Longing

She wanted to dance with him but he had Elena.


Dancer

He was to no surprise a really very good dancer.


Stand-in

She held Matt's hand but it was Stefan's she wanted.


Desperation

She only cared about Matt because he reminded her of Stefan.


Mess

She was a mess on the inside because of him.


Sex


She felt Matt's skin on hers and wondered how Stefan's would.


Inadequate

In Matt's mom's eyes, she would never be good enough.


Ferrari

It was a nice car. She mused with a smile.


Proxy

Matt's lips fell on hers all she thought of was Stefan.


Back-up

Would she always be the Elena back-up every single time?


Vervain

The pain was incredible and the single thought of Caroline kept him sane.


Corpse

She found Vicki Donovan's body in the woods and screamed for Stefan.


Pageant

She looked regal like a queen and he controlled his desire.


Blood

All he could focus on was how hers would taste.


Incarceration

While there in prison, all he thought of was her.


Based on Season One, episode 11-20