Chapter 2: You Can Talk?!

After arriving to her home, Amy was frosting her cake in the kitchen while Classic Sonic sat on the couch being a good, smiling kid. He waited patiently which was rare of him to do. Meanwhile Modern Sonic and Tails spied on him from outside by looking through her window.

"Look at him….smiling all innocent..I know he's planning something…" Sonic whispered as he gritted his teeth.

"Sonic, relax. What could he do?" Tails sanely asked.

"Anything, Tails, anything. For example, why is he waiting patiently? I don't do that." Sonic commented.

"You do have a point…" Tails said, as they watched Amy come in the living room, holding a delicious cake with pink frosting and a cherry on top.

"Look, he's clearly trying to kiss up to her." Sonic said as he continued to watch them.

Amy sat next to Classic Sonic and started to slice a piece of cake for him. The younger hero was quite excited to eat Amy's cake.

"Here comes the plane!" Amy cheered, as she fed a forkful of cake to the younger Sonic. He didn't seem to mind this treatment from her, in fact her quite enjoyed the blue hedgehog chewed and swallowed his cake and smiled for more.

"Aww, look at you gobbling it up." Amy gushed before feeding him more.

"It is kinda cute to look at." Tails commented as he watched them. Suddenly he heard Modern Sonic started to growl next to him with his fists clenched. A dark aura surrounded Sonic. He never felt this way about anything unless it was something very serious.

"What the hell does he think he's doing?" Sonic asked darkly, before going to the front door.

"Sonic..what are you doing?" Tails asked as the blue hedgehog knocked on the door.

"Coming!" Amy called out. The pink hedgehog answered the door and Sonic's dark aura quickly disappeared, bringing Sonic back to his calm, cool, collected self.

"Oh hey, Ames." Sonic greeted calmly.

"Sonic! What are you doing here?" she asked cheerfully.

"Oh you know just...passing through the neighborhood, stopping by." Sonic replied nonchalantly.

"Sonic, she doesn't live in a neighborhood." Tails correctly.

"It's just an expression!" Sonic snapped.

"Tails, you're here too?" Amy asked. The two tailed fox chuckled and approached her.

"Yep, good to see you, Amy." Tails said.

The pink hedgehog giggled. "Well since the two of you are here, why don't you come in for some cake?"

"Finally, some food!" Tails cheered before coming in.

"Sure, whatever." Sonic replied cooly as he walked in.

"Oh yeah, Sonic. There's an old friend in the living room." Amy informed.

Classic Sonic turned to the friends and did a backflip, which was his greeting towards them.

"Oh hey, it's the other you, Sonic!" Tails said. "How's it going?" he asked, giving the classic hero a high five.

"Yeah Yeah, I see him." Sonic replied, annoyed at his younger self. Amy sliced Sonic and Tails each slices of cake and served them. Tails enjoyed his piece while Sonic only glared at Amy fork-feeding his younger self and the fact that he was enjoying all this attention and smothering.

"Aww..you're so cute!" Amy cheered. "Like a little baby."

"Amy, he's not a baby, you know. He can feed himself." Sonic commented.

The pink hedgehog sighed softly. "Sonic, it's just me feeding 's no harm in it."

Classic Sonic nodded and stuck his tongue out at his Modern version without Amy knowing. Sonic saw this and growled quietly, trying not to let his anger out to strangle him.

"Oh I almost forgot, I should make some tea!" Amy said before heading to the kitchen, leaving the boys alone.

Sonic turned to his attention to his baby self with a scowl on his face. "Just what do you think you're doing? Coming over here and taking over!" he asked.

Classic Sonic had a confused expression on his face, giving his older self the silent treatment. Suddenly Sonic slapped his younger self across the cheek.

"Idiot, I KNOW you can talk!" Sonic yelled.

"Sonic!" Tails called.

"Whoa! Way past uncool." Classic Sonic commented as he rubbed his cheek.

Tails' eyes widened while Sonic remained unfazed. "You can talk?!"

"Yes, he can talk! Don't you remember meeting me?!" Sonic asked.

"Of course I do, but why didn't he talk the last time he was here?" Tails asked.

"Because that'd take away the purpose of being cute. Besides I'm all action, no talk. Unlike this loser." Classic Sonic bragged as he pointed to his older self.

"Oh bullshit, you cocky little bastard!" Sonic protested. The older Sonic sighed. "Never thought I'd say this but...now I know how Eggman feels.."

"Eggman? You mean Robuttnik?" the younger Sonic asked.

"No, I mean Eggman!" Sonic replied. "He changed his name or whatever."

Suddenly Amy came back holding a tray with her tea set. "I'm back with the tea!" she cheered before placing the tea set down on the table. Classic Sonic gave Amy a wink and a thumbs up.

"By the way...I heard another voice in here." Amy said.

"Yeah, it was him!" Sonic said as he pointed to the chubbier Sonic stuffing his face with cake. Classic Sonic protested by nodding no and pointed to his mouth, indicating that he can't talk.

"Sonic, he can't talk. He's just a little guy." Amy said as she patted Classic Sonic's head.

"He's not that little!" he protested. "I swear he was talking to me!"

Tails sighed, annoyed at his best friend. "It was me, Amy." he admitted.

The pink hedgehog turned her attention to Tails. "What? It was you, Tails?"

"Y-Yeah, I've been trying to get into voice acting as a side hobby..ya know? I'm kinda passionate about it." Tails lied nervously.

Amy smiled, buying into the lie. "Oh, well that was great! In fact...it sounded so familiar..I can't remember when I heard it before...Oh well."

Tails sighed in relief. "Thank goodness…" he thought.

"Oh right! I had an old sweater that I knitted for incase me and you have kids, Sonic! I'm gonna put it on your mini cute self!" Amy proclaimed before running to her room to retrieve it.

"Why did you lie to her?" Sonic whispered.

"Because I was getting tired and he clearly wasn't gonna prove that he could talk. "Tails replied.

"Fine..and you, why aren't you talking?!" Sonic asked his younger self.

Classic Sonic licked the frosting off his fingers. "Because to look cute, duh." he replied.

"Fine, whatever. Question is, why aren't you running away from Amy aka, Amy Rose, aka Rosey the Rascal, aka my stalker?!" Sonic asked.

The younger Sonic shrugged. "Cause she's pretty cool and besides...she turned into a complete babe!" he replied.

"Did you just call Amy a babe?" Sonic asked.

"So what if I did?" Classic Sonic asked.

"Whatever, you need to go back to your time and stay there. Also why do you talk like that?!" Sonic asked.

"Because I represented everything cool in my time." Classic Sonic replied. "You ask too many questions, old man."

"Old man?! I'm only sixteen!" Sonic protested.

"I'm baaaack." Amy cheered, returning to the living room while holding up a small red sweater. Classic Sonic did a backflip on the couch, which was his greeting.

"Well, I heard some more voice acting in here, Tails. You amaze me." Amy commented.

"Hehe, thanks Amy. Like I said, I've always been passionate about voices." Tails lied again.

Amy turned her attention to the younger blue hedgehog. "By the way, would you like to hang out with me, Sonic?"

"No thanks, I'm busy later on." Sonic replied, not aware that she wasn't talking to him.

"Uh..I wasn't talking to you..I was asking your younger self." Amy corrected. Classic Sonic nodded and gave Amy a wink before she put on the sweater on him.

"Of course…" Sonic muttured.

"I know that you're busy, so I don't wanna be a bother to you." Amy replied, keeping her friendly smile.

Sonic blushed a subtle shade of red. "But you're not a bother.." he thought.

Classic Sonic admired himself in Amy's sweater, it was quite a perfect fit for him. "Oh you look so adorable in that!" she cheered. "Well, I'm gonna get my purse and then you and me can walk around town." Amy said before heading to her room.

Sonic waited for Amy to leave before turning to his younger self. "You don't even like wearing sweaters!" he protested.

"How would you know?" Classic Sonic bragged.

"BECAUSE I AM YOU!" Sonic snapped. "AND I HATE SWEATERS!"

"Chill, Phil. Some people can change their mind." Classic Sonic corrected, which made his older self growl.

"You little bastard…" Sonic muttered, having his hands ready to strangle him.

"Okay, I'm back!" Amy cheered as she returned with her small pink purse. "Ready to go?"

Classic Sonic nodded and ran towards her. Sonic noticed that his younger self was definitely shorter than the girl. It made him think about how grown up he was now, considering that he was taller than her now.

"Well since you're leaving, we better leave too."Tails said, feeling awkward. "Thanks for the cake."

"Oh, no problem." Amy replied. "By the way, Tails, you should really do something with your voice acting. You could go far in it."

"Hehe, yeeeeah but you know, I have to be ready for inventions for when Eggman attacks again, but thanks Amy." Tails replied as they all headed outside.

"I see, well bye you two." Amy said, before facing the younger Sonic. "Come on, Sonic."

Classic Sonic nodded and held Amy's hand as they walked away. Amy giggling at the Classic Sonic acting goofy practically made Sonic green with envy. That little guy was funny despite not even talking to her. Sonic wanted her to laugh at her jokes and think that he was the coolest.

"Never thought myself would be my competition…" Sonic thought as he glared at the younger Sonic.

"Can we go home now?" Tails asked as he yawned.

"No way, we're following them!" Sonic replied as he grabbed his best friend's hand and ran after Amy.

To be continued...