Chapter 2
A/N Hey guys! I hope you are enjoying this story!
Disclaimer: I do not own Supernatural but I do own Vitani, the girls, and Nathan.
Sofia raised her hand.
"I'll go next!" she exclaimed.
"Go ahead Sofia" Dean said.
"Ok never have I ever killed a shape shifter" Sofia said.
Sam, Dean, Vitani, and Nathan drank there beers.
"Spill it" Bella said.
"Ok so the first time we killed a shape shifter was when I visited my friend from college" Sam said.
"Her brother was charged for murdering someone but he said on that night he was with someone else" Dean added on.
"Dean and I looked up everything in the book on what could have done this and we came up with a shape shifter" Sam added on.
"But the shape shifter shed its skin and made itself look like me and went to the girls house and attacked her" Dean said.
"Then I started to defend my friend by fighting off the shape shifter but I lost the fight" Sam said.
"Then I shot the damn thing and that's that" Dean concluded.
"Wow" the group said.
"So what about you two, what's your story?" Bella asked Vitani and Nathan.
"Well Vitani and I were in Bartlett rehearsing lines for a musical Vitani was going to be in and then we heard about a shape shifter in the area" Nathan said.
'The shape shifter shed its skin and made it look like me it even had a replica of my gold necklace" Vitani said.
"When I saw that there were two Vitani's I knew that one of them was a shape shifter and I made the hardest decision of my life I had to choose which one was the real Vitani but then I realized something the locket glows when someone sings so I sang something and only one of the locket glowed so I shot the one whose locket didn't glow" Nathan said.
"Ok whose next?" Bella asked.
"Let me try" Castiel said.
"Go ahead Cas" Dean said.
"Never have I ever had sex" Castiel said.
Everyone's jaw dropped but they were more shocked when Martina drank her beer.
"Cas, Martina you mean to tell us that you two have never done the dirty deed!" Sofia asked.
Both of them nodded.
"Even I had sex before and I'm the innocent one!" Susie said.
"With all due respect Susie I believe one you have committed yourself to a man through sex you are no longer innocent" Castiel said.
"Ok whose next?"
A/N And that's chapter 2 of Game night sorry it took me so long to update but more chapters are on the way!