Disclaimer- I don't own anything or anyone.

A/N- Thanks to Jorrieprincess, .., Cro009, PerfectlyxUnperfect, LiveLaughLoveStandingInTheRain, and xxFanficloverxx, thanks so much for the Reviews.

Chapter 2: Possibilities

John Cena looked out the window of his second floor bedroom.

It was sunny out in the Los Angeles suburb. With little kids playing soccer at the nearby park or on their lawns. Their happiness was the opposite of what John was feeling, he was feeling guilty, something he hadn't felt since the summer before.

"You know we wont have such a great view from the bars in our cells." a southern voice said.

"I wont settle for that." John said joking before turning to his rainbow haired friend who sat on the bed "I want a balcony on mine."

"You know they could just hang us like they did back then, then it would be bye bye balcony." Jeff said.

"That's not funny at all Hardy." John said.

"Really I thought I was." Jeff said giving John a crooked smile " So has Torrie called Maryse?"

John nodded "Yea but apparently Maryse went to France for the weekend, she will be home soon."

"She will be bitching about the letter, saying it was one of us." Jeff said.

John nodded thinking about Maryse's face, amazing platinum blond hair and most importantly bitchy attitude "Don't I know it."

"Is Randy almost here." Jeff said being not a very patient person.

John nodded sitting down on a chair looking around his room, his gaze finally resting on the shelf full of trophies and metals.

"He called just before you got here, saying that he would be here soon."

Jeff nodded "Did you tell him about our Punisher."

"Yea. Torrie told him all about it." John said.

Jeff grinned making his green eyes sparkle. Jeff had intense green eyes, a big smile, and his rainbow hair that made people notice him. Jeff was a genius with a 4.0 average, he was going to study art and engineering. Jeff had moved to Los Angeles a year ago from North Carolina.

"Why didn't you invite Torrie over?" Jeff asked

John shrugged at the mention of the blond beauty.

"Why isn't Maria here with you?" he asked to the rainbow haired warrior.

"She said she wasn't scared, but she is." Jeff said slight worry in his voice.

"Torrie told me that Candice was more upset than the two of them put together." John said.

"And paranoid, she wouldn't even give Maria the letter so she could show me, she made a copy instead." Jeff added. "Do you want to read it, I have it with me."

John shook his head "Nah, Torrie read it to me over the phone."

"So you have answered my question, Why not invite Torrie over." Jeff said.

John stayed silent, Jeff knew exactly why.

"You know her liking you is nothing to be afraid of." Jeff said with that stupid smirk on his face.

John shifted around uncomfortably. He knew Torrie had a crush on him. He felt happy and slightly guilty by it. Happy because John liked her too and guilty because Randy- his other best friend- had a crush on her, and John never went for his friends girls.

Also John was afraid that Torrie only saw John Cena the School Jock, not the funny- sweet John he was. He was just John.

"Plus, this is not a time for me to start a romance." John said.

As if in cue, a tall tan muscular from entered his room, the from of one Randy Orton.

Randy had been his best friend since the start of Freshman year, Randy was a jock as well but he only played football. John on the other hand played Baseball, Football, and was in track.

"Hey John, Jeff." he said his usual smirk playing on his lips.

Randy had short brown hair, brilliant blue eyes, and was the tallest of the three at 6'4. John was 6'3, and Jeff was 6'2.

"Sit down." John said "Jeff give him the letter."

Randy sat and read the letter that Jeff handed him.

"Well." an impatient Jeff said after a while.

"This person is seriously sick." Randy said looking up.

Jeff nodded "That's what Maria said."

John grinned "I think it's a prank, don't you?"

"No." Randy said immediately "I sound disturbing."

John's grin faded away "Well what do you think Mr. Genius."

Jeff grinned standing up and pacing for dramatic effect. "Well I think it's a Joke… maybe the girls discussed it and someone heard and decided to play a joke on us."

"Torrie said that they never talk about it." John said "And I don't think Maryse would."

They al sat there thinking about a the possibilities.

John broke the silence " Ummm have any of you talk about it in public."

"Hell no, I would be too scared." Randy said.

Jeff shook his head.

John sighted in relief. "Well I think the girls would feel the same way, so I think they didn't talk."

Silence over took them once again.

"What if our Punisher is real." Randy said. "What if it tells everyone the truth?"

John thought of how his parents would react. They would be shocked and then disappointed, or maybe they would understand why they did what they did but that was not believable. And then there was collage, who would want a murderer to attend their school?

"I for one think its one of us." Randy said.

"You mean one of us is playing a joke on us?" Jeff asked for the first time not knowing an answer.

"No." Randy said.

"I don't understand." John said scratching his head.

"Someone in the group is trying to hurt us."

"Why would they, they need a motive to hurt one of us." Jeff said running a hand through his shoulder length hair in frustration.

"They don't need a motive, they just have to want to hurt us." Randy said.

"How?" questioned John.

"There are a million ways of hurting someone." Randy said.

"And again I ask who in our group would have a motive." Jeff said.

"A crazy person doesn't need a motive." Randy without missing a beat.

John sat there thinking about what Randy had just said. He would understand someone wanting to get revenge, but being backstabbed by a friend was worst.

"Well Maria said that Candice was going along with the strip-teas thing." Jeff said after another moment of silence.

"Well I wouldn't mind seeing that." Randy said his usual smirk on his face once again.

Jeff and John laughed throwing pillows at him.

Just then the phone rang causing them to jump.

"Damn were paranoid." Jeff said as John picked up the phone.

"Hello." John said putting it on speaker.

"John." a voice with a thick French accent said "What's all this crap about a Punisher."

Maryse was the school bitch. She had waist length platinum blond hair, she had an angelic face, gray eyes, and full lips. John had gone out with her a few times, but he didn't really like her like that.

John laughed nervously "So you heard huh."

Maryse laughed sarcastically "Yea Maria told me all about it. What are we going to do."

"Well Candice will go on and do what it told her to do." Randy said.

"It?"

"Well we don't know what or who it is." Randy said.

"Well I hope that our parents don't find out, my old dad is a cop and would throw me in jail without a second thought." Maryse said.

"Aw poor you, don't you stop to think to what may happen to all of us not just you." Jeff said. He didn't like her very much, because of the history between Maryse and Maria.

They could almost imagine her rolling her eyes and flipping her hair "Whatever, and just when I though things were getting boring."

"Umm Yea." John said "And I already miss those days."

Maryse laughed her throaty laugh "Well lets meet up some time."

"Sure." John said before hanging up.

John turned to his friends to see Jeff shredding the latter and Randy just sitting there holding his head in his hands.

"You alright there Ledge." John said calling him by his nickname.

Randy looked up nodding.

"Still having headaches?" Jeff questioned his friend.

"Yea, me and my mom are going to the doctor soon." Randy said.

Randy was super close to his mom. His dad had died in a car accident when he was three and that just left him and his mom.

John and Jeff nodded as they changed the subject.

"You know Candice suggested that it could be him."

John shook his head immediately "No he was dead, and people just don't come back from the dead."

Randy nodded a far away look in his eyes.

John placed a hand on his shoulder "The person is alive, it cant be a ghost, ghost aren't real."

"I know it just makes me wonder." Randy said. "I guess I'm just scared of what this person is capable of."

John nodded "Were all scared. Even if Jeff here is to stubborn to admit it."

"I am not stubborn." Jeff said.

"Yes you are." John and Randy said.

They continued to talk for some time, they even went outside to play a game of ball, to try and keep their mind of the Letter.

The key word being Tried.

After a long day John went up to his room to get a good night sleep, but all he could think of was that night.

A/N- Ta-da how was it, good I hope. So how many of you want to know exactly what they did. Yea I have mentioned the word murder, but there more than that. Hope you all liked it and please REVIEW!