Nathan and Audrey arrived at the crime scene, the usual police-men and coroners and regular crowd of people were around Cathy's house. An ambulance was parked beside her house. Cathy had a warm blanket and some tea with her when Audrey and Nathan approached her. She was sitting on the steps to her house in shock.

"Miss. Hilson, we need to ask you a few questions. I know you're in shock but the sooner we figure out what happened, the sooner the case can be solved." Nathan told her.

"Nathan." Audrey gave the detective a glare. She sat down beside Cathy. "Miss. Hilson, my name is Audrey Parker and this is my partner Nathan Wuornos, we work for the Haven PD. We understand that you were the only one who saw Mr. Dane's-"

"Death? Yeah... I saw John.. Or... I don't know anymore. He just... Came to me... And he was saying weird things.. You know, he was drinking. He-He must have been drunk." Cathy told them.

"What did he say?" Nathan asked, looking at Audrey in the usual manner.

"He said... That he wasn't John." She told the officers.

"Miss. Hilson, did John go out to a bar the night of his death?" Audrey questioned, hoping of getting the answer she was looking for.

"Yeah, he went with- Oh my god! Ben! Is Ben okay!?" Cathy exclaimed.

"Ben?" Nathan asked, knowing Audrey was thinking the same thing he was.. This 'Ben' guy is troubled.

"Yeah, he... He was John's drinking buddies. They used to go to a bar called the Grey Gull but.." She paused.

"But they didn't this time." Audrey finished her sentence.

"No, they went to a new one that just opened up. It's called... Um... Pub n' Glub." Cathy replied.

"Guess we should have a talk with the owner." Nathan suggested to his partner.

"Wait, there was one thing. When John came up to me... He told me he wasn't John.. He told me John was dead." Cathy told the officers.

"Before he died he said John was dead?" Audrey asked.

"Yeah, he said he wasn't John. I didn't believe him. And he explained how John was dead... Why didn't i believe him?" She took a sip of her tea. "I could have avoided this whole thing... John..."

"Miss. Hilson, it's not your fault. I assure you, we'll get to the bottom of this." Nathan confirmed.

Nathan and Audrey began to walk to the car. They began to converse with one-another on the possible trouble or event that happened.

"So, we should send a call out and see if they can find someone named Ben, found drunk, hungover... Or dead." Nathan sighed.

"Right, the whole 'John is dead' thing... I should call Duke." Audrey suggested.

"What? Why?" Nathan asked.

"To see if John and Ben tried to get into the Grey Gull last night." Audrey defended her actions and pulled out her cell phone. While Audrey was doing this Nathan had no choice but to turn on the police radio and call for units to look for a male gentleman or any bodies.

"Duke?" Audrey asked from her phone.

"Yeah. What's up?" Audrey heard from the other side.

"Hey, did two guys try to come into the Gull last night? Maybe they were acting too obnoxious?" Audrey asked.

"Two guys?... Uh, yeah actually. A few regulars... But i banned them from the Gull a few days ago, what were their names again... Uh..." Duke stumbled on words.

"John and Ben?" Audrey looked at Nathan knowing they were the two Duke saw.

"Yeah. How are they?" He asked over the phone.

"They're dead." Audrey told him.

"Dead? How?" Duke replied.

"We don't know, probably some kind of drunk trouble. But, if you're not too busy, there's another bar now in Haven. It's new appearently. It' called Pub 'N Glub. Have you heard of it?" She said.

"No, but that explains why business has been so slow lately." Duke chuckled.

"Do you want to check it out? Maybe ask a few questions for us about John and Ben.. And you know, you can also find out why it's booming." Audrey teased.

"Will do. Bye."

"Bye Duke." Audrey faced Nathan "So, he's going to check out the Pub N' Glub and we can go help with searching for Ben."