OK some people may be confused by this when they read the first story but Thalia still exsists and saving Arria was a quest Luke was sent on. I'm really sorry that that didn't come across clear in the last chapter. My bad =} and my first chapter was really skechty because my computer was freaking out so her actuaul name is Arria Alice Michealson but it cut out arria i hope this chap is a little less sketchy!

and thank you to my first reviewer !

Luke's pov

I collapsed on my bed that night, hoping he would give me one night, just one night, that wasn't disturbed by his night mares. Of course not. I knew I was dreaming when I was standing in a huge cave looking into a dark, endless pit.
You have been a good servant Luke. the ice cold voice said "Thank you sir"
You have gotten me all the things I require ,yet you ask for nothing in does your heart desire Luke?
"I don't know" I lied. I knew exactly what I wanted. If I could find her here and take her back without looking...
I see it is a girl you desire? Arria? I shuttered when he said her name. I hated it , it was too cold. I soon saw a figure float towards us. "Ari?" I said as I saw her. I was horrified by what I saw. Her once brilliant smile was gone and no traces of happiness lingered on her face. I ran towards her but passed straight though. I fell to my knees and cried
She is what you want? You must say the words...
I took a deep breath and stood, a tear falling down my cheek, "No"

I shot up in bed. Looking around the room. It was just a dream... In a way I was relieved but it tore my heart to pieces to see her like that. I got up and looked at myself in the mirror. My hair was all out of shape and my chest was drenched with sweat(A/n: who else want to see a shirtless Luke?) I walked onto the deck and looked up at the stars. Why did it have to be her? When they got to Thalia a few years later, he saved her. Why did he let Ari die?
You can have her back Luke, you can finally tell her you love her...His steel voice said in my mind. I shuttered. My only regret when it came to Arria had never told her I loved her. I had had several chances but I never said it.
but you could...If you take him up on his offer you could have her back. I thought of having her right beside me again, being able to laugh with her and tease her and hold her." Do it" I whispered. There was a cold laugh and then..."Luke?"