Note: If you are not willing to read any of the following, you should not read this chapter: Femmeslash, Hayley and Caroline having sex, two women having sex while being watched by a male, Klaus watching Hayley and Caroline have sex, or pretty much ANYTHING RELATING TO ANY OF THOSE THINGS.

I do not want to get hate mail talking about how I misled you, so to repeat: This is Klayroline, but primarily Hayroline, set right before the Klaus and Hayley sex scene in S4. If you do not like that, don't read it.


General prompt: Hayroline


He had a gut feeling that he shouldn't be doing this, but Hayley was admittedly quite fetching as long as she kept her bloody mouth shut. And really, she'd practically jumped him, and who was he to say no? Caroline didn't want him, and he had needs.

Unfortunately, he seemed to have misjudged the situation, and he felt his chest clench in panic as he heard some very familiar footsteps and rushed to get jeans buttoned and his shirt back on. Hayley seemed to feel no such need, and Klaus winced when he heard the voice echo from the doorway.

"You have got to be kidding me."

Klaus looked up from Hayley's half-clothed body to see Caroline standing against the wall, her eyes narrowed.

"Hello, love."

"Don't even," she hissed, walking through the door towards them.

He couldn't help but admire the way she moved, how the anger practically radiated off of her in waves, and his lips twitched at her next words. "You bitch."

"Why? Because I'm having a one-night stand?" Hayley asked irritably, pulling on her shirt.

"With him."

"And? You didn't want him anyway," Hayley pointed out.

Though he felt that he had to side with Caroline on principle, Hayley did make a decent point, not that he'd ever admit it.

"It doesn't matter. What is your obsession with fucking every guy who's interested in me?" Caroline asked. "I mean, I know that you and Tyler met before you met me, but you only fucked him after you got back. Oh, don't waste that face on me, I know exactly what went on, and now you're after Klaus. Seriously?"

"Oh yes, I am living vicariously through those men because I have a dark, secret crush on you," Hayley said, her voice dry and sarcastic, though she was blushing slightly.

Caroline seemed to have noticed it too, because she looked slightly surprised.

"Oh my god, you so do."

"No, I don't."

"Don't worry. I'd be lying if I said I hadn't thought about it too, once or twice."

Hayley's eyebrows flew almost to her hairline before she schooled her expression and pushed away from the desk. "Is that an invitation?" Hayley asked, her eyes raking down Caroline's sundress-clad form.

Caroline smirked, sauntering towards Hayley and lifting her hair, turning to allow Hayley to unzip her dress. It pooled to the floor and Caroline stepped out of it, turning back to the other girl and reaching over to tug her bra away, cupping Hayley's breasts and letting her thumbs brush over her nipples.

Klaus felt his mouth go dry as Hayley gasped, her head lolling back as she arched her back, pressing her breasts more fully into Caroline's palms. "You should sit down if you're going to hang around and watch, Klaus," Caroline said softly, not even sparing him a glance as she unzipped Hayley's skirt before shedding her own bra and pressing against her.

He obediently sunk down in the armchair a few feet away, gripping the armrests as he greedily took in the scene before him.

Hayley tangled her fingers in Caroline's hair and pulled her lips to meet her own, their breasts brushing together as Caroline bit Hayley's lip harshly, reaching to squeeze the other girl's arse harshly and lifting her to sit on the desk. Hayley moaned loudly against Caroline's mouth, rolling her hips against the lace concealing Caroline's core.

Klaus felt his cock straining against the front of his jeans, and he reached down to unzip his pants, pulling them down to free his erection and grasping it in his hand, stroking himself slowly as he watched Caroline's fingers trail down Hayley's inner thighs towards her pussy, slipping a finger around her thong to rub her knuckle against Hayley's clit.

Hayley was gripping Caroline's arse, her nails making indents on her creamy skin, and Caroline moaned as Hayley tugged her last piece of clothing down to her knees, spreading her legs expectantly for Hayley's fingers.

Caroline pulled back from Hayley, both of their lips swollen from kisses, eyes dark with lust, and Caroline closed her eyes as she tipped her head to the side as Hayley kissed and nipped at her neck with her blunt teeth.

"Does it bother you, Klaus?" Caroline panted out. "Knowing that Hayley gets to pleasure me with her fingers before you even get to kiss me? That she'll lick my come from my pussy while you sit there only able to inhale my scent? Does it make you angry that it's her name I'm going to be screaming as she makes me come?"

"Yes," he said, his voice low and husky even as he stroked himself more firmly.

Caroline smirked, her eyelids fluttering closed as Hayley's fingers trailed around her entrance. "Hayley, tell Klaus how wet I am for you, why don't you?"

"She's soaking," Hayley said, her voice low and husky as she pulled her fingers away from Caroline's pussy to turn to Klaus, making eye contact with him as she licked Caroline's arousal from her fingers.

His cock throbbed in his hand as he stroked himself harder, groaning softly at the visual, making Caroline smirk even as she pushed Hayley on the couch just a few feet away from him, straddling her.

"I want you to fuck me with your fingers, Hayley," Caroline gasped out, sinking down on the other girl's fingers, letting out a soft moan as Hayley complied. "Yes, Hayley, fuck me harder. Just like that…"

Caroline tore Hayley's thong off even as she rubbed herself wantonly against Hayley's fingers before pushing her own into Hayley's pussy, brushing the other girl's clit with her thumb.

Hayley moaned, her legs spread wide as Caroline fingerfucked her, her breasts heaving as she gasped out Caroline's name through her ragged breathing.

Caroline leaned over, her breasts pressed up against Hayley's, both of them moaning at the sensation, still a tangle of limbs as their fingers continued to move, and Caroline bit Hayley's ear before pulling their hands away from each other and flipping them so that Hayley was on top as they laid horizontally on the couch.

"Lick my pussy," Caroline ordered, her voice tight as Hayley sucked on the hollow of her neck.

Hayley immediately brushed her lips over Caroline's before nipping and licking her way down Caroline's body, sucking her nipples and tugging at them lightly with her blunt teeth briefly before moving lower, leaving fast-fading red marks against the skin of Caroline's stomach.

Hayley pushed Caroline's thighs back only to pull one of the other girl's legs over her shoulder as she flicked her tongue against Caroline's clit before swirling it around Caroline's entrance and burying her face between Caroline's thighs, lapping at her core enthusiastically, moaning at the taste.

Caroline tangled her fingers in Hayley's hair, holding the other girl's face against her as she ground herself against her tongue. Klaus felt his balls tighten as he watched Hayley's arse move in the air as she licked Caroline's pussy as she'd been ordered.

"Don't come on your hand, Klaus. That doesn't exactly speak well of your stamina," he heard Caroline gasp out, and his eyes locked with hers.

Her eyes were dark, her lips slightly parted as she moaned softly when Hayley swirled her tongue around her clit, but she'd clearly been watching Klaus touch himself with a lustful gaze, and he pulled his hand away, trying desperately to distract himself from how painfully hard he was by digging his nails into the armrests of the chair, watching Hayley continue to eagerly lap at Caroline's juices.

He watched Caroline throw her head back against the cushions, her eyes shut tight as she tugged Hayley's hair harshly. "Yes, make me come, Hayley," she hissed, rolling her hips against the other girl's face. "Look at me, Klaus. Don't you wish it was you with your face buried between my thighs? Your tongue licking up my juices as I moan your name? Don't you wish I was about to come on your lips? Yes, Hayley, tonguefuck me just like that…Yes, Hayley, I'm coming…"

He was so hard it was painful, and he had to fight to resist throwing Hayley across the room and sheathing himself in Caroline's tight heat.

Caroline was breathing hard once she'd stopped writhing against Hayley's face, and she let go of the other girl's hair before pulling Hayley back up to thrust her tongue in the other girl's mouth, and pushed Hayley to lie down on the couch the other way, allowing Caroline to face Klaus as she bent down, licking a trail up Hayley's inner thigh, making the other girl gasp.

"Now you're going to watch me lick her pussy, Klaus. You're going to see what you could have had if you'd just kept it in your pants for another hour. Don't you want my tongue on your cock, Klaus?" she asked, keeping eye contact with him as she gave Hayley's center a long lick, swirling it around her clit.

"Yes," he said, unable to keep the word from sounding more than a bit breathless.

"That's unfortunate, isn't it?" she said softly, bending down to wrap her lips around Hayley's clit, sucking lightly and causing Hayley to grip the cushions, sobbing out Caroline's name.

The next five minutes were pure torture as he watched Caroline's tongue dance against Hayley's skin, her nails scratching lightly down Hayley's inner thighs. She made Hayley beg for release, made her moan and scream for her, and Klaus knew that if he so much as brushed his hand against his cock, he would come all over his palm.

When Hayley was finally shaking with release and Caroline licked the other girl's pussy clean, she pushed herself up, her lips glistening from Hayley's arousal, and crawled up Hayley's body, keeping eye contact with Klaus as she feasted on the other girl's lips before pulling away slowly.

"I want you to pleasure yourself for me, Klaus. I want to watch you come all over your hand, desperate for my touch against your cock. Maybe you'll get your wish another day, or maybe watching Hayley tongefuck me is the closest to my pussy you'll ever get."


Hayley suggests to play a game where whoever stays quiet the most, wins. Caroline is very competitive and wants to win. But then Hayley, who wants to win even more, starts kissing Caroline's neck, ears, etc. They start having sex, and Caroline can't be quiet so after sex Hayley keeps teasing Caroline.


Caroline moaned as Hayley's tongue ran along the shell of her ear, causing the other girl to giggle quietly and bite Caroline's neck with her blunt teeth. "Do you want to play a game?" Hayley whispered, her voice breathy and hot against Caroline's ear.

"What kind of game?"

She felt the curl of Hayley's lips against her skin before the other girl spoke. "You know how I love it when you scream for me?"

Caroline's heart thundered in her chest as she hummed in answer, unhooking Hayley's bra and helping her shrug it off.

"If you can be quiet until I make you come, you win, but if I can make you scream…"

"Fine. What do I get if I win?"

"I'm sure we'll think of something."

"And what if you win?" Caroline asked, pulling her shirt over her head and arching her back so that Hayley could peel her bra away.

"Again, I'm sure we'll think of something."

Caroline hissed as Hayley abruptly began to lick and suck her neck, her blunt teeth scraping across her skin in just the right way to make her squirm. Hayley slid her hands below Caroline's skirt to bunch it around her waist before stroking the insides of her thighs lightly.

"Spread your legs for me?"

Caroline obliged, lifting her hips so that Hayley could pull her thong to her knees before she pushed a finger inside Caroline's soaking heat. The feeling of Hayley's finger curling against her g-spot before she added another was almost too much for Caroline, but she managed to swallow her moans as she rolled her hips against Hayley's fingers.

Caroline felt her nipples tighten as Hayley's hot breath met them, and she struggled not to pant when Hayley's lips latched against one, sucking lightly before pulling at it with her teeth.

Hayley's fingers were moving hard and fast, and they were curled to brush perfectly against Caroline's g-spot with every thrust. She squirmed to try to get more friction, spreading legs farther and raising her hips to encourage Hayley to fingerfuck her harder and faster.

"You're so hot like this, Care," Hayley said softly between swirling her tongue around Caroline's nipples. "You look so fucking sexy with your legs spread for me while you try not to moan my name."

Caroline sunk her teeth into her lower lip as Hayley bit lightly at her nipple before applying suction to soothe the sting, and she felt Hayley grin against her skin at how close she'd come to breaking.

Caroline was loud, and she knew it. Hayley had a way of coaxing whimpers and pants out of her as no one else ever could. Hayley had made her scream, made her yell her name so loudly it echoed off the walls, and she knew just how to touch her to make her beg.

The only chance Caroline had of winning the bet was to make herself come before she could make any noise.

Caroline tangled one of her hands in Hayley's hair, tugging it lightly and making the other girl moan softly against her breast, before trailing the other hand down her bare stomach and below her skirt to circle her own clit.

She took in a shuddering breath as the jolts of arousal shot up her aching core, and she gasped in surprise as Hayley slapped her hand away, pausing the movements of her mouth against Caroline's breast to chastise her.

"Caroline, you can't move it along. I intend to win this bet, and I'll do that by teasing you until you beg for my tongue on your clit."

"I won't," Caroline whispered, her eyes narrowed.

Hayley just shot her an infuriating smirk before moving to take her nipple in her mouth again, and Caroline squirmed under the movements of Hayley's expert tongue.

She felt Hayley's fingers return to their previous brutal pace, and Caroline's legs buckled as Hayley fingerfucked her hard before changing the angle so that she could rub Caroline's clit with her thumb. Her other hand circled around to squeeze Caroline's ass harshly as Hayley kissed down her abdomen.

Caroline's eyes were tightly shut in a haze of pleasure. She could feel her core aching, and the tension in her belly was building rapidly. She knew that if Hayley teased her much longer, Caroline would be begging and pleading for the other girl's tongue on her pussy.

Her thoughts were almost incoherent, and she spread her legs even further, arching her back and rolling her hips in invitation, almost missing Hayley's low laugh of satisfaction at Caroline's wantonness.

"Do you want my mouth on you?" Hayley asked, murmuring the words against Caroline's hipbone.

Caroline nodded, her teeth firmly biting into her lower lip to prevent sound, and she felt Hayley smile, the movement of her fingers slowing down. "Caroline, do you want my mouth on you?" she repeated, and Caroline nodded.

"Care, I can't hear you."

Caroline rubbed herself against Hayley's hand in frustration. "Yes," she whispered.

"What? I didn't hear you."

"Yes, please, Hayley."

"Please what?"

"Please lick my pussy."

"You want me to eat you out?"

"Yes," Caroline hissed, choking down a moan as Hayley's tongue lightly flicked against her clit.

Caroline pulled her hand to her mouth and bit down hard against her skin as Hayley's tongue swirled around her clit before her lips closed around it, sucking hard as Hayley's fingers continued their movements.

Caroline could feel the tension tightening fast, and she clenched around Hayley's fingers, her breathing ragged.

"Please."

"Please what, Care?" Hayley asked, her voice wicked.

"Make me come."

"Didn't catch that."

"Make me come, Hayley," Caroline demanded, her voice louder than she'd meant it to be.

She felt Hayley's tongue return to her pussy, Hayley's thumb moving to press against her back entrance as she enthusiastically fingerfucked her, Hayley's tongue moving rhythmically against Caroline's clit.

"Hayley, you feel so good," Caroline gasped, having now given up on being quiet as she writhed under Hayley's talented tongue. "You're so good with your mouth."

Hayley smiled against her before speeding up the movements of her fingers and mouth until Caroline was moaning loudly, grinding her pussy against Hayley's face as she rocked her hips the other girl's fingers as she came.

Hayley enthusiastically lapped up Caroline's juices as she came before pulling her fingers away and sucking them clean in front of Caroline, smirking in satisfaction.

"You were so loud."

"Was not," Caroline mumbled, though she knew that she'd lost.

"You were. I love it when you scream for me, you know. I'm never going to let you forget this."

"I know you won't," Caroline said, rolling her eyes good-naturedly. "So, what do you want?"

"For my prize, you mean?" Hayley asked, moaning softly as Caroline snuck her hand between her legs, lazily tracing Hayley's entrance.

"Yeah. You earned it, you know," Caroline said, lowering her voice slightly.

Hayley hummed contentedly as Caroline pushed a finger inside her. "I'll have to think about it."

"Well, when you figure it out, let me know."

"Oh, I will."


A/N: Thank you for reading! Almost scared to ask for your thoughts, but please do tell me what you think :)
But remember, you were warned.

Hugs!
-Angie