2 months later

Caleb's phone rang when he was asleep and he was really groggy, but he reached over to grab it. His cell phone said Sarah on caller ID.

Honey why you calling me so late?

Sarah said while crying, "Caleb."

It's kinda hard to talk right now.

Honey why you crying?

Is everything okay?

I gotta whisper because I can't be too loud.

Caleb whispered, "What's wrong?"

"Is Jessica there?" asked Sarah still crying.

Well, my girl's in the next room.

Sometimes I wish she was you.

Caleb answered, "Yeah, but she's asleep next to me."

Sarah said, "Can you meet me at the Old Ipswich colony in like 15 minutes?"

"Sure," said Caleb.

He drove there and met here near where the Putnam barn used to be before it burned down. Sarah was waiting for him when he got there. He waltzed over next to her.

She said, "I love you, Caleb."

Caleb said, "I love you too, Sarah."

I guess we never really moved on
It's really good to hear your voice say my name
It sounds so sweet
Coming from the lips of an angel
Hearing those words it makes me weak

"I wanna be back in your arms and never leave me again, Caleb," whimpered Sarah.

Caleb said, "Me too, Sarah. We just can't do that right now."

They got closer to each other and kissed. They both missed the feeling of being so close to each other like they were before a lie was told.

And I never wanna say goodbye
But girl you make it hard to be faithful
With the lips of an angel

"Ever since we separated I have dreamed of being back in your arms even though I knew it wouldn't go back," said Sarah.

It's funny that you're calling me tonight
And, yes, I've dreamt of you too
And does he know you're talking to me
Will it start a fight
No I don't think she has a clue

"Does Reid know that you talk to me?" asked Caleb.

Sarah answered, "No, because I lie and say I am talking to Kate and need to talk outside. What about Jess?"

Caleb replied, "She may have overheard me once, but she has never said anything to me."

Sarah said, "I really do still love you, Caleb."

Well my girl's in the next room
Sometimes I wish she was you
I guess we never really moved on
It's really good to hear your voice say my name
It sounds so sweet
Coming from the lips of an angel
Hearing those words it makes me weak

"If we got back together would you stay with me?" asked Sarah.

Caleb said, "Never again, Sarah."

And I never wanna say goodbye
But girl you make it hard to be faithful
With the lips of an angel

She said, "Caleb, I need to tell you something very important."

It's really good to hear your voice say my name
It sounds so sweet
Coming from the lips of an angel
Hearing those words it makes me weak

Sarah said, "I am afraid that you'll hate me and never want me again."

"I won't. Please just tell me, Sarah," said Caleb.

And I never wanna say goodbye
But girl you make it hard to be faithful
With the lips of an angel

Sarah began to cry again like before when she was on the phone. He really was curious as to know what she was going to say.

He lifted up her chin and said, "If it is really important then I'll listen."

She breathed in deeply and tried to keep it together to tell him. She looked him in the eye and he stared back knowing she was scared, nervous, and many more emotions.

Sarah whispered, "I...I'm...I'm...I'm pregnant."

He wrapped his arms around her and puts his head inside the crook of her neck. Then he nudged his head up against her neck trying to calm her down a little.

He said, "I am not leaving you again, Sarah. I am so sorry that I did this. I knew you wanted to go to Harvard, but I didn't know this would happen."

Sarah cried into his chest and said, "It's not your fault I agreed to having sex with you."

And I never wanna say goodbye
But girl you make it hard to be faithful
With the lips of an angel

"This is why I called, but I wasn't sure if you would care or think it was Reid's. Maybe even not want me or it," said Sarah.

He said, "I love you and our baby."

She smiled and he smiled. As he smiled he ran his hand across her stomach to see if there was essence of magic and to try to show his love for it to Sarah.

He said, "Did you tell Reid?"

Sarah said, "No, but I broke up with him because I wanted to be with you and to tell you the secret I have kept for a month from everyone."

"I am going to leave Jessica for you and never leave you again and I now know that you were telling the truth about not cheating on me so I trust you," said Caleb.

Honey why you calling me so late?