Chapter Warnings: Contains sex.
Warrior's Sin
Riley's heartbeat quickened as he heard the knock on the door. It was Drew. He knew it was, and he was afraid out of his mind.
He groaned to himself at his lack of foresight. He really should have planned this better. What were they going to do anyway? Just talk and come to an agreement? Drew had already shown himself to not be one to back down. It would all be so much easier if Drew would agree to a partnership of sorts – well, short of Drew disappearing all together. He clinched his fist in thought of tearing Drew a new one and sending him crying out of town, but something told him that not even that would dissuade Drew. Plus, Riley was a better person now. He didn't do anger. He would not betray the faith that Peter had in him.
Peter was such a good friend; Riley knew he couldn't ask for any better. He recalled the sheer glee he had felt this summer when Peter had offered to let him move in with him. It was a nice thought to know that he had a secure place to go if his parents ever kicked him out. It was a nice thought that made him feel more love than he was comfortable with feeling towards his best friend. It was that thought that truly kept him from moving in. He wouldn't risk ruining a friendship due to a painful crush. There was also the sheer terror of his parents ever finding out about his sexuality; it was true and a good excuse to hide behind to stay tucked away in the closet.
And it was now this closet that served as the weapon Drew Torres was using to get what he wanted.
He took a deep breath and he heard his teeth clattering ever so lightly as he opened the door. Drew was awaiting patiently with a smirk on his face that Riley didn't know if he wanted to remove with his first or his mouth.
"Sup," Drew greeted as he invited himself in. Riley grumbled without commitment as he closed the door, and turned around to find Drew making himself feel at home on the couch.
Riley just stared, not sure what steps to take next.
Drew grinned and pat the couch next to him. "Come sit," Drew requested. "We're either going to fight or make out – might as well be close to each other."
Riley nodded blankly as he took a seat. If he wasn't sure what was supposed to happen tonight, it couldn't hurt to let Drew take the reins. He could take Drew in a fight easily if it came to that, and what else could Drew really do?
He sighed as he relented, and took a seat next to Drew who wasted no time in placing his hand on Riley's arm. Riley chuckled. "Wasting no time, are you?"
Drew smirked as he removed his hand and laid back against the arm of the couch, kicking his legs into Riley's lap. "Hardly," he said. "Just seeing where things go."
Riley nodded in understanding, recalling the similarities between now and his first time alone with Zane; both were quiet yet eager for the other to make a move. He took a breath as he rested his hands on Drew's knees. Drew shifted his legs slightly and chuckled at the hardness under his thighs. Riley groaned at both the contact, and the joy that Drew was getting from this.
"Someone's having fun," Drew quipped with a smile dancing delicately on his lips. "Didn't think I'd… arouse your excitement so quickly."
"Yeah?" Riley murmured as he nudged Drew's leg with his cock. "Maybe you have."
Drew blushed at the contact.
"Embarrassed?" Riley questioned, realizing that Drew wasn't as experienced as he wanted to seem; maybe he could turn this to his advantage. If Drew's bravado was all an act, maybe he could talk him out of whatever scheme had had planned.
Riley grinned as he leaned closer. "Don't be," he said as he put his palm over Drew's lap, brushing against his already hard penis. Riley grinned as Drew giggled nervously and pushed his crotch up into Riley's palm. "You're new to this?"
"Maybe?" Drew retorted playfully. "Have you… done things with a guy before?"
"A bit," Riley stated wistfully. "Zane and I got up to a lot this summer."
Drew grinned. "He isn't bad looking, is he?"
"Not in the least," Riley said with a fresh enthusiasm. "I really like him."
"Let me guess – he was the first one to make you realize that you liked guys?" Drew asked.
"Not exactly," Riley answered. "That would be Peter. You've met him, the barista at the Dot."
Drew nodded his recognition. "He gay?"
"Here's hoping!" Riley cheered.
They sat like that for a while, eyes locked as they waited for the other to make a move. Riley kept up his occasional ministrations on Drew's member through his pants, and Drew adjusted his legs over Riley's lap in a feigned attempt to get comfortable.
"This brings back memories," Riley murmured wistfully. "Touching another guy for the first time, waiting for the other to make a move as we feel each other up."
"It… has its appeal," Drew agreed. "Where do we go next?"
"Come 'ere," Riley invited as he pulled Drew into his lap by his arms as he relaxed against the back of the couch. Drew barely covered a yelp as he went along with the momentum, and settled with his crotch painfully pleasant against Riley's as he rested his knees around his waist. "Kiss me," Riley whispered seductively into Drew's ear.
Drew gasped at the heat on his ears and his lips were on Riley's before the words had left his mouth. His lips ate at Riley's hungrily as he humped against Riley's abs and his hands slid behind the older boy's neck to pull them deeper into a kiss.
Riley grunted and pressed into Drew's rear with his cock, before reaching under Drew to grab his butt and give it a squeeze. Drew moaned as he rubbed his body against Riley more eagerly, and then let out a shuddering exhale of breath as Riley's hand slid under his pants to grab his bare ass.
"Nice and smooth," Riley groaned lustfully as he broke their kiss and started trailing his lips down Drew's neck. It was thrilling to Riley to see and feel a moaning, lithe and tan body writhing in such a way that got him harder than any amount of porn could. He hadn't been sure how things would go tonight, and a part of him had doubted what Drew would be willing to do. But now that Drew was melting like putty in his hand, he knew that Drew would do anything he wanted – and Riley wanted nothing more than to hear Drew whimpering into the couch as he pounded him.
"You like that?" Drew croaked in as much of a brag as he could managed as he moaned into Riley's neck.
"Yeah," Riley groaned. "Twinky Torres is right up my alley."
"That's definitely one gay terminology I know," Drew murmured into a yelp as Riley gripped at his ass. He stroked his right cheek with one hand, while he squeezed on his left with the other with enough force to cause Drew to moan and hump at Riley with renewed enthusiasm.
"You like your ass being played with?" Riley asked, only to be answer by a warm sigh into his ear before Drew started nipping at it with wet lips. "First time I take it? You going to bottom for me, Drew?"
"Su-sure," Drew stammered into as his body shuddered into a sigh. "Are you gonna just uh… put it in?" he asked nervously.
"Not quite," Riley said knowing as he slipped a finger between the crack of Drew's ass. He chuckled as Drew jerked almost violently in his arms as his index finger brushed his anus. "You're entirely too tight for that – plus, I have a whole set of plans for us…"
"And what's that?" Drew queried, relieved that there was more time before he had a penis whose size he hadn't yet witnessed inside him – all he knew was that it was sizable from the hardness digging into his leg.
"Ever wondered what a dick taste like?"
Drew's reaction to his questioned was priceless to Riley, as Drew froze and pushed away far enough to look at his penis, and his hands began to trace the outline of his cock through his pants.
"Maybe I have," Drew teased.
"Want to give it a go?" Riley asked. Drew nodded slowly in answer before Riley spoke again. "Take it out," he coaxed.
Drew eagerly tucked his fingers under the buckle of Riley's belt and unclasped it as his thumbs pushed into the button to pop the pants loose. The zipper came down with momentum as Drew pulled Riley's pants down before Riley lifted his rear to kick them off the rest of the way.
Drew giggled at the sensation of pubic hair on his fingers as they slipped beneath the waistband of Riley's underwear. Riley groaned as Drew pulled his dick out and stroked it awkwardly. They shared a silly smirk as Drew explored touching a dick for the first time, and Riley was once again reminded of his time with Zane. Was it like this with all guys? Or was it the excitement of exploring sex with a new guy?
Those thoughts were lost on him as the tip of his dick flushed with warmth as Drew's tongue darted over it, before pulling back. "Don't be nervous," Riley said. "Just kind of go for it – it's not as weird as you think. You'll probably like it."
Drew nodded, and went down without much more hesitation. Riley's breath hitched as Drew's warm mouth surrounded his penis, and he groaned as Drew's tongue explored the underside. He let Drew keep to his own devices as he explore giving his first blow job; he wasn't particularly good at it, but it was fun enough as he stroked his fingers through the younger boy's hair.
Riley felt Drew do something similar to a gulp as he gave his ass a slap before slipping his hand back under them to stroke his smooth cheeks. He was about to start loosening Drew up when he realized there were still a few steps he had to follow.
"Get up," Riley ordered gently.
Drew pulled his head up slowly to look into Riley's eyes.
"I'm going to go see if I can go find some lube and a condom in Peter's stuff," Riley informed. Drew nodded and wiped stray saliva from his cheek. "Go ahead and strip down while I'm gone," Riley suggested as he stood and discarded the underwear at his ankles.
Riley darted up the stairs and headed for Peter's room. He sighed with ecstasy as he inhaled the scent. He hated himself for it, but there was always something enticing about his first crush's scent. He was excited for the chance to go through his drawers for a justified reason. Peter had after all been gung ho about him meeting up with Drew; stood to reason that he would want him to play it safe.
The first place he looked was the top drawer of Peter's nightstand and it was the jackpot. Lube was the first thing he saw which elated him, and a sex toy that he would have to tease the hell out of Peter for. Sadly, there was no condom so he'd have to leave things up to Drew in that regard.
He danced down stairs and his jaw nearly dropped as he saw Drew resting lazily on the couch with a sly grin on his face, clad only in his underwear. Riley licked his lips at the well-muscles yet lean tan skinned guy that awaited him.
"I found some lube," Riley said as Drew saw him. "No condom though."
Drew broke into a laugh at that. "Sounds like he has more solo-time than anything."
Riley snickered at that. "Do you still want to do it - without a condom? I hate to think I'm teaching you bad habits, but it's really the only option that we have."
"It's fine," Drew said dismissively. "What's the worst that could happen?"
Riley grinned as he collapsed onto Drew's body to plant a kiss on his lips before travelling down his body with kisses. Drew gasped as lips passed by his nipples then settled into a low groan as they passed his belly button and down to his underwear.
Riley looked up to see Drew's eyes clouded with pleasure and grinned as he pull down Drew's boxers, took a moment to admire his attractive penis, and took it within his mouth in one swift motion. Riley enjoyed the sound Drew made at that and sucked his dick with an enthusiasm he never had before. Riley felt his dick twitch every time Drew whimpered or exclaimed the coveted 'oh fuck.'
Riley kept up his oral ministrations until he knew Drew was about ready to blow before he pulled off to look Drew in the eyes. "Having fun?"
"So much," Drew groaned in reply.
Riley adjusted so his back was against the cushions of the couch and pulled Drew into his lap as was their position earlier. "Kiss me," he requested as he squirted lube into his hands. Riley groaned as Drew followed his command and pressed his lips to Riley's mouth and humped up against Riley's abs, his penis now moistened by saliva and precum.
Riley slipped his lubed hand behind Drew and stroked it sensually down his back and over his butt before sliding his fingers into Drew's crack once again. "Let me know if it gets uncomfortable," Riley said as he began to make circular motions on Drew's hole with his slickened index finger. Drew made no sounds of protest as Riley loosened him up, and just continued finding new ways to explore Riley's mouth with his tongue.
Riley had two fingers comfortably inside Drew and was playing with getting a third into him when Drew made his first whimper of protest. "You okay?" Riley asked.
"Ugh, yeah," Drew groaned. "Just give me a moment."
Riley grinned and adjusted Drew's position on him until his penis grazed the younger boy's rear. "You can take over now. Just kind of sit on it and take it slow until you're comfortable."
"Oh god," Drew groaned as he reached under himself to find Riley's dick.
"Wait," Riley yelped. "We'll definitely want more lube," he said as he squirted a large glob on his dick and spreading it all over before applying excess lube between Drew's cheeks. "That's better. Let me know if you need more."
Drew nodded slowly and made a face as the head of Riley's cock was at his entrance. He puckered his lips up to his nose as he pushed down ever so slightly, the huffed as if the air had been knocked out of him as it popped in past his anus.
They shared a chuckle at Drew's accomplishment.
Riley tilted his head back and groaned with ecstasy as Drew slowly slid down his shaft, getting inch by inch in until his ass was down to the base. "It feel okay?" Riley asked.
"It's… something," Drew murmured with a grimace.
"Once you feel comfortable, let me know and I'll flip you over to give you a world of pleasure."
Drew nodded as he slowly lifted his body up before dropping down causing him to release a squealing grunt.
"I take it you liked that?" Riley asked hopefully, words slurred by the pleasure coursing through his veins and over his skin.
"A bit," Drew moaned as he repeated the motion which made Riley shudder and use every bit of his will power not to thrust up into Drew – soon, but not quite yet would he take charge.
They shared moans as Drew repeated the motion several for times, and soon enough Drew was riding him with full enthusiasm as he trailed his hand up and down Riley's check.
"Ughh," Drew moaned as he completed a thrust down. "This is pretty good."
"You haven't felt anything yet," Riley promised as he lifted Drew off of him and laid him face down on the couch. Riley tossed him a pillow. "Get comfy. I'm about to show you what a real ride is like."
Drew whimpered with excitement as Riley climbed up behind him and started trailing kiss up his back before stopping at his neck to plant kisses that were sure to leave a hickey. He head Drew sigh into the pillow he as placed his dick above Drew's ass. Riley tilted Drew's face towards him and placed a long kiss onto his lips as he slid his penis back into him; they groaned into each other's mouth at the pleasant intrusion.
Riley pushed all the way in and groaned at the warmth that surrounded his penis. It had been scarcely a minute but it felt like a lifetime without the pleasant heat. The groans Drew made as he buried his face into the pillow drove him wild and he did it again eliciting a similar cry of ecstasy from Drew.
"You like this?" Riley asked and he was met by a grunt and nod from Drew. Taking that as he que to continue, he kept at it until the world was a haze around him and the only sounds he recognized were the stimulating groans from Drew, the slapping of their skin, and his own exhausted grunts.
The next he knew the world was spinning and Riley saw a haze of white through his clinched eyes as he pumped into Drew and came.
"Uh, yeah," he heard Drew whimpering as he returned to his sense, and Riley was so turned on that he returned his lips to Drew's neck.
"You like that?" Riley whispered between kisses. "Did you cum?"
"Yeah," Drew exhaled between heavy breaths. "Somewhere in there."
"Good," Riley murmured as he slowly withdrew his penis from inside Drew and pulled Drew up until they were both in seating position. He smirked as he saw Drew's stomach soaked with his own cum. "I see you did." His eyes drifted down to the couch under where Drew was. "Peter is so going to kill me for that."
"I'll say," Drew agreed. "We made quite the mess."
"Yeah," Riley laughed. "I can't believe we did that."
"I wasn't that bad I hope?" Drew asked.
"Not at all."
They remained in silence for a while.
"So, I hope I taught you a few thing?" Riley asked to fill the air.
"You did," Drew acknowledged.
"Maybe we could make this a thing. I can teach you about being quarterback – and maybe a little bit of sexy time."
"Hmm, maybe?" Drew asked himself. "Can we talk about this tomorrow? I should probably get home – and I need to make an excuse for all these hickeys."
Riley nodded slowly. It wasn't what he had hoped for, but it sounded like Drew was at least considering a more peaceful solution to their quarrel.
"Sounds good," he said as he fetched their clothes from the floor, and threw Drew's at him. "Do you need a ride home?"
Drew shook his head. "I'll be fine. Walking home will give me time to make a story."
"I thought you didn't mind if you parents knew?"
"Correction," Drew stated as he slipped his shirt on. He frowned at the stickiness on his abs, but shook off the discomfort. "I said I'm not ashamed of liking guys, or even people knowing. Doesn't mean I want my parents to know about my sex life."
Riley nodded. "Makes sense," he said slowly. After a pause, he spoke again. "I'm trying, you know? To come out. I really look forward to the day when I can just be myself."
"That's good," Drew stated from the floor as he put his arm under the couch. "Hopefully it works out for you." He made an AHA! motion as he stood up. "Dropped my phone!" he said brandishing it.
Riley nodded. "I'll walk you out," Riley said now fully-clothed as he walked Drew toward the door. "Be safe!"
Drew chuckled. "Don't worry," he promised as he gave Riley a peck on the lips before turning and heading down the hall.
Riley was grinning like an idiot as he saw his new special friend heading down the hall. He hoped that it wouldn't be the last time that they meet on such 'friendly' terms.
