A/N: Wow, a number of very sweet people reviewed which is why I am updating so fast. You guys were really nice and now I want to keep going and writing this pretty little story for you. The big chunk in italics is a flash back.
Disclaimer: Me no own Chuck or 16 and Pregnant.
"YOU WHAT!" Chuck practically screamed at Sarah. He didn't quite understand how she had always told him he could tell her anything, that honesty was key in any relationship. Now he finds out that she has been hiding this huge secret.
"How, what, how long have you known about this?" His confusion was pretty evident at this point.
"Are you asking how long I have known I've had a daughter or how long I have known she is coming here?" Sarah asked trying to lighten the mood.
"Both," Chuck responded with indignation.
"Well, I have known about her coming here since I arrived at the Starbucks about seven minutes ago, but I have know that I have had a daughter for 14 years. Chuck I didn't know how to tell you. Please, don't hate me," Sarah explained practically in tears.
"I could never hate you. But you always talk about trusting one another, about honesty and how important it is for us. Now I find out that you have been keeping this secret from me. How could you do this to me, to us?"
"I thought this was behind me. This is part of my past. I mean, I was so young when she was born, I was only 16. I never thought she would find me or ever want to come see me."
"And here she is about to show up. What am I supposed to say to this kid? I don't know anything about your past, so what can I say?"
"Ask me what you want to ask me, Chuck. I know what you really want to ask me. You want to know how I was so stupid that I could get pregnant just before my 16th birthday."
"Sarah, I... would never phrase it like that. But seriously, how did you become an episode of 16 and Pregnant? You just seem to smart for that."
Sarah took a deep breath and paused to reflect back on that night.
"Have you ever had that experience of love at first sight? You know, like when your heart stops and your stomach flips. You feel like you're going to die, throw up, and fly away on a cloud all at the same time."
"Of course I have. When I met you," Chuck replied, taking Sarah's hand and gently rubbing his thumb over the top of it. He knew this was going to be hard for her and realized that he had not been all that supportive up to this point.
"That's what happened when I met him, my first love, the father of my baby."
They met at the con. She stood there staring into his eyes and he into hers.
"Hey," he said. His voice was shaky, not at all what she thought it would be seeing as he had just rescued her.
"Thanks for that," she replied barely able to get any words out herself. She was still a little scared, maybe from nearly being trampled or maybe it was from how weird she was feeling. She didn't know what to do, but she knew she wanted to get to know him better.
"You wanna get out of here? I know this great spot on the beach. I go there every day." She was worried he would say no. He was wearing a mask, but she could tell he was cute, and he had a great smile.
He couldn't believe that a girl this pretty was talking to him. Sure, it was an offbeat beauty, but her eyes sparkled and she had long brown hair which he loved. It was then that he had been just staring at her for a full 30 seconds and she had a worried look on her face.
"Oh, yeah, sure, definitely. Let's go." He grabbed her hand and led her to the exit.
As soon as he touched her, they both felt the electricity shoot through their bodies. It was as if they had been struck by lightning. They gasped, looked down at their hands, and paused. When they looked back up at each other, they knew that this thing between them was something special that would change their lives.
They agreed to meet every day at the same time in the same place on the beach, their place. They would just talk about everything and nothing, never sharing names or other identifying things. The boy never took off his costume, which she thought was adorable. They felt safe with each other, and they knew that they were falling in love, each of them for the first time.
On the last day, they didn't know what to do. She cried and he held her. They both knew this was goodbye, but it was hard to let go of something you wanted so much. It was an unusually chilly day, so they sat in the back of his car to have their farewell talk.
"I love you, but I have to go. I'm a kid. I have a family, responsibilities at home," he said, knowing that his words wouldn't be good enough.
"I love you, too, which is why I can't let you go. Please stay, just till the end of the summer," she begged, knowing full well that this relationship would always have an expiration date.
Then he kissed her with more passion than he thought he possessed. Before she knew it, he was on top of her, and she was taking her shirt off. She didn't know what she was doing and neither did he. All they knew was that they wanted this. Things continued to get more and more heated in the backseat of his car. That evening, they both lost their virginity. What neither of them thought of at the time was using any sort of protection. They were emotional and passionate and good sense was no where to be found. They held each other then, but she knew she had to go. So she got herself together and left her first love behind.
Little did she know that he would always be a part of her in the form of her daughter who was born nine months later.
Chuck just stared at Sarah.
"Chuck, please say something. I mean, I really just poured my heart out here. I've never told anyone that story."
"Sarah, this is super important. What was this guy's name?"
"I told you, I never knew his name. We never shared names. I only know that his costume said CC on it," Sarah stated bluntly while Chuck's mouth opened wider than she thought it could.
"Sarah, I'm CC, Charles Carmichael. That was me. I'm the father of your baby."
A/N: Dun, dun, dun. Some of you had already guessed it, so good for you. I know you have questions, but they will surely be answered. Review away people, and you will get more chapters out of me.
