After killing and burning the bodies of the Vampires, Reggie and Tim sat at the table, talking to each other about what was about to happen to Sam. They couldn't wait to get started with him for what had happened to their friend, they have been seeking revenge ever since he died at the hands of Demons. Knowing that Winchester started the apocalypse, letting Lucifer free, drinking Demon blood to kill Demons. When they found that out both men were going to use Sam as a weapon, getting him high on blood to do the killing for them before they killed him.
Things did not work in their favor when Sam fought back spitting the blood out of his mouth, knocking them out so he could escape with the girl he work with. After that Sam disappeared from the town he lived and work in, they have been searching for him ever since. They have heard of him joining back with Dean a few weeks later, staying away from both Winchesters until the time was right. When they heard of Dean disappearing with no trace of him, they started their search for Sam again coming up empty on leads they got. Some might have thought that Sam got killed after the attack; others think he's in hiding, while other hunters think he went off the grail. Either way Reggie and Tim had to stop their search again, both were really anger that they couldn't get to Sam.
Now that Dean was back again teaming up with Sam, they stayed as far away as possible. Not knowing how the older brother got back to his younger brother, they kept a safe distance until they knew the facts. Hearing in the hunters grape vine that the brother's had a Angel on their side, always helping them in some way or another, they kept their ears open. Finding out that Dean was back with a Vampire he help escape, they knew they would need some help from other hunters. Some of the hunters they talked too wouldn't help them, for being in fear of the brothers, or being in fear of Dean. That was until they meet a hunter name Nathan who has a grudge against Dean, come to found out that he got his brother killed on a hunt. Now they had what they needed someone who wasn't afraid of Dean, who wanted to find him and take what was his as pay back. Now after four years they are finally getting their own payback from what happen too Steve, they are going to make Sam pay with his life at the same time breaking Dean. Sitting around the table drinking their beers while they waited for Nathan, they both talked about what they would do to Sam.
"When I finally get my hands on that freak downstairs, I'm going to give him so much pain by beating the hell out of him. After that going to carve him like a Thanksgiving turkey going to do it slowly, so he can feel ever ounce of pain I will be giving him." Reggie sneer.
"You better leave him alive for the rest of us, Reggie for our payback, that is when Nathan is done with him. Still don't know why he is giving him blood transfusing for, if he is only going to kill him." Tim said through clench teeth.
"The reason why I'm giving him blood is to keep him alive long enough, for all of us to have our fun with him. That blood-sucking freak took a lot of blood from Sam almost killed him, so we need to replenish his blood supply so we can have our fun." Nathan said as he walked into the room.
"Well, I still think we should just have ended his life then, sending his body parts to his brother."
"What's the fun of that, Tim if we did that, don't you want to have fun with Sam before we kill him? I want some payback for what Dean did to my brother on that hunt; the only way I can do that is by giving his brother the same thing. After I'm done with him Dean is going to know that pain I felt, when I lost my brother to Demons who tore him apart."
"Nathan, we do understand the revenge you have against Dean Winchester, we have beef with him to for what he did too us. You don't know the kind of person Winchester is when he's in his so called brother mode, he would tear you apart for looking at Sam the wrong way or even hurting him. Knowing him right now he's probably on the search for his brother as we speak, even though they are fighting at the moment that doesn't stop him for being protective."
"Reggie, for some reason Sam was caught by those Vampires while away from his brother care, so what ever is happening between them I'm counting on Dean to look for him. They might be fighting or Sam was on some kind of run, either way the older brother will be looking for Sam. He don't even know where his brother is being held at, we only found out was by Joey who happen to see the Vamps taking Sam here."
"It's been two days, Nathan, since you have been giving Sam blood, how much longer do we have to wait to have our turn with him?"
"He's improving. His blood pressure is almost back to normal; by tomorrow we should be able to have our fun with him. Don't worry you guys will have your first shot with him, while I go pay his brother a visit. Want to see what that asshat is up too these last four days, want to see if he really cares about his brother or not. Don't worry he won't see me going to plant some of Sam's belongings by the motel, starting with this that has his blood on it." Nathan hold up Sam's shirt covered in his blood.
All three hunters smiled wickedly as they looked at the younger brother's shirt, it was dark in color compare to the blue it should be. Knowing when Dean's see it he's going to be in big brother mode, charging in to save his younger brother from death.
Laying the shirt on the table he turned to the other hunters, telling them to get some good sleep for tomorrow. Heading down stairs he walked into the room where Sam is now laying, making sure his binds are tight and his blood pressure was back to normal. Nodding his head he knew tomorrow would be the day for some major payback, with that in mind he laid on the bed in the same room as Sam was in.
~~~SPN~~~
Feeling the fog lifting from his mind there were two things Sam felt, sharp pain that seared through his body, he was no longer hanging like a piece of meat. He slowly try to move his body which felt like dead weight being tied down by a lead brick, moving his head was even harder to do with the marching band playing in it. Ever inch of his body even though he couldn't move it hurt like hell, just the slightest movement cause white-hot pain shot through him. With his head pounding with each beat of his heart he couldn't think, or hear since he only heard each beat with his headache. Trying to open his eyes took a great deal of effort; they felt so heavy to move them like someone was keeping them close. When he finally got them to open was a feat in itself, he blink a few times to clear the fog in his vision. Lifting his head to see where he was that is when he saw he was tied to a chair, trying to think what had happen to him as he looked around the room. Wanting to stand he tried to lift himself from the chair, only to feel binds on his hands, ankles and chest, confusing went through his foggy mind. Why was he tied to a chair? Why wasn't he at the motel? Where was his brother? The thought of Dean brought everything back to Sam like a wave hitting a sea wall, the words that were said to him, the punch to the jaw, running from the room. Being hit in the head to wake up to a Vampire drinking from him, all of that came back to Sam mind so fast it made his head swirl. Closing his eyes taking deep breaths to calm himself down, he could feel his stomach turning with the pounding of his head.
When he finally got his breathing back to normal well as normal as could be, he open his eyes to look around the room. He didn't see the Vampire anywhere in the room not even in the shadows; hearing foot steps coming down the stairs his heart sped up pounding in his chest. Trying to calm himself down was hard to do, he didn't know if he could handle another feeding or the pain. Hearing the footsteps coming closer he tried to get his hands free, that is when he realize he had some strength in him. He tried hard to free his hands from their bind he pulled and tug; the ropes were tied tight around his wrists and the arm of the chair. Waiting for his capture to returned to feed on him he tried his best not too look fearful, even though he was terrified of what was about to happen to him.
He felt himself tense when the person came through the door to his prison room, breathing a sigh of relief when he saw it was a human. Thinking it was someone who was here to rescue him he sag against the ropes, only to be hit hard in the head by the man standing in front of him. Shaking the black dots from his vision he glared at the man, he didn't even know him so why is he here and what does he want. Clearing his throat he was going to ask the man, only to have him beat to it first.
"Hello Sammy, I bet you are wondering who I am?"
"How do you know me? What do you want with me?"
"I know all about you, Sam Winchester, the kid with the Demon blood." Seeing Sam go pale he smirk at the man. "I told you I know who you are Sammy, the Demon spawn of Lucifer, drinking Demon blood to get your high. Don't worry I'm not going to make you drink any blood, or my friends won't make you drink either. Isn't that right Reggie and Tim."
Seeing Sam's eyes go wide he laughs at the young man's distress, seeing the two men walking in he saw how tense Sam got. Still standing in front of Sam he grabbed his head roughly so he was looking at him.
"I'm going to tell you who I am since I have a bone to pick with your brother."
"What did Dean do to you?"
"Well see Sammy, my brother was on a hunt with Dean a couple of years back, they were hunting Demons in Houston, Texas at a warehouse. Your brother Dean got my brother killed for being to reckless on the hunt, they separated your stupid brother lead mine into the trap. The tore Andy apart while Dean stood there and watch, so now I'm going to do payback with you to show Dean how it feels."
"Hate to burst your bubble, Dean wants nothing to do with me, kick me out of his life. If you want payback go get his brother Benny, he'll be more concern about him not me."
"Well, if he don't care about you then he won't mind if we tear you apart, but first we are going to have some fun with you. I bet Dean will care when we bring you back, well I have some things to do have fun Reggie and Tim."
Turning from Sam Nathan walked out the door towards the steps, when he reaches the top one he heard Sam's screams of pain. Smiling to himself he pick up the shirt walking to the door, when he started to walk out he heard more screams coming from down stairs. Getting into the car placing the bloody shirt next to him, he pulled out of the drive way heading towards the motel Dean is staying in. Stopping a few buildings from the building he walked the rest of the way, glancing around he didn't see anyone around in the parking lot. Looking at the door he saw the Impala parked right out side of it, seeing another car that was a station wagon with brown paneling. Walking up to the Impala he place the bloody shirt on the hood, so when Dean comes out it would be the first thing he sees. Walking back to the street he hid behind the bush and waited, hearing door opening he peered around the bush in the shadows. Seeing a man in a trench coat walking out a door next to the Impala, with a smaller man behind him closing the door. Waiting to see what they would do he looked around to make sure no-one was watching, he knew it would be tricky coming here in the morning he wanted to see Dean's face. What made him anger was the man in the coat took the shirt off the car, handing it to the smaller one who put it in his car. Turning on his heals he walked back to his car in an anger stride, he couldn't believe that man would move the shirt. He would need to ask Sam who he was and that little bastard, they both ruined his plan he had set up for the older brother.
~~~SPN~~~
Stepping out the door Castiel waited for Garth to pull into the parking lot, seeing a brown station wagon pulling in he waited for the hunter. As he pulled up the Angel could see he was wearing one of Bobby's old truckers hat, smiling at the thought of his friend who he lost as he waited for Garth. Waiting patiently while he got a room next too theirs the step inside to talk privately.
"I got your message, amigo, came as soon as I could, what's going on with Dean and Sam."
"I don't know what an amigo has to do with Sam missing, got your number from Dean's phone."
"Sam's missing, what happened, is Dean looking for him."
"That is why I called you in, Dean is not looking for his brother, he's helping a Vampire to find a nest instead of trying to find Sam."
"Wait! Dean is working with a vamp while Sam is missing? What happen since the last time we met?"
"It's a long story that I can tell you while we search for Sam, we need to get going I got a feeling he's in trouble."
"Okay, let's get going then and Garth this town on our search for Sam."
"Garth this town, do I want to know what that means."
Garth looked at Cas shaking his head at him, Dean and Sam has told him about the Angel. They were telling him the truth on how he is.
"Never mind let's get going we need to find Sam."
Opening the door Cas looked over at Dean's door deciding if he wanted to tell him, thinking it over he thought better of it. As he turned toward the smaller man he notice Sam's shirt on the car, walking over he pick it up seeing blood he search the parking lot. He knew who ever put it here can't be too far away, hearing a vehicle driving down the road he couldn't get a good look at it. Knowing the person has to be close he check carefully, maybe someone was hiding in a shadows of the trees or bushes. Seeing no-one he was about to hand it too Garth when he heard Dean's door opening, telling the man to hid it in his car he turned blocking Dean's view. What Cas didn't know is when he took the shirt off the hood, he smear some blood over the car black skin.
Glancing over to the older hunter he waited for him to say something as he walked out, hearing a car door close he felt Garth next to him. Waiting for Dean's response which he knew was coming, when he found out what he was doing he would be anger. Not caring on what the older brother had to say Cas walked over to Garth car, ready to get in he heard Dean asking him where's he's going.
"Cas what are you doing out here this early-what is Garth doing here?"
"Amigo, here called me in to help find Sam-"
"Dammit Cas I told you to leave that subject alone about Sam, he was the one who left-"
"Why did he leave, Dean?"
"Because he's a selfish bastard that's why."
"That is not the truth Dean you told him to leave after you hit him, telling him he's not your brother anymore, can't even trust him, should have left his sorry ass behind. Did I cover everything you said to him."
"Cas I didn't mean any of that Sam knows how I-"
"Dean, Sam has been trying to make things up to you for what he did, you have been tearing him down every time he tries to say anything. Yes Dean you did mean everything you said to him so don't lie to me, you broke your brother now he could be somewhere dying or dead and do you care." Cas waited for an answer from the older brother, not getting one who knew his answer. "You don't care about Sam anymore."
Cas shook his head as he got into Garth car not hearing on what Dean said to him; he's done with the man's attitude towards his brother. He will go out and find Sam himself takes him away so Dean won't be able to find him.
~~~SPN~~~
Pulling out of the parking lot Garth headed for down town to start their search, he glance over at Cas to see if there was any reaction from him. He could see how angry the Angel is at Dean for not caring about Sam, he was surprise to hear it from Dean in not so many words. When they reach down town Garth looked for a parking space, finding one he pulled in shutting off the engine he glance over at the Angel. He needed to know what the plan was.
"Cas, what do you have in plan?"
"We go and asked questions if anyone notice anything strange going on, isn't that what you hunters do?"
"We do ask questions Cas even look for things that might not be notice by others, let's go start at that that bar over there to see what they might know?"
Before getting out of the car Garth reach over to his glove department, pulling out an ID for a federal agent. Glancing at the man next to him he motion to see if he had one, pulling his ID out of his pocket they both got out of the car.
Walking around the car the younger hunter walked down the sidewalk towards the bar, he didn't have to look too see if Cas was behind him. Pulling the door open he waited until Cas walked in before he step inside, looking around he saw a man standing behind the counter with two people sitting next to him. Pulling out a picture of Sam he walked up to them with Cas behind him, stepping up Garth nodded his head to him to come over. Pulling out his badge motioning Cas to do the same he showed him who he is, handing him the picture he asked if he saw this man.
"How may I help you gentlemen?" Greg asked them as he walked up to them.
"I'm Detective Ryan Carver and this is my partner Detective Jim Singer, we are looking for this man who went missing five days ago."
"What has he done to have two Detective looking for him?"
"He hasn't done anything wrong he's a friend of the family, he was supposed to get together with my sister. When he didn't show up she waited a few days before calling us, we have been checking around for two days now."
"I know most of the people that come in here to drink and have fun, I haven't seen this man come into my bar." Turning to his friends he asked them. "Billy, Donny have you seen this gentlemen at your jobs."
Walking over to his friends he showed them a picture of Sam, shaking their heads no he gave the picture back to Garth.
"Sorry, we couldn't help your sister find her friend Detective, hope he does show up soon." Billy after he handed the picture back Greg.
"What about you, Donny have you seen her friend?" Cas asked when he didn't answer.
"No, I have never seen the man before at my job, sorry I have to go now see you later, Greg."
Donny stepped off the stool heading towards the door, glancing back to see if anyone was following him. Having a feeling he was lying Cas told Garth he had to use the restroom, stepping out the back door he hurried to see were the man was heading. Following him closely not close enough to be seen by him, he notice the man looked nervously around to make sure he wasn't being followed.
As the man walked into a building Cas notice it was apartments not his work place, carefully he walked in as he stepped into the elevator. Seeing what floor he stopped at the Angel looked around the lobby, seeing no one in sight he disappeared with a flutter of wings. Appearing in the hallway he saw the man enter a room down the hall, walking quietly as he can he stopped in front of the door listening carefully. He could hear him talking to someone about some people looking for someone, confused he turned the doorknob seeing if it was lock, it wasn't. Stepping inside Donny's back was to him as he talked on the phone, waiting for the man to get off Cas stood and waited for him.
"Hey there are some Detectives here asking the same questions as the others...no I didn't tell them anything...you know what they said if we spoke to anyone...you might want to die I don't...well then I have to keep low so they can't find me...thanks for the help buddy bye."
Hanging up the phone he turned around shock to see Cas standing behind him, placing two fingers on his forehead both men were outside in a back alley. Looking stunned at what just happen the man look fearfully at the Angel, glancing for a way out not seeing one he stepped back from the Detective/Angel.
"How did we get here? What the hell do you want?"
"I know you are lying about my friend when you saw his picture, I can tell when someone is lying you are."
"I don't know anything I sw-" Donny felt pain on his back as air was pushed out of his lungs.
"Don't lie to me there's something you know about him, who were you talking too on the phone. Don't say it was nothing I heard the fear in your voice, so what are you hiding from me."
"Okay, okay don't get your panties in a bunch dude, the only thing I know is that there were four guys looking for him."
"Who were these guys? What did they want from you?"
"They came into my job two days ago asking if we saw that same person, my co-worker said he saw him around town walking like he lost his best friend. They asked if we know where he is staying, what time does he show up, in what direction he came from. I couldn't tell them anything since I have never seen him, my co-worker told them everything they wanted to hear. When they left their leader told us if we ever said a word about this, they would come back and kill us."
"So we kept quiet about the talk with them, not telling anyone on what they said. I have a family to protect so I couldn't have them comeback, they might have killed me and my wife and kids."
"We does your co-worker live so I can go question him, he might know where they are staying."
"He's not in town he left for vacation last night to California, he won't be back for two weeks. Even trying to call him he won't talked about what they did, he came back scared like he shit himself, what ever they did to him he won't say."
"That would be useless to talk to him or trying to find him, were these four men carrying guns or knives. I have to know if they are hunters or some other creature."
"Where are you from talking about hunters or creatures, this is not the twilight zone-" Feeling another round of pain to the back and head as he hit the brick wall. "Okay, okay no they didn't have guns or knives that I could see."
"Then they must have been hiding them from you when they came in, if you say one word what I said or did I will come back and smite you. Do I make myself clear."
Seeing the man shaking his head yes to his question, Cas laid two fingers on his forehead knocking him out before placing him back in his room. Appearing again in the bar's bathroom he walked out the door, seeing Garth still talking with the owner he motion the hunter too leave.
"I was thinking you fell into the toilet Cas, what took you so long." Garth asked the men.
"I followed the gentleman to his apartment building took him out back to talk, he said there were four men here two days ago looking for Sam. He didn't see Sam, his co-work has, they asked him where they saw him around town. The boy told them after he showed them in what direction Sam went to, was going to talk to him he's on vacation in California so I won't be able to find him."
"That is just great, BALLS! What are we going to do now Cas, how are we going to find Sam."
"We need to ask around some more to see if anyone has seen him, or maybe asked about the Vampires that are in town."
"One hunter to an Angel Cas, you don't go asking about Vampires to people, they might think you got out of the funny farm. Let's go and asked some people if they heard of disappearance."
Walking with his new friend he let Garth take the lead on the questions.
~~~SPN~~~
Dean stood like he was frozen when Cas asked him if he cared about Sam, if he cared if he was dead to him. He did care for his little brother just because he was piss as hell at him, didn't mean he didn't care about him. He does have a right to be piss at his brother for what happen, Dean would never give up looking for Sam no matter what. So why did Sam give up so easily on looking for him for a whole year, thinking about it brought a whole new level of anger towards his brother. He was seeing red when he thinks about all the betrayal Sam has ever done to him, breathing hard to calm the ragging fire in him he turned back to the door. Running his hand over the hood he felt something sticky on his hand, looking he saw red blood on his palms and fingertips. Frowning on how it could have gotten there he would have to asked his brother, opening the door he looked over at Benny who was now sitting at the table.
"Hey brother, what was all that about?"
"Cas still has the idea that Sam is hurt or dying, when in truth he's just hiding licking his wounds."
"Chief, maybe we should go look for Sam-"
"Benny, don't you start this shit now, he's an adult he can take care of himself. He didn't need me when I was in Purgatory, he don't need me now when I'm back. It's what he wants so he has it now see how far he'll get, by the way why is there blood on the hood of the Impala. Did we get into a fight last night at the bar, or maybe on a hunt can't remember how it got there?"
"I couldn't tell you, Chief, how it got there don't know, we should go-let me finish, go look for the Vamp nest now while the sun is out."
"Benny, the sun will burn you too if you are out in it too long, how are you suppose to hunt with me during the day?"
"I will hide in the back seat of the Impala with towels covering the windows, when we get to a few places let me off in the shade."
"Alright let's go then brother so we can find some Vamps to kill."
Grabbing a few towels Dean open the back passenger door for Benny to get in, leaving the his friend he headed back inside secretly leaving Sam a note.
As Dean headed back inside Benny smile wickedly as his plans were going perfectly.
~~~SPN~~~
Storming back inside of the house they had Sam held in, Nathan ran down stairs to confront Sam about the younger hunter and man in trench coat. Walking into the room in a anger stride he pushed Tim and Reggie away from Sam, he didn't care if they were cutting him or not, he needed answers.
"You are going to tell me who is that person in the trench coat is, who is the younger man with him looking like a string bean."
Breathing through the pain Sam was in he could only hear some of the words the man said, blinking slowly he looked at the man with a blank face. Trying to focus on him he felt a sharp pain to the head when Nathan hit him hard, shaking the stars out of his sight he glance at the man in front of him.
Leaning further into Sam space he asked the man again who they were.
"Answer my question Sam who is the man in the trench coat, and the string bean man beside him, won't be asking again."
"D-don't know about the thin man who were talking about, Cas wears a coat, that could be him. There are only three of them staying there in the room."
"Don't lie to me Winchester not in the mood right now, planted something for your brother too see those two ruined it. So I'm asking one more time, who is the string bean man."
"I don't know who he is, there was only Dean, Benny and Cas that was it."
Seeing the anger in the man eyes put the fear in Sam, he didn't see the knife coming until he felt the pain in his side. Screaming as it went in deep Nathan moved it around giving as much pain as possible, hearing his screams excited the man he's going to give him more if he don't get the answer he wanted.
"Who is the young man that looks like a string bean Winchester."
"I-I d-don't k-know." Sam told him between gasp of pain.
"That is not the answer I'm looking for Sammy, I'm going to get my answer one way or another. You two go out and get some lunch, while Sam and I have some fun together."
Glancing at the two men who were moving he shoved them out the door, waiting for them to leave the house he turned back to Sam. Twirling the knife in his hand he walked behind Sam placing his hand on his shoulder, leaning close to his hear he asked the same question to him.
"You are going to tell me who the other hunter is Winchester, or I'm going to carve you up like a Christmas Turkey. Placing your parts in a bag before I returned them to your brother, going to see that look of lost in his eyes when he sees you."
"I already told you I don't know who the other hunter is, as for Dean he won't care if you kill me. He will thank you for putting me out of his life."
"Well Sam we'll have to see about that now won't we."
Taking the knife Nathan pushed it in on Sam's left side, he made sure he miss any vital organs. He wanted his capture in a whole lot of pain, didn't want to kill him to fast he wanted to enjoy it. Listening to the screams coming from the man in front of him, he moved to the other side pushing the knife in deep. He kept on doing it until Sam past out from the pain, cleaning the wounds making sure the bleeding stop before he left the room. His friends came back with lunch and he wanted Sam rested before he started some more, this time he'll used something else to deliver the pain.
Stepping back in he saw that Sam was just waking up from his last time with him, stepping up to him he cut the ropes from his wrist, ankles and chest. Going back to the table he pick up a hammer before turning around, seeing the horror in the man's face he smile at him.
Seeing the man walking up to him Sam got off the chair only to fall on the floor hard, he couldn't stop the scream from coming when he hit the concrete. Trying to get back up he felt a sharp blow to his left knee cap, hearing a pop he knew it's been dislocated breathing threw the pain as he laid on his side. Glancing up he saw Nathan standing over him with the hammer in his hand, he couldn't stop the blow that was coming to his damage knee. Feeling the hammer hitting hard to his knee cap not hard enough to break it, he scream from the pain that shoot through his leg before another blow hit on his leg. Looking up with pain filled eyes he saw Nathan kneeling down to him, once again asking the same question as before. Getting the same answer angered the hunter to no end, getting back up he went back to the table getting the cattle prongs. He step up to the men turning them on listening to him pleading not to do it, he smile wickedly when the first shock went through his body. He kept it up until Sam block out from the pain, only to start again when he woke up not giving him any time to rest.
