The team walked into the police department fifteen minutes later and talked to the chief.

"I understand your argument, but you're basing this on a video that might be from years ago,"

"You have to re-open the case, we have evidence that she is still alive. The case was never solved," Hotch argued. The chief pondered for a moment. "This can give her family some reassurance,"

"Um, Hotch," Morgan cut in. "She doesn't have a family, they died shortly after her case was closed. Her mother and father drove off a clif and her brother hung himself," he said hanging his head.

"This case has caused enough pain," the chief argued.

"Exactly, make the pain end, and help up find who started this and put him behind bars," Hotch said. The chief sat at his desk and pondered the argument before closing his eyes and nodded.

"I'm gonna regret this," he whispered. "We'll re-open the case," he said and the faintest smile crossed Hotch's face.

"Alright team, get to work, we have to find her," Hotch said walking out of the office and towards the discussion room. The team took a seat and looked at Hotch. "Morgan, if you don't want to work this case you don't have to," Hotch said but Morgan shook his head.

"If anyone is going to save her, it's me. I have to work this case," he said and Hotch nodded.

"Alright, so far all we know is that the UNSUB is mostlikely a male, around her age, no more than ten years older. She knew the man very well, even trusted him. He may or may not have been in the Fraternity, so far that is our only lead," he began when his phone rang.

"Talk to me Gracia,"

"Alright, I found over a hundred men in that fraternity in that time period. Only abotu fifteen however fit the description. I'm faxing that information over there now. I also did a little digging into people that worked at the school at the time, just to check and I found that five male's at the time had criminal records and two of those five haven't been seen since the year Casey went missing,"

"Anything else?"

"A few of the Frat boys that have criminal records are in jail, it looks like five of the fifteen have been arrested in that time period, five are in currently in jail and three are married with children, living all withing a hundred miles of here. Only two seem to fit perfectly, Darel Hines and Matthew Benson,"

"We'll look at those two more carefully,"

"Anything else?"

"Have her check any abandoned buildings and warehouses in the area, it's unlikely that her moved her very far if she is still alive. Also look for any houses with basements owned by any of those men," Reid said and Hotch nodded.

"Did you get all of that?"

"Loud and clear," Garcia said as Hotch hung up and she went to work.

"Darel Hines and Matthew Benson," Hotch said.

"I know them, both were on the football team with me, Hines was the tackle back and Benson was a forward," he said and Hotch nodded.

"Did she know them well?"

"Benson and Hines both dated girls in the sorority, well, dated, isn't exactly the correct word, more like saw, girls in the sorority. They were both pretty sweet on Casey, always trying to get at her. Hated me for yelling at them when they tried to get her to brake up with me a year before she was taken. I scared the hell out of them," he said.

"What happened after that?" J.J. asked.

"They stayed away, never went near her again. The year she went missing, they both got angry. Threatened to hurt her and me. They were the reason I stopped playing football,"

"The threats?"

"No, they hit me with their car," he said almost calmly. "I was out for the year," he said. "It was never proven that it was them becasuse their parents paid their way through the charges," he said.

"So they had motive, time, and strength," Emily said.

"It's unlikely though that the person doing this has a partner," Reid said. "One would usually excell over the other, causing a major issue. They would have killed eachother long before now," he said.

"But is it possible to have more than one person? Even on a slim chance?" J.J. asked and Reid nodded.

"In cases like this the UNSUB would usually want all of the power. The person is most likely very selfcenteres and egotistic,"

"You just described both of them, kid," Morgan said.

"Than these two would make the perfect match," Emily said.

"Brains and Brawn," Morgan said. "Benson was top of his class, Hines benched three fifty," he said. "Benson would easily be able to set the camera up, and Hines would have been able to take her,"

"But she must have trusted the person that took her. At least enough to be alone with," Hotch said.

"What if she didn't trust them?" Rossi finally spoke. "How did she sound when she was talking to you last? Do you remember?"

"She sounded normal, she was tence but she was scared so I didn't think anything of it," he said and than he paused. "They were already there," he said. "She knew it, they already had her," his head dropped again.

"We're not even sure it was them yet, though putting the pieces together, it does seem plausable," J.J. said as she picked up her phone and called Garcia agian.

"What can I do for you?"

"Get me a recent address for Matthew Benson and Darel Hines," she said as Garcia searched the computer database for them.

"It looks like they live together, 5982 S. Jefferson street," she said as J.J. hung up.

"5982 south Jefferson,"

"That's not far from the collage," Morgan said as they rushed out of the buliding and to the house.

To be continued...