Claire saw Sylar sitting on a motorcycle through her window and she hurried back down stairs. Claire didn't notice Noah sitting in his office and when she opened the front door he came out and saw her trying to leave.
"Where are you going?" Noah asked
"I was just going to visit Peter and Angela" Claire said hoping she could pull off the lie
"They are in town?" Noah questioned
"Oh yeah just for the night though thats okay right I just figured it would be" Claire said trying to hurry out the door
"Do you need a ride?" Noah asked hoping she would say yes
"Thanks dad but actually I got a ride. A friend of mine is going to drop me off" Claire replied pointing out the door hoping Sylar kept the helmet on
"On a motorcycle? With a guy?" Noah said looking at Claire and then out the door
"Yeah dad its fine don't worry ok? I love you so much" Claire said this was her goodbye and he didn't know it
"I love you too Claire bear I will see you tomorrow ok have fun" Noah said finally letting Claire out the door
Claire took off out the door and she ran to Sylar and gave him a hug. Noah was still watching from the door and then Sylar took off his helmet so that he could give Claire a kiss. When he did that Noah rushed outside and took Claire by the arm which made her jump.
"What are you doing with my daughter?" Noah asked his voice full of hate and anger
"I love daughter and she loves me. I'm taking her away to start over" Sylar honestly said
"The hell you are. Claire go inside while I take care of this monster" Noah said pushing Claire towards the house
"No dad don't hurt him. He's right I love him and we are going away together so that I can be happy" Claire said in a stern tone
"How can you love someone like him?" Noah asked glaring at and pointing at Sylar
"He makes me feel happy dad ok I know you think this is a stupid choice but let me do this because you love me and you want me to be happy" Claire pleaded holing on to Sylar's arm
"Claire he will break your heart because he is a monster and you will come crawling back to this life and I won't be there for you when that happens you understand that?" Noah said locking eyes with Claire
"Fine dad be like that I have Sylar and I know he won't hurt me. Now I'm going to go live my life with him and I'm sorry that you don't love me because of this. I wish I could of made you proud" Clarie told Noah as she got on the motorcycle with Sylar
Noah just stood there and watched the one person he promised to protect ride off on a motorcycle with a dangerous man. Claire and Sylar took off speeding out of the neighborhood. Claire had tears falling down her face as she held on tight to the complicated man she loved.