The next morning, everyone in Sesame Street was celebrating Christmas. Zoe got a ballet doll, Rosita got a new guitar, Telly got a super pogo stick, Murray got a Spanish speaking guide, Grover got a dance mat, Cookie got a cookie jar, and Big Bird got a mammoth toy. Snuffy was in Cincinnati to see his grandmother for Christmas and Big Bird misses him terribly. David and Fluttershy comforted him.
Meanwhile, Cecil got a dancing cane and hat, Reginald got a picture of Tucker, and Gus got nothing but coal. "Maybe you wouldn't get coal if you didn't get angry in people's faces and say those harsh words."
"Maybe," Gus said in a cranky tone, "And I would be pleased if Noodles didn't play Space Probe with me."
Then he left. Elmo saw how everyone was happy on Christmas and he wished that it would be Christmas every day. He shook it and shouted, "Blitzen!"
Nothing happened.
Meanwhile at The North Pole, Santa's elf lieutenant, "Bernard" was checking preparing the after Christmas party when Wayne the elf announced on the intercom that it's Christmas again. Bernard didn't like the looks of this. There he warned Santa about what's going on. Santa told him to get a reindeer to talk sense into Elmo. Unfortunately, they were all tired, except Lightning, he was called, "Lightning" because he can travel the world within a second.
As they were enjoying presents, the kids were when they heard an announcement on the radio that tomorrow will be Christmas. Everyone was shocked and Elmo was surprised that it will be Christmas tomorrow. He explained that kids need to go to school to learn, people need to go to the grocery store for food, and people need to work for income.
Betty Ann and Pinkie Pie wasn't sure on the wish due to school closing, "Without school, I would do my educational themed party." Pinkie Pie added, "Betty Ann suggested it."
Applejack and Kiki weren't sure on the Christmas every day either, "We need grocery stores y'all." Applejack said.
Finally, Lilo, Gary, and Twilight weren't agreeing on it either, "Without work, my dad's magic store is doomed." Gary said.
Santa decided to take them on a sleigh ride. Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash posed as reindeer, while Lightning was the head reindeer. One by one, everyone gets into the sleigh.
"I like to help, but I had to go through chimneys again," Santa said, "Luckily, someone can fill in my shoes."
He points to Natalie, who was walking up with Mistletoe on her leash. She was wearing green earmuff and a white winter jacket. "Natalie?" they asked.
"Natalie of Sesame Street has a strong love for Christmas at age 4. Also, Mistletoe was her big Christmas present last year, because she needed company while her mother worked as a florist."
Natalie saw The Celestian Alliance and Santa. He put Natalie into the sleigh and Mistletoe got on. There Lightning took off.
"I wished I gave him the pink bear." groaned Santa.