Guys! I can't believe so many of you liked this! Thank you for the prompts, the reviews, the follows and favs. I honestly thought this wasn't going to do so well but you guys proved me wrong. So I'm doing hypotheticalllly's prompt. PureFaerie, don't worry, your prompt is coming up straight after this one, especially after I rewatched the movie and saw a certain someone's hand on someone's knee when the driver put the divider up. Fangirling slightly over here, sorry. Anyway, I really thought about how to do this but I think you guys will like it, enjoy!

When Maleficent came with her henchmen to tell them they were headed to Auradon Prep, Jay went to lead the group in getting the hell out of there only to crash into the only human henchmen Maleficent had. While Mal argued with her mother, the words that had been said only a little while ago finally hit Jay. Auradon Prep, school for the daughters and sons of the good guys of every fairy tale.

"I'm not going to a school filled to the brim with prissy pink princess!" Mal argued

"And perfect princes." That. That's why he blocked everything else out, while his body worked on auto-piolet. The others didn't know this but he and Evie had been going out ever since he gave her back her poison apple necklace. While Mal dragged Carlos to get the muck they called coffee, Jay tried to smoothly ask Evie if she ever wanted to hang only to act like a nervous wreck. Evie didn't mind though, according to her, she thought it was cute and said yes. Two days after, they were hooked.

Jay felt his body pull things out of his vest. His dad, right. He finally started paying attention as he pulled out a lamp and handed it to his father who dropped everything.

"A lamp!" Jay looked embarrassed as his father started having a mini panic attack trying to get a genie to come out. Jay rolled his eyes at Evie, who just smiled in return.

"Dad, I already tried." Jafar let out an annoyed air as he threw the lamp back to his son.

"Evie's not going anywhere till we get rid of this unibrow." The Evil Queen said, causing her daughter to gasp

Jay hated that. He hated when Evie's mother kept saying things like that to bring down her confidence. Evie was the most beautiful girl he knew. There was a reason she was considered the fairest of them all on the Isle of the Lost. Which is why he knew his decisions was going to be one of the hardest things he'd ever have to do.

"Ow!" Evie gasp as her mother pulled out an eyebrow hair

"Pain is beauty." Her mother said, causing Evie to shoot her a large smile. However she let out a squeak as she was lifted from her chair by her arm and dragged out of the room

"Where are you going?" Maleficent asked, obviously annoyed

"Evie helped me hide a stash earlier, be right back!" Jay called over his shoulder as he led them out of the Bargain Castle. When they were back on the streets, Jay quickly took them to their alleyway, an alleyway that people rarely went to. It was where they would meet up for dates, or where they'd go to rant about their parents or just to get away from everything else.

"Jay, Jay. Jay, slow down! What's going on? Why did you tell Mal's mom I helped you hide a stash?"

Jay turned to face the blue haired girl and took her gloved hands in his, "Eve…" Jay didn't know how he was going to do this. He didn't want to but, he wanted what was best for Evie, even if he was gonna hate it.

Evie started to look concerned from the look on her boyfriend's face, "Jay, what's wrong? I don't think it was dad, so why are you so upset?"

"Evie, in probably less than an hour, we'll be on our way to Auradon Prep, where they have perfect princes-"

"Jay," Evie interrupted, "you know I only said that to keep up the act. Despite what Mommy says, I have my prince. You." Jay couldn't help but smile at the genuine smile of his princess's face. He loved seeing her happy, even in a dark and dreary place like the Isle.

'Which is why this is going to be so much harder than I want it to be.'

"I know, Eve. It's just, I wasn't really paying attention but I know your mom had to of mentioned you finding a prince, someone who can be your true prince."

The young princess started to lose her smile, "Jay, what are saying?"

Jay let out a large sigh and looked away before looking at Evie straight in the eyes, "I really, really don't want to do this but Eve, I think we need to break up."

Silence seemed to fill the whole alleyway. Jay took one look at the shocked and crushed look at his girl- ex-girlfriend's face before turning his gaze away

"W-what? Why?"

"Eve, look. Our parents would never approve of us and when we take over Auradon, your mother's expecting to spare one prince. For all I know, there could be a prince out there who you might really like. I don't want to be holding you back from that."

"That's the only reason you're breaking up with me?" Evie asked. Her mind was still reeling from what she just been told. "It's not because you got bored of me or I'm holding you back?"

"What? Evie, no." Jay took the girl's face into his hands, "I'm not breaking up with you cause I want to. I'm doing it because you deserve your prince, a real one. Just know that this is one of the hardest decisions of my life, which is saying a lot. Please, don't be sad because then I'm going to feel even worse and want to take you back when I really shouldn't."

Evie looked away. She could see the point that Jay was trying to make but it didn't mean she was happy about it. Her mother would kill her if she found out that Evie refused a prince for Jay. She placed her hands on Jay's and looked at him, "I'm not happy about this but, I understand. Just, don't think this will be easy for me."

Resting his forehead against hers he said, "It's not going to be easy for me either, trust me."


Almost two weeks later, Jay sat in the cafeteria for breakfast. It had been two days since Mal and Ben went on their first date and three since the Tourney match. While people were surprised about how well he worked with the team, they were still weary to approach them. That was fine with him. He wanted to be alone after the last few days. He wasn't joking when he told Evie that being away from her was gonna be hard. He saw Chad and Evie heading under the bleachers under class on their first day of class and it took everything in him not to stomp over there and drag Evie away.

'You asked for this when you and Evie broke up. You did it so she could find her prince. Stop getting so upset over it.'

He let out a sigh and pushed his lose hair back before looking up to see Mal sitting across from him, staring him down.

"When'd you get here?" he asked stabbing at his eggs

"While you were still in the midst of your angst." He shot her a glare before picking up his coffee mug. He was taking a sip when Mal asked, in a casual-but-not-really tone, "So, why'd you and Evie break up?"

To say he was surprised would be an understatement. He almost spit out his coffee on his purple haired friend but now that she could use magic, he had a feeling he'd get cursed an inch of his life so he tried swallowing. It all didn't go down the right way and Mal stared at him, unimpressed, as he launched into a coughing fit.

"W-what are you –cough- t-talking about?" he wheezed, finally clearing his throat of the coffee. He ignored the stares he was getting to look at the sly smirk on Mal's face

"Oh please. Did you really think you could fool me? That time you gave her back her necklace, when me and Carlos came back, the two of you were way too happy. I may of followed E to her first date with you."

Jay looked at her in utter disbelief. There was no way she followed them without him noticing. He had fast reflexes for a reason.

"Well, not the whole thing. Just the two of you passing my house holding hands. After watching you two for a while after that it was obvious to see you two were in love. And then, the day we left for Auradon, you took Evie out for a while and I could see the sombre looks on your faces when you came back. What happened?"

Jay should have known Mal would have figured it out. He was hoping she'd be too concerned about her current love life to bother him about his non-existent one.

"I broke up with her so she could find her prince. This was the only chance she was going to get and I didn't want her to regret not doing it later. Of course my misery is only for her happiness." He said, seeing Evie come into the cafeteria. She was talking to Doug.

He was glad that he didn't Doug as a threat. He could tell that Evie only saw him as someone outside of her friends who appreciated her for who she was. The same couldn't be said for Chad however. He took great pleasure in slamming him to the ground during the Tourney try-outs.

'That's what he gets for trying to take advantage of Evie. Doesn't he know how sensitive she is?'

Of course he didn't. Jay groaned as he tried to take his mind off Evie. This was much harder than he thought.

"Good morning. Mal you left earlier than I did." Evie said as she placed her tray next to Jay, a habit she had been trying to break with no success.

"Yeah, Ben wanted to see me before he had to go talk to the council this morning. Something about the items being sent the Isle."

"Oh, do you think it might be about what we told him during our first dinner here?" Evie asked

Due to little amount of food they got on the Isle, the 4 had been wary about taking a lot but after Ben told them they were allowed to have as much as they want, they went a little haywire. But that was a story for another day.

Lonnie came running over to the table, Audrey in tow. All the occupants of the table glared as they saw the daughter of Sleeping Beauty approach them. From the looks of it, she didn't want to be there either.

"Hey guys! Where's Carlos?" Lonnie asked

"He said he'd walk Dude before getting breakfast. He's probably playing with him and forgot about breakfast." Evie said, taking a bite out of her muffin.

"Oh, well if I don't see him before breakfast ends make sure and tell him this. We've finally organized the party for winning the Tourney Cup. Everyone's invited and the Team is going to be the stars of course. Jay, just so you know, a lot of the girls who helped organized the party really wanted to get a photo with you." Jay rolled his eyes. He may be a bit of a flirt, but most of the girls here were nothing but pretty faces. He immediately stopped the thought, knowing it was going to lead to Evie.

"We'll be there. When is it?" Evie answered

"Tonight. I'm sorry its last minute."

"That's fine. I'll get everyone ready by then." Evie said, already thinking of the different outfits each person could wear.

Mal rolled her eyes, "we'll see you then. We'll make sure and tell Carlos."

"Great, we'll see you then. It's going to be in our dorms common room. It's on the ground floor, the huge doors across from the front door. Bye." Lonnie said before nudging Audrey

"Yeah, see you there." The girl said uninterested before walking off.

"Ugg, I'd like to spell practise to that girl." Mal said glaring at Audrey's retreating back

"Get in line," Evie said as she picked out pieces of cantaloupe from her fruit salad and put them on Jay's plate, where they were immediately eaten. Mal couldn't help but smirk at the couple like scene in front of her. They might not be together but their bodies obviously still wanted them to be.

'Hmmm, I have an idea. I didn't get a chance to do some proper matchmaking with these two before, might as well get it in now.'


Jay waited for Carlos to finish dressing Dude in a vest that matched his outfit. The vest matched Carlos's outfit of black and white shorts, white button up with a red tie, black blazer and red shoes. Carlos struck a pose of Jay, "think Evie will approve?"

"Yeah, but I think she'll hate it even more if we're late. Come on." Jay said opening the door and leading them out.

"I think Evie might make you change your jacket." Jay was wearing a long sleeve white shirt under a black leather jacket and black jeans tucked into his combat boots. His hair was pulled into a bun, similar to how he had it during Tourney try-outs.

"What's wrong with what I'm wearing?" Jay asked as they headed to the girls' room.

As they reached the door and the thief knocked, Carlos said, "look I know Evie and she's going to say you're wearing to much black, even for a villain."

Evie loved to dress up her friends, especially Jay because one pout and he let her do whatever she wanted to him

The door opened to reveal Mal wearing black leggings and her black ankle boots, purple tank top and a black leather jacket with a mix of blue and green on it.

"Hey, we're almost ready. E's just finishing something. You know she's gonna make you change your jacket right?" Mal said, directing her last statement to Jay.

While Carlos was distracted by Evie calling him over, Jay whispered to Mal, "Why do you make it sound like we're still going out?"

"Because, as much as the two of you are trying to fight getting back together, your minds can't help it. Admit it Jay, you want Evie back."

"Of course I do! But I can't stop her from finding a prince. It's all she's dreamed and talked about. What kind of boyfriend would I be if I tried to stop her from that?"

Mal had half a mind to say the he was Evie's prince but decided not to.

'I'll just get them to admit it tonight.' Mal thought as Evie walked over to them. She was wearing a white short sleeve button up shirt, a blue mini skirt, a blue leather jacket lined in gold with a popped collar and a cape attachment and black wedge boots. She held a dark red leather jacket in her hand that Jay's snake icon on the back

"Here, you're wearing too much black." Evie said, not noticing the 'I told you so' looks her other friends were sending Jay. As he pulled the new jacket on, he followed Mal and the others down stairs where to doors to the common room where open. Music poured out and people hung around the door. Lonnie and Ben were waiting for the Rotten 4 by the door.

"Hey guys. Looking great as always. Carlos, Jay, they wanted to get a team picture inside with the trophy." Ben said pointing inside, after kissing Mal on the cheek

"You guys go ahead; E and I will prince hunt." Mal said, enjoying the glare Jay sent over his shoulder.

The common room was large, almost the size of two dorm rooms put together. Large bay windows let in moonlight, making the fireplace on one side look inviting, especially with the armchairs and couches surrounding it. Tall circular tables where spread throughout the rest of the space, still leaving enough space to dance. On the other side of the room, where bookshelves stood between the bay windows, table with food and drink sat.

Mal watched Evie watch Jay get his picture taken with the team. She rolled her eyes at the obvious pinning.

'How much longer are these two gonna drag this out? You'd think they broke up 2 years ago, not 2 weeks. I don't know how much longer I can put up with this. Ruling the world is going to be utter torture if these two don't get back together.'

"Hey, E, can you grab me something to drink?" Mal asked

"Uh sure. Be right back." Evie didn't notice Jay's eyes on her as she went to the refreshment table. Evie poured punch into a cup when someone tapped her shoulder. She turned to see a dark skinned teen about her age. He had curly black hair and green eyes. He was dressed in a green shirt, black jeans and blazer. He bowed dramatically and took Evie's free hand

"A pleasure to meet you Princess Evie. I am Navi, Prince of Maldonia." He kissed her hand, not noticing the furious glare Jay was giving him

To showcase their team work, their couch made the team put their hand on someone's shoulder. The only person close enough was Prince Chad, so he got the job of feeling Jay's tightening grip as he looked at Evie and Navi.

"Ow, hey! Easy! Villain, let go!" Jay ignored Chad's complaining as he watched Navi flirt with Evie. The urge to break something was growing and the main target was Navi's face.

"You're eyes are so pretty. I've meet Snow White and I can tell you, you beat her in the fairest of them all line."

Evie let out a small laugh. She should be happy. A prince was paying attention to her, this is what she wanted. This is why Jay broke up with her, so she could get her prince. Except, he didn't feel like her prince. Neither did Chad. The only reason she was upset was because he had been her only chance of getting a prince at first. But she didn't want a prince; she wanted her prince, Jay.

Navi lifted Evie chin to look the girl in the eyes, "I hear you've had trouble with love. I'd be more than happy to help you in that department." Evie started to lean back as Navi tried to kiss her. She put her hand on the table looking for the cup of punch she had filled before when someone tapped Navi's shoulder. He turned only to be introduced to Jay's fist. As Navi went flying into the table, Jay grabbed Evie's hand and dragged her outside, ignoring her protests.

"Jay!" Evie yelled, pulling him to a stop on the steps outside, "what's wrong? Why did you punch him?"

The Thief whirled around, "Eve, I can't do this! I thought I was doing you a favour but seeing that prissy prince all over you, I couldn't stand it. Evie, you can hate me forever for saying this, but I want you back." Evie opened her mouth to say something but Jay continued with his rant, "Yes, I know I broke up with you so you can find your prince, but I've been miserable ever since. It doesn't help that you're constantly on my mind and that my body keeps thinking were still together and is acting without think, like brushing your hair back or always keeping my eye on you or my heart flipping whenever you smile at me." Evie tried to interrupt again only to be talked over, "Evie if I have to win you back I will. I'll-"

Finally having enough, Evie grabbed Jay by his jacket and kissed him when he was close enough. Jay was frozen for a second before he responded, holding her head in his hands. When they pulled away Evie said, "I want you back too. Jay, I know you broke up with me to help me be able to get a prince, but I meant what I said back at the Isle. You're my prince, always have been, always will be."

Jay let out a laugh before pulling Evie into a hug, "think I'll get in trouble with couch for punching whats-his-face?"

"No, I'll just tell him that Navi was getting handsy. You're my prince so you had to come and save me."

"Of course," Jay said looking down at Evie, "I'll always save my princess."

Ok so the way I usually do story updates, is one chapter of each stories goes up and the cycle continues. However I couldn't stop thinking about this story so I had to finish this and post it. I really hope you guys liked it and I'm sorry if Jay seemed a little desperate. I feel that since finding love on the Isle might be kinda hard, if you truly find someone you love, you don't want to let them go. Please tell me how I should think when writing Jay. The girl's outfits were from the Fashion Catour game on Disney. Jay's also really hard to dress cause he always wears some type of leather. I guess I could stick to jackets. Anyway, enough rambling, please review. These reviews make me happy!