**This chapter is revised! Fixed some errors and added some new things!**
Sebastian's POV:
SebastianSmythe: So wait .. you called Brody to that hotel room and got Finn involved?
SantanaLopez: Yep! From what Finn told me, he beat up the guy and trashed the room too.
SebastianSmythe: Wow. When did Finn become such a badass?
SantanaLopez: I heard he kissed Mr. Schue's bride-to-be .. which is probably what triggered his anger.
SebastianSmythe: Holy! Why are there so many feuds?
SantanaLopez: Beats me. Anyway, I gotta go and try to apologize to Kurt and Rachel again.
SebastianSmythe: Good luck!
SantanaLopez signed off.
I stared at my computer re-reading our conversation. I thought the Warblers had it bad, but McKinley is going through a lot of trouble this week. They should at least be happy that they're going to Regionals ever since we were disqualified.
Do I regret giving into peer pressure? Yes. Do I regret making Hunter captain? Obviously. But it's okay. With his expulsion, I had become the captain again. I got rid of the nice version of me and became my old self again. The only person who really gets to see the soft side of me is Santana.
Speaking of Santana .. sigh. I miss her. I was glad to hear that she had moved to NYC, but I wish she could visit Lima more often. It's not the same without all the McKinley graduates here. I started thinking back to our Smooth Criminal duet.\
(Author's Note: This flashback is completely from the episode! It's all in italics)
*Flashback*
Santana walked into the room just as soon as The Warblers walked in. She was wearing a short black dress, black hat, black coat and black high heeled boots. If I wasn't gay, I would probably hook up with her right then and there.
"Hey Andrew McCarthy!" she yells out to me.
"Don't know if you've heard, but Blaine may lose an eye. The same Blaine who was just besties with most of you not four months ago" she tells us.
"Wait, are you serious? Is he going to be okay?" I hear Trent ask her.
"Well sure, if he doesn't mind seeing in three dimensions."
"Trent I got this" I said as I faced him.
I turned back to Santana. "Bummer, about Blaine. He was pretty. He shouldn't have gotten in the way though; that slushie was meant for Kurt" I tell her, smirking.
"You may look like the villain out of a cheesy 80s high school movie, but you should know that I'm fully prepared to go all Danny Larusso on your ass. Admit you put something in that slushie. What was it, huh? Glass? Asphalt?"
I tried to keep a straight face as the lie rolled out of my mouth. "Red dye number 6."
"You're a liar" Santana accused.
I pretended to look shocked. "She questioned my honor. I demand satisfaction in Warbler tradition."
"You want a duel," Santana asks me.
She turns to the Cello players. "Cello players, can you hang back for a second, I'm going to need you for this one."
I saw them nod and took their seats.
"Everyone else, clear out. I don't want you to see me make a girl cry" I said as I continued facing Santana, smirking.
"Let's just keep this on point." Santana walks away and takes a seat near the cello players.
The music starts. I stand by the chairs, staring at Santana. I started walking around, slowly making my way towards her.
Sebastian:
Uh, as he came into the window
It was the sound of a crescendo, uh!
He came into her apartment
He left the bloodstains on the carpet, uh!
I brushed my hand against her shoulder and quickly walked away, ignoring the sparks I had just felt.
She ran underneath the table
He could see she was unable
So she ran into the bedroom
She was struck down, It was her doom
Annie are you OK?
Santana:
So, Annie are you OK?
Sebastian:
Are you OK, Annie?
Santana:
Annie are you OK?
Sebastian:
So, Annie are you OK?
Santana:
Are you OK, Annie?
Sebastian:
Annie are you OK?
Santana:
So, Annie are you OK?
Sebastian:
Are you OK, Annie?
Santana:
Annie are you OK?
Sebastian:
So, Annie are you OK?
I felt Santana grab my blazer and tie, forcing me to turn around and face her. I lightly hit her head and started chasing her as if it was a game of cat and mouse.
Santana and Sebastian:
Are you OK, Annie?
Annie are you OK?
Would you tell us that you're OK (Sebastian: uh!)
There's a sign in the window
That he struck you - a crescendo Annie
I felt Santana brush her hand against my blazer, only to push me away. I felt my heart beating fast at that moment.
He came into your apartment
He left the bloodstains on the carpet (Sebastian: uh!)
And then you ran into the bedroom
You were struck down
It was your doom
Sebastian:
Annie are you OK?
Santana:
So, Annie are you OK?
Sebastian:
Are you OK Annie?
Santana:
Annie are you OK?
Sebastian:
So, Annie are you OK?
Santana:
Are you OK Annie?
Sebastian:
Annie are you OK?
I started checking her out as she started walking away from me. I couldn't help it, I'm a guy!
Santana:
So, Annie are you OK?
Santana and Sebastian:
Are you OK Annie?
Sebastian:
You've been hit by
Santana:
You've been hit by
Santana and Sebastian:
A Smooth Criminal
As the cellos kept playing, I saw Santana walk away from me. I started to do the same, mimicking her moves as we sang our next lines.
Santana (Sebastian):
I don't know! (Annie are you OK, will you tell us, that you're OK, there's a sign in the window)
I don't know! (That he struck you - a crescendo Annie)
I don't know! (He came into your apartment)
I don't know! (Left the bloodstains on the carpet)
I don't know why baby! (Then you ran into the bedroom)
I don't know! (You were struck down)
(It was your doom)
(with Santana: Annie!)
(Annie are you OK?)
Dang, gone it - Baby! (Will you tell us, that you're OK)
Dang, gone it - Baby! (There's a sign in the window)
Dang, gone it - baby! (That he struck you - A crescendo Annie)
Hoo! Hoo! (He came into your apartment)
Dang, gone it! (Left bloodstains on the carpet, uh!)
Hoo! Hoo! (Then you ran into the bedroom)
Dang gone it! (You were struck down)
(It was your doom - Annie!)
Sebastian:
You've been hit by
Sebastian and Santana:
You've been struck by
A Smooth Criminal
We ended up face to face. I threw the slushie in her face, and she was about to slap my face, I grabbed her hand and I suddenly leaned in to kiss her, and we ended up hooking up that day.
*end flashback*
I wish I hadn't thrown that slushie at her face that day. But at the time, I wasn't completely aware of the feelings I had for her. I was so into my thoughts that I didn't realize my phone was ringing. I checked my phone - it was Santana.
Sebastian: Hey what's going on?
Santana: um .. I ended up coming to Lima. Can I come over?
Sebastian: Yeah sure.
Santana: Okay. I'll be there in 10. I have to tell you something.
