A/N: Omg, I'm so sorry for not updating. I was super busy and I had to go to Chicago for something. Thanks to the few people that followed, favorited, and reviewed. This is my first story so it's probably not that good but whatever. And thank you so much Kaylacutiepop for reviewing! You totally inspired me even with just your 6 words cause it was my first review. Anyways sorry for blabbering. You might wanna get used to it cause I do that a lot. ON WITH THE STORY! … Oh right.

Disclaimer: I do not own Fairy Tail :(

Chapter 2:Sleepover

Normal POV

"Levy-chan!" Lucy cried out. "For the last time, we're just friends!" Lucy blushed a dark crimson. Levy raised an eyebrow. "Oh? That's not what your face is telling me." Lucy blushed even more if possible, but she quickly got back at Levy.

"What about you and Gajeel, huh Levy? What have you guys been up to? Gone out on a date yet?" Now Levy was the same color Lucy was just seconds ago. Suddenly both of the girls' faces lit up. "Hey Levy-chan, are you thinking what I'm thinking?" Lucy asked smirking at her friend. Levy smiled slyly.

"SLEEPOVER!" They screamed together. They planned out everything and it was decided that the sleepover would start at 5:00 and it would be at Lucy's house because her dad had insisted that she only get he best apartment on Strawberry Street.

"This is where we part ways Lu-chan! Bye!" Levy shouted.

"See you at five!" Lucy waved back. Then she skipped home, humming all the way. Lucy threw open the doors to her apartment and sighed, "Ah, finally home."

"Wow, someone's happy today." A voice said. Lucy swiftly turned around and saw Sting and Natsu sitting on her couch. She groaned and then glared at them. She was having such a great day and then these two just had to come by and ruin it.

"What the h*ll are you two doing here?!" Lucy asked angrily.

"We were hungry so we came here to get some food." Natsu replied nonchalantly.

"You could've just gotten food at your own apartment you idiots! Now I have to go grocery shopping again for the sleepover." Lucy groaned.

"NOW GET THE H*LL OUT IF MY APARTMENT OR ELSE!" Lucy threatened menacingly. But Sting and Natsu were not fazed.

"Or else what?" They asked simultaneously. A tick mark appeared above Lucy's head. "I've had enough of you two. LUCY KICK!" Lucy sent them flying out the window. (A/N: Don't ask how they survived. -_-)

Sleepover Time

Knock knock! The first knock sounded against Lucy's door. "Coming!" Lucy called. She was super excited to have a sleepover. She hadn't had a "girl night" with her friends for a long time. Lucy opened the door and Erza walked in. "Nice apartment, Lucy." She commented, looking around and nodding approvingly. "Thanks Erza!" Lucy said brightly. Soon after, everybody started arriving. There was Mira, Levy, Evergreen, Wendy(who might be a little young to hear the things we say :3), Cana, Juvia, Lisannna, Bisca, and more. Mira clapped her hands loudly, taking charge.

"Come on, girls! Let's go to the living room and play truth or dare!" Mira said a mischievous glint in her eyes. Lucy gulped. She knew where this was heading. "Uh, why don't I get some snacks for everyone?" She asked. After a few minutes, Lucy came in with two plates of cookies, a fruit bowl, and some sandwiches as well as two bottles of juice. "Ok, let's start the game now." Mira squealed. "I'll go first." Mira spun the bottle and it landed on Levy. Levy looked a bit frightened, knowing that Mira loved to play matchmaker. "Truth or dare, Levy?" She asked, prepared for both of them. Levy decided to play it safe, knowing that Mira could be a demon at times. She took a deep breath and answered, "Truth."

"Aw, but oh well. My question is who do you want to have your first kiss with?" Levy blushed deep red at this question and all the girls leaned in, eager to hear what Levy had to say.

"…*cough*Gajeel*cough*…" Levy said in a small voice, trying to hide the name in between coughs.

"What was that?" asked Cana.

"I said Gajeel." Levy muttered in embarrassment. Wendy patted her back. "It's okay. I'm sure we all have someone we have feelings for." Wendy said, smiling sweetly. Levy smiled back at the innocent girl. "Thanks Wendy. Okay, my turn." Levy spun the bottle and it landed on Cana. Cana chose dare and Levy made her wear only undergarments to go see Bacchus. (A/N: I know, I know. Not a very good dare but whatever. I ran out of ideas. *sulk*") Cana's face was only a bit red which Lucy couldn't tell if it was from the alcohol or just a faint blush. Lucy covered Wendy's ears so she wouldn't hear anything inappropriate. Cana spun the bottle and this time it landed on Lucy. Cana looked at Lucy deviously. "Just wait until you see what's in store for you, Lucy." She winked and Lucy shuddered, deciding to stay safe like Levy. "Truth." She answered confidently. Cana smirked.

"Ok, if you had to choose between Natsu and Sting, who would you choose?" Everyone gasped, now super interested in Lucy's answer. Lucy thought for a bit. Hmmm, Natsu's funny but reckless. Kind and caring. Loyal but immature at times. Sting is flirty. He's a playboy but I know he wouldn't hurt me. He is tough on the outside but when it comes to me he is really gentle and kind. Lucy looked up. Everyone leaned in for her answer.

"I'm sorry but I can't answer that question." Lucy said apologetically. Mira looked kindly at the blonde haired girl. She knew what it was like to fall in love with two different people. "It's fine Lucy. We'll let you off with a pass." Mira smiled at Lucy.

"Really? Thanks so much, Mira!" Lucy's face immediately brightened. As the sleepover continued, the girls did all different kinds of things like building forts, having pillow fights, doing blind makeovers, and watching movies with popcorn. They all went to sleep at like 3:45 in the morning. But Lucy couldn't get Cana's truth or dare question out of her head. Who would she pick if she had to choose between Sting and Natsu? Would she have to? But the last question was the worst: How did I fall in love with two different people?

A/N: I hope you enjoyed this chapter and I'm sorry if you thought it was too short. I will try to update faster! Goodbye, see you next chapter!