Sam cleared his throat trying to think of something to say to her. Nothing seemed to come out as he opened his mouth to speak.
"Dean, this is really not a good time. What are you doing here anyway?"
Sam looked at his brother again for some reassurance but all he saw was the face that meant don't screw this up for us.
"Well, I wanted to see you…again." Sam said a little unsure.
"Of all the times you could have called or visited me before you pick my boyfriends fathers wake to crash."
"Yeah about that, I'm sorry. It's just after I talked to your roommate, I was a little worried, and she said that you were in danger here."
"You mean Paris? Since when do you refer to Paris as my roommate and not simply just Paris? And who does she think she is bringing you into this mess?"
"She was just trying to help; she is really worried about you. I know you're in trouble and I can help. I just need for you to be completely honest with me."
"About what?"
"About what's going on, the mysterious deaths of certain members of the Life and Death Brigade."
Rory began to look around her feeling uneasy.
"Keep your voice down. And how did you know about the Life and Death Brigade?"
"That's not important. You have to believe me, I'm here to help you, as well as your friends that may also be in trouble."
"Dean, what could you possibly do to help me? It's been over a year since we've even seen or spoken to one another. You don't even know who I am anymore. Besides even if I wanted to tell you what was going on, I can't. I'm not even sure I know the truth." Rory said as she walked away from him arms folded with tears starting in her eyes.
Just as she was about to step back into the house Dean stepped out and smiled blocking her way inside.
"Hey, it's you again. Where you running off to? I see you've met my brother Dean."
Rory gave him an awkward stare. "Yeah, Dean and I already know each other, pretty well actually."
"Oh yeah?" Dean asked sounding a little intrigued.
"Yeah, well enough for me to know that he doesn't have a brother."
Sam looked at Dean in panic.
"Oh, well actually we're cousins. It's just that we have been traveling together so much lately it's like we're brothers. Isn't that right Dean?" Dean asked Sam as he went over to him and put his arm around his shoulder.
"Yeah that's right, sorry Rory. It slipped my mind; I don't think you ever got to meet my cousin. This is Sam, Sam this is Rory."
"Yeah well we've already met, we ran into one another when I was looking for the bathroom earlier."
"Well it was nice meeting you Sam. I should really get back inside; Logan is probably looking for me."
"No Rory wait." She turned back around to face Sam.
"What Dean?"
"You're right, I don't know you anymore but that goes both ways. I'm not the same person I used to be either."
Dean began to chuckle a little causing both of them to stare back at him. "If only you really knew." He thought to himself.
"After we broke up I left town with Sam. Ever since then we have been helping people who find themselves in unusual and unexplainable situations. People like you, who may not even realize how much danger they are actually in. I need you to trust me now, more then ever. We can put the past behind us. This isn't about you and me anymore; it's about your safety."
"Dean this just doesn't make any sense. My mom said you were still working for Tom. And you are starting to scare me, even more then Logan already has."
"What has Logan told you? Does he know what really happened?"
"I know he knows more then he is telling me. I've asked him to explain things to me but he just says that I'm already in enough danger being a member of the Life and Death Brigade and being his girlfriend doesn't seem to help any either. His father didn't kill himself and neither did the others. I knew all of them; they would have never done this to themselves. Someone killed them and tried to make it look like a suicide. Logan came for me the night everything happened, he told me that we had to get off campus."
"Is there any connection between the three victims? Maybe something they did together that would upset someone?"
"That would be the information being withheld from me. Logan keeps a lot of secrets, it's funny, and I never even realized it before until now. I don't want to be a part of this anymore, I just want to go to school and be normal again. I hate hiding especially when I don't even know exactly what I'm hiding from."
"So basically what you're saying is we won't be able to get any information from this Logan guy, so we need to find someone else that will talk. Do you have a list of the members?" Dean asked suddenly jumping into their conversation.
"There is no list. No documentation. But I do know other members."
"Perfect let's go." Dean said walking down the front porch stairs toward the car.
"Go where?" Rory asked Sam.
"Back to your dorm, we need to find some of the other members of this club and come up with a plan to figure out exactly what's going on." Sam said trying to make her feel like she had to come along with them.
Rory hesitated for a moment as she looked back toward the house and then back at Sam. At this point Dean has already made it back to the car. Sam came closer to Rory.
"Come with us. Whatever happened between us before just forget about it. You have to trust me this time." Sam said extending his hand out for hers.
Rory gave in to his request grabbing his hand. At this point she found herself smiling and thinking that this had to be the most mysterious and spontaneous Dean had ever been since they day she met him. Sam's smile quickly matched hers as he realized she was giving into him. They both began to sprint towards the car hand in hand. As they got further away from the house Logan appeared on the porch where they had stood just moments before. Logan missed most of the conversation but he did catch the part when Sam asked Rory to trust him and to go away with him, he continued to watch as the black car sped off down the road.