Thank you for the reviews
"So Haruhi, What if, hypothetically speaking it hadn't stormed that day you and Hikaru went on that date, do you think you'd be going out together now?"Kaorus question seemed to stun everyone, even Hikaru who was staring at his brother in complete awh.
"Kaoru how could you ask something like that! Of course they wouldn't be dating! Hikaru and Haruhi and brother and sister!"Tamaki yelled obviously still lost in his family related delusion. But no one else said anything, as Kaoru sat there patiently waiting for Haruhis answer.
"I guess, I'm not sure, the date was going well up until that point"Haruhi shrugged not really sure herself, she was enjoying herself that day when her and Hikaru had been out together. It wasn't like she didn't enjoy his company.
'I've never really thought about having any type of 'relationship', but I guess that was considered a date'Haruhi thought as she pondered the question in her head for a bit longer.
"Seriously.."Hikarus hadn't really given it much thought either, but maybe if he had acted better that day, he would have been with Haruhi. But of course, this is a game of what ifs.
"So now I ask the question right?"Haruhi asked seeing as how Kaoru seemed happy enough with her response to him. As Haruhi eyes scanned around the circle of her friends she noticed how Tamaki and Hikaru seemed to have tensed up, Kyoya remained looking at his note book, Hunny continued eating his eat, and Mori had an unchanged expression.
"Yeah, so go ahead Haruhi, everything's on the table"Kaoru leaned back into his seat, trying to ignore the questioning eyes of his brother who looked nervous now.
'A question..anything I want?'Haruhi thought as she looked around, her eyes passed over Tamaki was instantly pretended that he was looking at something very important on the table.
"Kyoya-senpai"Haruhi eyes fell on Kyoya who looked up from his note book, and respectfully closed it
'It seems I'm actually going to have to pay this game'Kyoya thought regretfully as he leaned forward
"Yes Haruhi?"Kyoya answered looking at her, she seemed to be slightly tense, but after Kaorus questions everyone was interested to here this question
"What if I hadn't said anything that night at the beach house, would have continued?"That was the question he had been hoping she wouldn't ask. Haruhi sat there awaiting his answer while everyone else seemed confused.
"Huh? What happened at the beach house Haru-chan?"Hunny asked innocently as he placed his fork down on the plate.
"Haruhi I think this question should be answered at another time"Kyoya narrowed his eyes as he looked at her, but somehow Haruhi seemed totally oblivious to it. While Tamaki sat there looking like some lost puppy
"No way Kyoya-senpai, rules are rules, what did you try to black mail her or something?"Hikaru asked feeling much better that the pressure was now on Kyoya and off him
"Fine, well Haruhi hypothically speaking if you hadn't answered in the way you did, I would have continued..until you pushed me off of course"Kyoya answered honestly trying to not add to much detail that would allow them to know a lot about the incident
'I don't have the energy to put up with Tamaki if he finds out what I was doing'Kyoya thought as he looked away from Tamaki
"Fair enough"Haruhi shrugged being happy enough with that answer, she had ben curious how serious Kyoya was that night and now she had her answer
"What do you mean 'until you pushed me off?' what were you doing on top of our daughter?!"As the realization hit Tamaki he instantly went into that same defensive mood he always entered when dealing with Haruhi.
"Yeah Kyoya what the hell is that!?"Hikaru stood up from his seat and curled his hands into fists, clearly upset
"I simply offered Haruhi the chance to remove her debt, by giving me her body, we didn't get very far so shall we move on"Kyoya signed not really wanting to deal with this any longer
'However..I have been curious about it'Kyoya thought as he Tamaki scooted away and started to pout, while Kaoru claimed Hikaru down.
"Now I suppose it's my turn, so Hikaru I'm curious about something"Kyoya looked over to Hikaru who was sitting next to his brother, amused by what had been going on. But with Kyoya asking the questions it was obvious that this wasn't going to be a nice question.
"What if Kaoru was to fall in love with Haruhi, would you simply let him have her?"Kyoya question was harsh, well it was like Hikarus worse nightmare actually and Kaoru looked like he was about to have a heart attack from the question.
'How..does..does he know?'Kaoru thought as he looked over at Hikaru who seemed to be completely floored by the question
"There's no way that would happen, I'd never love someone like her!"Kaoru yelled defensively trying to get Hikaru to not think so much about this. But it was too late, Hikaru was staring down at the floor and gripping his knees
"I can't answer that question"Hikaru answered as he reached into the jar and pulled out a folded piece of white paper.
Hikaru looked down at the paper and then over to Kaoru who was now standing beside him. Kaoru had written all the punishments and of course must know which one Hikaru had picked
"What's it say Hikaru?"Tamaki asked curiously as he tried to look over Hikarus shoulder
"It says I need to strip"Hikaru signed as he placed the paper down on the table and then quickly began to remove his over coat
"Sorry Hikaru I honestly thought Haruhi would grab that one, since it was at the top"Kaoru apologized to his brother.
"Stop, if you take off anymore I'm leaving"Haruhi looked away as Hikaru stood up and started to unbuckle his belt after having removed his shirt and handing it to Kaoru.
"Fine whatever, the next what if is mine"Hikaru sat down after redoing his belt.
Hikaru ran his fingers through his hair, feeling kind of weird about this whole thing. This simple game was getting out of hand but even Hikaru had some "What Ifs" floating around in his head.
"So.. What if"
What do you want Hikaru to ask? And to who?
