Peach arrived at the Mushroom Orphange looking for a brother for Toad. Instantly, she found a perfect fit for her little boy. She saw an almost identical Toad playing with building blocks. He looked just like Toad; except he had a blue hat and a blue vest. Peach decided to go talk to him. Just then, the Toad turned around and saw the Princess. He walked up to her to see what she wanted. "Are you Princess Peach?" he asked. "Why yes I am!" she said cheerfully. "Oh wow! I've heard lots about you!" he said as he hugged her. "What brings you here?" he asked. "My baby feels lonely at home and has noone to play with while hes home alone. I came here looking for someone who could fix that" she said. "Wait, your baby would'nt happen to be Toad; would it?" he asked. "Yes he is!" said Peach. "OH BOY! I'M A HUGE FAN OF TOAD! HE'S MY HERO!" said Blue Toad in excitement. "Would you like to be his brother then?" Peach asked. It was at this moment that Blue Toad nearly wet his diaper. "Oh thank you Princess! I love Toad so much, he'll be thrilled!" said Blue Toad in joy. "Dont mention it" said Peach as she adopted Blue Toad.
As they walked back to the castle, Peach realized that she had not asked for a name of the Toad. "Whats your name by the way?" she asked. "Oh, its Blue Toad! Couldnt you tell by my blue hat?" Blue Toad asked. "No, I could'nt. Thanks for telling me that" said Peach as they walked back to the castle.