elizabeth asked.
"Lizzie! You've gotta come see this!" Elizabeth followed the sound of her voice and found her in the bathroom.
"Lizzie, do you know if daddy and papa are trying to have another baby?" Aria asked.
"That would be pretty hard to hide from us, buddy. I don't think they'd able to sneak a surrogate around without us noticing." Elizabeth said.
"But look!" Aria turned to Elizabeth and shoved her hand in front of her face. What she was holding shocked Elizabeth to the core.
Elizabeth snatched the pregnancy test from her hands, "Where did you find this!?"
"I saw it in the trash!"
Elizabeth felt like and idiot. How could she have left the test in the bathroom? She should have burned it while she had the chance.
"Are they trying to have another baby? That's great! I wonder if it's daddy or papa's. Who do you think-"
"Aria, this isn't theirs. They aren't trying to have another kid." Elizabeth sounded defeated.
"Then why-"
"It's mine, okay?!" Elizabeth blurted out.
Aria's eyes grew wide, "W-what?"
Elizabeth put her face in her hands and sighed, "It's mine. I'm pregnant."
"Lizzie…" Aria whispered. The younger sister closed the gap between them and wrapped Elizabeth in a hug.
Elizabeth couldn't hold it in anymore, she began to sob into her younger sisters shoulder.
"Lizzie, it's going to be okay." Aria said sweetly.
"How? How on earth is this going to be okay?" Elizabeth cried.
"We'll make it okay. Me, Daddy and Papa are here for you. Everything is gonna be okay."
"They don't know, Ari. I haven't told them yet."
"Then tell them!"
"Do you know how pissed they'll be? They'll hate me."
"Has either one of them ever stayed mad at us for more than five minutes?" Aria asked.
"…no." Elizabeth admitted.
"Exactly! They'l be mad for a few minutes, but then they'll be super dads and do whatever they need to do to make this easy for you."
"Aria, I literally just found out I was pregnant today! You only found out because you saw the test, I wasn't going to tell anyone this quickly. I need some time to let this information set in too. Give me some time, I'll tell them eventually." Elizabeth groaned.
"'Eventually' better be soon. You don't want them to find out the way I did."
"I will. I just need some time. I still need to tell the father, remember that." Elizabeth said.
"Who is the father?" Aria asked.
"You won't know him, but his name is Nathan Miller." Elizabeth responded.
"Miller? Is that Sasha's brother?!" Aria asked, panic on her face. Sasha was Nathan's little sister, and she was on Aria's soccer team. The two weren't too fond of each other, in face they hated each other.
"Yeah, that's right. Why?"
"Uh-oh." Aria whispered, "You're not gonna like this."
"What?" Elizabeth asked, becoming nervous.
"I overheard Sasha's parents talking to my coach that she couldn't be on the team anymore because the family was moving. I didn't hear where they were moving, but if Sasha can't be on the team anymore it's probably far away." Aria said. The younger sister for the inevitable freak out her sister was about to have.
Elizabeth, however, was frozen. No response whatsoever. "Oh." was the only thing that came out of her mouth.
Aria watched as her sister slid down the wall and sat on the bathroom floor and began to sob for the third time that day. Aria climbed into Elizabeth's lap and wrapped her arms around her neck and hugged her.
"I'm so sorry, Lizzie." Aria said.
"I'm so stupid," Elizabeth cried, "How could I let this happen?"
"Lizzie you couldn't have known-"
"No, not about them moving. How could I have let myself get pregnant? I'm so stupid."
"Don't say that," Aria said sharply, "please don't say that. You're not stupid, you made a mistake. Everyone makes mistakes. Everything will be okay."
"I love you, Ari." Elizabeth sobbed into her shoulder.
"I love you too." Aria smiled at her older sister.
Just then, the two sisters heard the front door open.
"Girls!" Blaine called throughout the house, "We're home!"
"Be down in a second, daddy!" Aria called down to him, "You gonna tell them?"
"Not tonight. Soon, I just need time for myself right now." Elizabeth said, finally standing up.
"Alright. go lay down for a little bit. You're exhausted." Aria said.
The two sisters smiled at each other and gave each other a hug before leaving the bathroom.