"Are you awake?" Finn whispered. He figured jacking off wouldn't be loud so if Puck couldn't hear him or if he was asleep he'd still be in the clear. "No?" Puck didn't reply. "Good."
It was 1:10am on a Sunday night and Finn was horny. Usually he would wait until the morning but just an hour ago he was with some hot blonde girl he met from a party the other night and he thought he was totally going to get it in. Wrong. She just made out with him and got him hard and then very abruptly left because she said it was too late. He offered for her to sleep over but she insisted she couldn't. Finn sighed and watched as she went and that's right when Puck walked in. Minutes after Puck went to bed he started dry humping his mattress because that's all he could really do without making too much noise. But Puck saw him moving in the dark and asked what he was doing. He lied and said he was just trying to get comfortable.
Now here he is an hour later, naked under his covers and still rock hard. This was his chance. He figured spit or lotion would make too much noise so he decided that the precum he was making would have to be all he used. So he quietly moved his blanket away from him and let the cold air hit him. Instantly his nipples erected and he moaned a bit when his cock popped out of the covers. He thought Puck couldn't of heard him so he placed one hand on his cock and the other bent around his head. His biceps never looked bigger than when he was in this position.
With slow motions he starts jerking off. Up and down moving his hips with his strokes. The mattress started to making squeaking sounds but at this point he didn't care; he'd be done within the next minute.
Finn was holding back moans, biting his lip and making a scrunched up face which was probably not as sexy as he'd thought it was at the time. He stroked his cock just a couple more times fast and hard and that's when he came. His cum went flying everywhere but mostly it was on his hand. Finn let out one giant moan and he could finally breathe again. Masturbating sure made Finn tired and he slowly drifted to sleep.
The next morning Puck woke up first, as usual. He got up in his sweats and stretched and yawned, completely shirtless. He went to open the blinds in their dorm room to let more sunlight in so he went to walk past Finn but he paused at the end of Finn's bed.
"Dude!" Puck spoke loud enough to wake Finn up. "Yo Hudson!"
Finn woke up. He answered still a bit groggy. "What?"
"I thought I heard you going at it last night. God couldn't you wait until the morning?" Puck laughed at Finn who was completely naked with no covers on and his now soft cock was out with dry cum all over his thick black pubes.
"I thought I got away with it." Finn sighed and looked ashamed.
"You should try harder." Puck said laughing while throwing a pillow to cover Finn's junk.
And the next time Finn wants to jerk off, try harder is exactly what Finn will do.