Finally back with Chapter 2! Sorry it's taken me so long. To be honest I just needed to figure out where this story was going, now that I have a clear idea chapters should start coming more quickly! As always I don't own the rights to Glee nor to any of it's characters and this is nothing but a work of ficiton.
Sam's thoughts
Blaine's thoughts
Chapter 2:
Blaine was rummaging through his movies trying to decide what he and Sam should watch. 'What would he want to watch? I don't think I could convince him to watch a musical. Maybe a Disney movie? No that's too childish.' Blaine huffed in frustration as he decided to take out The Little Mermaid and Gypsy, 'Ok. I just need to stop over thinking this. It's just a movie. I'll just take these three and let him choose.' Blaine ultimately decided to pick The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, Les Miserables, and 500 Days of Summer. 'I hope he doesn't find these stupid.' As if on cue Blaine's phone buzzed with a new text message, his stomach flipped when he saw it was from Sam. 'Hey babe, mom just took the cookies out of the oven. Be over in 20! x S.' Blaine smiled widely and grabbed the movies before heading downstairs, he practically leaped into the kitchen to see what they had to go with cookies, 'Milk is too simple, I want to impress him. God, I'm so pathetic. Sleep with a guy once and it's like I'm his housewife. Fuck it, I'm making milkshakes.'
Blaine had just finished putting the cherry on top of their milkshakes when there was a knock at the door, he ran to the door but stopped to take a deep breath before opening it to reveal Sam holding a container full of cookies in his hand, "Hey babe. Sorry it took me so long." Sam stepped in and gave Blaine a quick peck on the lips, making Blaine giggle, "No problem. I made us a surprise in the kitchen." Sam smiled, "Hmm, I love surprises." Blaine took Sam's hand and led him into the kitchen, "Hope you like milkshakes!" Sam laughed as Blaine took the cookies from him and handed him his shake, "Chocolate milkshake with chocolate chip cookies? Blaine Anderson you are a man after my own heart." 'Why do I keep saying stuff like that? I shouldn't be leading him on. This could never be anything. I mean Blaine's meant to be with Kurt and I'm...' "Sam?" Blaine was looking at Sam like he was waiting for an answer to something, "Sorry, must have zoned out. What did you say?" Blaine rolled his eyes, "I said do you still want to watch a movie?" 'Do I want to watch a movie? I shouldn't complicate this, but, god damnit!' "Of course babe. What are we watching?" Blaine picked up his shake along with the cookies and headed towards the living room with Sam close behind, "I hope you don't find these stupid. They were the only ones I thought we might be able to agree on." Sam picked up the three movies and looked them over, 'Lord of the Rings? Nah, too long. Les Miserables? Hugh Jackman is one of my personal heroes, but crying in front of Blaine would be embarrassing so maybe not.' "How about this one?" Sam handed 500 Days of Summer to Blaine, "Oh! I love this movie. Zooey Deschanel is such an amazing actress, have you seen it before?" Sam just smiled and shook his head, "Really? I hope you like it. It's kind of mushy but not in the typical chick flick kind of way. But we can watch something else if you want." Sam laughed, 'He's so funny, man I'm in way over my head.' "Blaine, stop defending it, I haven't even seen it yet! Let's sit on the couch and watch it. Preferably before my milkshake is totally melted." Blaine chuckled, "Right, sorry." 'Damnit! Stupid, ugh I impress him with the milkshakes then fuck it up by babbling on about a movie he hasn't even seen.'
Blaine inserted the disc into the dvd player and went back to join Sam on the couch, he sat on the other end wanting to give Sam his space, Sam just rolls his eyes when he notices how far away Blaine was, "Blaine you don't have to be weird around me, I fucked you senseless a few hours ago and now all I want to do is cuddle with you and watch this movie you're so excited about, ok? Come here." Sam put their shakes down on the coffee table and pulled Blaine close to him placing Blaine's head on his chest, "Better?" Blaine was blushing as he nuzzled into Sam's chest and nodded, "Much." Sam picked up the remote and pressed play, 'He's so warm and I love his hair when he leaves it curly.' Sam began to absentmindedly run his fingers through Blaine's curls, eliciting a soft sigh from Blaine, 'His hair is so soft, FUCK! I'm so boned, I don't even know if I'm gay for Christ sake!' At that moment Blaine wrapped his arm around Sam's waist and squeezed gently, making Sam's stomach flutter, 'And what was that?! He barely touches me and I go nuts. Shit, I do have feelings for him.'
As the movie continued Sam found himself really enjoying it and he continued to gently stroke Blaine's hair, by the end Sam wasn't sure his heart could take it, "Wait, you mean, they don't get together in the end?" Blaine looked up and smiled at him, "Not all love stories have a happy ending. But look at what they did for each other, he actually knows how to be in a relationship now and she finally let herself love someone because of him. That's what love is all about." Sam smiled warmly, 'He's right,' "I see why you love it so much." Blaine's smile widened, "You didn't find it stupid?" Sam chuckled, "Are you kidding? That is my new favorite romantic movie. Thanks for showing it to me." Sam pulled Blaine up into a kiss, 'God I love kissing him. Fuck it, I need him.' Sam broke the kiss and took a deep breath, "Blaine?" "Yeah?" "Would you wanna...give this a try?" Blaine's eyes got so big Sam thought they were going to pop right out of his head, "Do you mean?" Sam nodded, "I mean, I can't promise to be perfect all the time or to never hurt you. But I will try my best to be good to you, I just want to be with you." Blaine smiled warmly, "I would like that. So, are we going to tell people?" 'Please say yes, please say yes, please say yes.' "I want to, but I don't think we should. I just broke up with Brittany today and if I show up tomorrow and announce I'm dating you it might cause a lot more trouble than it's worth. Is that ok?" Blaine sighed, 'I guess it will have to be.' "Absolutely." Blaine put on his best smile and Sam seemed to buy it, "You are so amazing, you know that?" Blaine giggled, "If you say so." 'I can't push him. So just being with him is good enough for now. It's better than being alone.'
Sam gently gripped the back of Blaine's head and brought their lips together, Sam sat up slightly so was holding Blaine as they continued to kiss. 'I can't belive I just asked him that! This is crazy! But even if I only get a little piece of him, it's worth it.' Sam squeezed Blaine tighter as the kiss became more desperate, their hand quickly went to the others shirt and in a flash they were discarded to the floor. Sam lifted Blaine slightly and laid him down on the couch placing his hands on Blaine's sides but his grip was gentle. 'This is totally different than before. Does he actually want to be with me? What if he changes his mind? Shut up Blaine and just enjoy the moment.' Blaine hooked his legs around Sam's waist so he could pull him down and grind into him. 'God that feels amazing!' The friction their jeans created was overwhelming for both of them, soon Sam was thrusting against Blaine as they moaned into each others mouths. After one more thrust Sam cried out Blaine's name and exploded in his jeans, Blaine following close behind.
Sam kissed Blaine passionately before standing up from the couch, "Well it seems we both are in need of a shower. Care to join me?" Blaine smiled slyly, "I thought you'd never ask." They raced up the stairs to the bathroom in Blaine's bedroom, Sam was the first into the bathroom and turned to catch Blaine who was running right behind him, "Beat ya!" Blaine scoffed, "Well you have longer legs than me so I say it was an unfair advantage." Sam smiled, "I happen to enjoy you're height, perfect for me to pick up." Before Blaine could say anything Sam picked him up by the waist causing him to wrap his legs around Sam as their lips smashed together. Sam walked forward slightly until Blaine's back was against the door, he then moved his hand down to Blaine's ass and squeezed tightly making Blaine moan, "God I love your ass." Blaine smiled against Sam's lips, "Well it's all yours at the moment. Care to take advantage?" Sam bit down on Blaine's bottom lip almost hard enough to break the skin, "I think we should get in the shower now." Sam put Blaine down gently and turned to turn on the water, once he got it to the right temperature he turned to Blaine, "You seem to be overdressed, here let me help you with that." Sam's hands moved to the button on Blaine's jeans, he hooked his thumb in the waistband of Blaine's underwear so he was naked in one swoop. Sam stepped back to admire Blaine's body, "So sexy." Blaine blushed, "You know you're still wearing pants. That doesn't seem fair." Sam smiled, "You're right, it doesn't." A second later Sam's jeans and underwear were discarded to the floor and he pulled Blaine into the shower.
The water was so warm and felt amazing rushing down their bodies cleaning all the dried cum away, they just stood under the water kissing, enjoying the feeling of just being together like this. 'He's so perfect, and for right now he's mine. He's so good.' Sam cupped Blaine's face gently as he kissed him deeper, "You're so beautiful." 'No ones ever said anything to me like that before. At least not the way he does.' They kiss for awhile longer and then finish showering, after drying off Blaine pulls Sam back in for another kiss and leads him to the bed, "I believe you said something earlier about how much you love my ass? Well I'm not one to disappoint." Blaine crawls onto the bed on his hands and knees with his ass facing Sam, "It's all yours." Sam couldn't suppress the strained moan that came out of him, 'Fuck he's so hot.' He smacks Blaine's ass, "Fuck yeah, Sam. Don't you want to fuck me? I want you to fuck me so hard." Sam's eyes darkened with lust, "Fuck yes, I'm going to ram your pretty little ass. Would you like that baby?" Blaine moaned deeply, "God, yes. Please."
Sam grabbed the lube from the bedside table and slicked up his fingers, he pressed one finger gently against Blaine's hole and pushed until it slipped in, Sam moaned as he moved his finger in and out of Blanie, he added a second finger and spread his fingers apart, "God you're so tight. I can't wait to have my cock inside you again." Blaine moaned, "Then stop talking about it and do it. I'm ready." Sam didn't need to be told twice, he removed his fingers and put on a condom before positioning himself at Blaine's entrance, Sam almost screamed in pleasure as the head of his cock slipped in, he pushed in all the way until Blaine's ass was flush with his stomach, Sam built a rhythm quickly and was slamming into Blaine with no reserve, "Fuck yes, god yes, Sam fuck me!" Blaine was a complete mess of pleasure, his vision was so blurred it was as if everything was glowing, "God you're so tight! You like my cock in your ass don't you Blaine? Don't you love it?" Blaine moaned a bit higher than he would like to admit, "Yes! I never want you to stop fucking me! Fuck!" Sam couldn't believe how hot Blaine was making him, he was slamming into Blaine so hard the sound echoed around the room. Blaine leaned back and captured Sam's lips, the new angle causing Sam to slam up against Blaine's prostate, "FUCK YES! " Without warning Blaine began cumming all over the bed, Sam continued slamming into him until Blaine tightening around him was just too much and came inside of him with a cry that almost sounded animalistic.
Blaine's strength quickly gave out and he collapsed on the bed taking Sam with him, Sam removed himself carefully and disposed of the condom before he snuggled up behind Blaine and pulled him close, "You ok?" Blaine sighed happily, "Yup. Just...so tired." Sam chuckled, "Same here. I should go." "No, stay." Blaine whined, Sam couldn't help but smile softly to himself, 'Should I stay? That's a stupid question.' Sam nuzzled against Blaine's shoulder and sighed, "Ok. I'll stay, but set your alarm for like 2 am, if I'm not home before my Dad gets up at four I will be so dead." Blaine laughed lazily as he programmed the alarm in his phone, "All set." Within minutes they were both asleep, Sam was clutching Blaine tightly around his waist and was smiling into his shoulder as Blaine's hand laid over his, neither moved until the alarm went off hours later. "Blaine, you're alarm." Blaine groaned, "Sorry." Blaine reached over and turned off the alarm he placed the phone down and leaned back against Sam to give him a kiss, "Hey," Sam smiled, "Hi. How'd you sleep?" "Like a rock, must have been the mind-blowing sex." Sam chuckled, "What can I say? Fucking you just does something to me." Blaine giggled, "Always happy to please. So I guess you have to go now huh?" Sam sighed, "Yeah I should, we do have school tomorrow." "That reminds me, you never told me what song you thought we should do to wrap up Guilty Pleasures week." Sam laughed, "Oh yeah. That's why I wanted to come over, I forgot. I was thinking Mamma Mia!" Blaine laughed loudly, "I love that song! That's perfect. You're a genius." Sam smiled, "I know. But I should really go."
Sam got up from the bed and started gathering his clothes, "Uh, do you have a pair of underwear I can borrow? Mine are still..sticky." Blaine rolled his eyes before getting up and handing Sam a pair of boxer-briefs from his dresser drawer, "Here, wash them before you give them back." Sam arched an eyebrow, "Says the guy I was ramming a few hours ago." Blaine chuckled, "That's different. Just do it." Sam scoffed mockingly, "Fine Mr. Anal Retentive. Get it? Anal." "God you're ridiculous." After Sam was dressed he pulled Blaine against him, "It's going to be so hard to keep up appearances at school tomorrow." "You know, we don't have to." Sam averted his eyes, "Blaine..." Blaine sighed, "I'm sorry. I won't say anything until you are ready. As far as anyone knows we're still just bros." Sam smiled, "Thanks. Would it be cool if I came over tomorrow night too?" Blaine flashed a genuine smile, "Absolutely. My parents won't be back for another week so it would be nice to have someone to talk to." Sam's face dropped a little, "I'm sorry you're by yourself so much. That must be rough." Blaine shrugged, "It's cool. I mean it's not, but I'm used to it." Sam pulled Blaine in and kissed him gently, "Someone as amazing as you should never be alone. Besides, you have me now." 'Yeah, behind closed doors.' Blaine nodded, "Yeah, I know. You should probably go before it gets too late." "Right," Sam gave Blaine one last kiss and turned for the door, "See you tomorrow B." "Yeah, see ya."
The door closed and Blaine sat on the edge of the bed, 'What am I doing? He can't even be public with me. No, stop it, he's just figuring things out and doesn't want to upset Brittany. He's being smart about this, and besides he still wants to be with me. I guess that's something. Fuck, I'm screwed.' Blaine flopped backwards on the bed with a groan, he closed his eyes and took a deep breath, 'Great, now my bed reeks of him. Not like I don't think about him enough already.' He decided to change the sheets before going into the bathroom to take another shower, once he was clean he nestled in under the covers, 'I need to stop acting like a child. I care about Sam and maybe he will end up caring about me. I just need to give him the time to figure it out. I just hope I don't regret this.' Moments later Blaine was asleep, too exhausted to worry about him and Sam anymore, but even as he dreamed the fear of yet another heartache loomed. He just hoped he was strong enough to handle it.
Hope you enjoyed it! This chapter was mostly to get them together so the story could move forward, next chapter should be a bit longer! Reviews are always appreciated. Until next time!